• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Starfield | Review Thread

What scores do you think StarfieId will get?

  • 40-45%

    Votes: 3 0.5%
  • 45-50%

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 50-55%

    Votes: 1 0.2%
  • 55-60%

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 60-65%

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 65-70%

    Votes: 2 0.3%
  • 70-75%

    Votes: 5 0.8%
  • 75-80%

    Votes: 15 2.3%
  • 80-85%

    Votes: 81 12.5%
  • 85-90%

    Votes: 241 37.3%
  • 90-95%

    Votes: 243 37.6%
  • 95-100%

    Votes: 55 8.5%

  • Total voters
    646
  • Poll closed .

SmokedMeat

Gamer™
Sony and Nintendo don't need "influencers" to sell their console because their quality 1st party games sell themselves with good reviews and word of mouth.

On the other hand, MS needs to buy these people in order to compensate for the lack of games (and the lack of demand as a result). It's pretty pathetic.

No, never Sony.




I’m sure none of these celebrities got free PlayStations… Nope.

  • LeBron James
  • Jimmie Allen (country music star)
  • King Bach (actor and comedian)
  • Nigel Sylvester (BMX athlete)
  • NaLyssa Smith (WNBA All-Star Rookie)
  • Ja’Marr Chase (NFL star)
  • CeeDee Lamb (NFL star)
  • Liza Zimouche (French football freestyler)
  • Romelu Lukaku (Belgian football star)
  • Julio Cocielo (Brazilian content creator)
 

graywolf323

Member
No, never Sony.




I’m sure none of these celebrities got free PlayStations… Nope.

  • LeBron James
  • Jimmie Allen (country music star)
  • King Bach (actor and comedian)
  • Nigel Sylvester (BMX athlete)
  • NaLyssa Smith (WNBA All-Star Rookie)
  • Ja’Marr Chase (NFL star)
  • CeeDee Lamb (NFL star)
  • Liza Zimouche (French football freestyler)
  • Romelu Lukaku (Belgian football star)
  • Julio Cocielo (Brazilian content creator)
great now demonstrate how they go out there and evangelize the brand doing anything that remotely approaches the level of the Xbox influencers

crickets GIF
 


Dunno if anyone else already posted this, but absolute LOL. Bro is coping sea salt over the ban but even without it he'd be too scared to post 🤣

No, never Sony.




I’m sure none of these celebrities got free PlayStations… Nope.

  • LeBron James
  • Jimmie Allen (country music star)
  • King Bach (actor and comedian)
  • Nigel Sylvester (BMX athlete)
  • NaLyssa Smith (WNBA All-Star Rookie)
  • Ja’Marr Chase (NFL star)
  • CeeDee Lamb (NFL star)
  • Liza Zimouche (French football freestyler)
  • Romelu Lukaku (Belgian football star)
  • Julio Cocielo (Brazilian content creator)

Oh wow geez darn shucks darnit snap, you really got us there!

It's not like I can't tell the difference between an international celebrity obviously doing product placement, vs. no-name content creators who suck at acting trying to lie about a product given to them for free.

Nope. Virtually impossible to tell the difference /s.
 
Last edited:

Madflavor

Member


Dunno if anyone else already posted this, but absolute LOL. Bro is coping sea salt over the ban but even without it he'd be too scared to post 🤣



Oh wow geez darn shucks darnit snap, you really got us there!

It's not like I can't tell the difference between an international celebrity obviously doing product placement, vs. no-name content creators who suck at acting trying to lie about a product given to them for free.

Nope. Virtually impossible to tell the difference /s.


What a jabroni.
 

SmokedMeat

Gamer™
Oh wow geez darn shucks darnit snap, you really got us there!

It's not like I can't tell the difference between an international celebrity obviously doing product placement, vs. no-name content creators who suck at acting trying to lie about a product given to them for free.

Nope. Virtually impossible to tell the difference /s.

My comment wasn’t even to you, but you immediately felt the need to reply with “got us”.

Do you guys have ranks?
 
Maybe now they are, since they have an established business and it doesn't matter that much, but I bet they were much "nicer" 10-15 years ago when they were trying to get things going..

If xbox ever gets to that level of success, you won't see them being as aggressive.. there will be no need for it.

I'd like to believe you, but Microsoft are the only platform holder who's both written a bible blueprint for astroturfing, and has actually followed up on it. That plan was put into motion back in the early days of 360 console-side, even...well, maybe. I believe it was written and shared internally around the early 2000s.

If it's that ingrained into their corporate DNA in terms of marketing & messaging, I don't think a scenario where MS reaches PS or Nintendo levels of success would abate it. In fact, they'd probably ramp it up. Why stop a good thing if it's giving you net benefits?

If I were you and not eager to play I would wait a little longer until some updates improve the game
In November or later

Well I just found out my family member's GPU expired. Guess they are doing month-to-month. Now I'm gonna sound like some of the people in that ResetERA thread trying to find ways to game for a cheap sub.

Though since I've never actually subbed to Game Pass yet myself, I might be able to get some perk if I sub for GPU for the month. They did keep spamming me to try it out on Windows. Worst come to worst I'll just probably pick up a cheap 1-month offer and play it from there.

My comment wasn’t even to you, but you immediately felt the need to reply with “got us”.

Do you guys have ranks?

Actually, yes. Yes we do. I'm rank GAF Master Sergeant. Now drop and give me 20 (MS Reward points) 😁!
 

killatopak

Member
I'm glad some people are enjoying the game, but I think even those who are loving Starfield should call BGS out.
True and I’ve done my part.

I’ve been pretty consistent of this. Half of my posts in the RE4 Remake OT, Review and other threads was pretty much full of complaints and nitpicks yet it is my GOTY. That game scored 90+ but still wasn’t exempt from my criticism. I do it because I want the game to be better. Some can be personal or just general stuff but I do it because I don’t want them to be complacent and think this thing that I think sucks should be done on the sequel. Someone has to tell them or they’ll keep doing the same mistakes.

I still haven't been able to start the game yet so i have no personal opinion on it... but i find it pretty funny that we are over 100 pages on this game's review score alone with countless front page threads bickering about different aspects of the game and its engagement. Even if this game is a shitty 60% bottom dweller it still has succeeded in getting people to non stop think/talk about it this entire week and who knows for how long into the future. Already seeing some amazing mods/articles and stuff. Hopefully i can get around to playing it this weekend so i can see for myself. :)
Controversy breeds discussion. Prime example is Redfall. More pages than BG3, Hi Fi Rush and Sea of Stars combined.
 

Pimpbaa

Member
I ain’t losing my shit over 6 million players of this game, I like the game a lot, why would I? Lots of people like the game here, some might be losing their shit but not all. What an ass to generalize everyone here.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Last edited:

JTCx

Member


Dunno if anyone else already posted this, but absolute LOL. Bro is coping sea salt over the ban but even without it he'd be too scared to post 🤣



Oh wow geez darn shucks darnit snap, you really got us there!

It's not like I can't tell the difference between an international celebrity obviously doing product placement, vs. no-name content creators who suck at acting trying to lie about a product given to them for free.

Nope. Virtually impossible to tell the difference /s.

536.jpg
 

Heisenberg007

Gold Journalism
Looks like it’s currently 80% on Steam.
SteamDB is way more robust and faster at updating the data than Steam client.
Never messed with Steam Database, but it doesn’t update as quickly because Steam is currently showing 47,351 reviews total compared to 46,282 on Steam Database.

So Steam is the more accurate score with an extra 1,069 reviews accounted for.
Steamdb gets its data from Steam. So the numbers are the same across both platforms.

SmokedMeat SmokedMeat , the reason you're seeing different numbers on Steam is that it automatically applies filters by your preferred language. You've to remove filters every time you want to see the overall data. That's why Steamdb.info is the easiest way to find the data.

Otherwise, both platforms show the same numbers.

If I remove all the filters on Steam, it'll show me the same data as Steamdb.info -- barring a handful of reviews that are still being synced.

uqsnnZt.jpg
F9lekgi.jpg
 

acm2000

Member
10 hours in and it's a Bethesda RPG in space, Star Effect, exactly what I was expecting.

It's so easy to tell the people on here who are just shit posting about the game from just having watched it on twitch rather than playing it, it's embarrassing 😂

Don't understand people saying it feels laggy etc too, the controls are very responsive and tight for a 30fps title, once again they seem to be just shit posting from what they've read elsewhere, either that or they have some poor man's Chinese knock off TV with 200ms screen lag.

Solid 8/10 from me so far, could move to a 9/10 once I play the main quests more, could drop to a 7/10 if my adoring fan* doesn't stfu before I put a bullet in his skull.

(Yes my choice, I low key like the punishment of his whiney little voice)
 

3liteDragon

Member


Dunno if anyone else already posted this, but absolute LOL. Bro is coping sea salt over the ban but even without it he'd be too scared to post 🤣



Oh wow geez darn shucks darnit snap, you really got us there!

It's not like I can't tell the difference between an international celebrity obviously doing product placement, vs. no-name content creators who suck at acting trying to lie about a product given to them for free.

Nope. Virtually impossible to tell the difference /s.

retard-alert.gif
 

GHG

Member
DenchDeckard DenchDeckard if you don't mind, can I take a moment of your time.

A few days ago you summoned me to the Starfield OT:

Exactly what I said it would be. GHG GHG Must be seething. Once again, Steam proves to be the reviews we can trust.

Welcome to constellation everyone. We are going to be here for years.

And here was my subsequent response:

I love that you will ignore me when it's convenient for you to do so (for example when you're caught in your lies) but want to drag me into an OT for a game that I'm yet to play.

But I'll entertain you, for now. No reason for me to "seeth", they are indeed the only reviews that I deem to be trustworthy over periods of time. If it settles into a very positive rating then there's a higher chance that I'll give it a spin sooner rather than later (which should be a win for your employers, so don't get too upset).

That said, yet again you seem to be living your emotions. If it were anyone else I would caution you for doing this too early, but that wouldn't be any fun now would it?

If you want to continue this discussion feel free to do so in the review thread where it would be more appropriate.

Regretfully, I did not hear back from you (however, it must be said, this was expected).

Just a few days later the current situation is now as follows:

LILVHg2.jpg


I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on how the situation has evolved since your original post to me.
 
Last edited:

Heisenberg007

Gold Journalism
DenchDeckard DenchDeckard if you don't mind, can I take a moment of your time.

A few days ago you summoned me to the Starfield OT:



And here was my subsequent response:



Regretfully, I did not hear back from you (however, it must be said, this was expected).

Just a few days later the current situation is now as follows:

LILVHg2.jpg


I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on how the situation has evolved since your original post to me.
You should also update this one. 😛
 

Zheph

Member
I just finished it and I think "mostly positive" is what I would say as well. Just feels old but most things kinda work, decent scope tho
 

AntiCap

Member
The people who haven't played Starfield sure aren't in a rush to take it's name out of their mouths!
Some things, - such as earthquakes, train-wrecks and Starfield, - are simply worth talking about, whether or not one has had the misfortune of experiencing them.
 
Last edited:

Heisenberg007

Gold Journalism
And the main culprit pops up in no time. Keep going, maybe you’ll convince everyone! 😂
That's some weird victim complex, my friend - that the world is out to get you. Pointing fingers and blaming others because of that persecution complex is weird, to say the least.

Do you think that the 11,000+ negative reviews, and the overall 7.5 / 10 Steam user reviews, are also because of "the main culprits" on NeoGAF? Or are they real Steam users who perhaps didn't like the game enough after spending $70?

Why are you not even entertaining that possibility?

F9lekgi.jpg
 
Last edited:

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
So much time spent by people trying to convince other people that Starfield is a bad game 😂 Let it go
Actions have consqeuences.

People have shitting on exclusives for decades now so this behavior isn't even thing new. If people used games like Elden Ring to shit on Horizon Forbidden West then expect the game treatment for Starfield.

Many Xbox fans have used this game to make PS fans jealous and it was hyped as one of the games of the generation from many people online.

If the game is hyped up, then make sure it lives up to it because the review scores don't reflect it and it's obvious it was going to be used in console wars.
 
That's some weird victim complex, my friend - that the world is out to get you. Pointing fingers and blaming others because of that persecution complex is weird, to say the least.

Do you think that the 11,000+ negative reviews, and the overall 7.5 / 10 Steam user reviews, are also because of "the main culprits" on NeoGAF? Or are they real Steam users who perhaps didn't like the game enough after spending $70?

Why are you not even entertaining that possibility?

F9lekgi.jpg
No victim complex at all. I couldn’t care less if you don’t like it. What I wonder is, why you and a few others on this site expend so much time and effort trying to convince other people it’s a bad game? Honestly, why?
 
Actions have consqeuences.

People have shitting on exclusives for decades now so this behavior isn't even thing new. If people used games like Elden Ring to shit on Horizon Forbidden West then expect the game treatment for Starfield.

Many Xbox fans have used this game to make PS fans jealous and it was hyped as one of the games of the generation from many people online.

If the game is hyped up, then make sure it lives up to it because the review scores don't reflect it and it's obvious it was going to be used in console wars.
Ok, so it is a console war thing. Thanks for confirming
 

GHG

Member
And the main culprit pops up in no time. Keep going, maybe you’ll convince everyone! 😂

And here's where you're wrong, I don't need to convince anyone of anything. Better luck next time in attempting to drag me into some off topic crap in the OT:

I'm sure the really 'real' reviews are still to come.

And for the record, the real reviews have indeed been coming in for the game.
 

Chechack

Member
And the main culprit pops up in no time. Keep going, maybe you’ll convince everyone! 😂

Well if Starfield is really the game of all time and as good as people claim in to be it should not have to worry about few people talking bad about it in some random video forum right?

The game quality is good right and will still sell coz it wont be affected by some rambling of some obesecure random internet hater right on the net right? 🤷🏻‍♂️
 

Heisenberg007

Gold Journalism
No victim complex at all. I couldn’t care less if you don’t like it. What I wonder is, why you and a few others on this site expend so much time and effort trying to convince other people it’s a bad game? Honestly, why?
Who is convincing others not to like a game? This is just a projection. No one is doing that.

We are all only discussing the reviews of a game in that game's review thread. The fact that you keep thinking like that confirms what I said earlier -- it's just a baseless persecution complex that the world is out to get you.

Contrary to your claims about me, here is one of my comments to a person who was asking for thoughts on the game earlier.

So, what's the general consensus? Should i be excited for launch in a few hours. Because i am.
If you're excited, then you should remain excited. Give the game a fair go instead of being influenced by reviews -- unless you're paying for the game.

In that case, yes, please make an informed decision.
 
Top Bottom