Finished Tales from the Borderlands. I had a very good laugh out of this.
As far as rankings go, I'm a little undecided between best telltale game and second best. I think Walking Dead Season 1 edges out a bit because of the novelty at that time and Nostalgia bias.
So I would rank the tallTale games that I played like this:
1. Walking Dead Season 1
2. Tales from the Borderlands
3. Wolf among us.
4. Walking Dead Season 2
5. (Game of Thrones)
Incidentally I just finished Tales 10 minutes ago and it has to be the surprise of the year for me especially compared to my own expectations (aside from Dirt Rally being released out of the blue, and an updated Eastside Hockey Manager being released out of the blue, and...). I know it technically started last year but it's a 2015 release for me. When they announced Tales from the Borderlands, I just laughed at how the mighty have fallen so quickly (Telltale). What a completely stupid idea AND I have zero interest in Borderlands anything.
However, ever since the release of the first episode people have been saying it's legit. Like, actually really good but I only dove in after the recent Telltale bundle deal at Humble and boy am I glad I did. As for your rankings, I'm going to repeat that list. Tales really should be number 1 (!!!) but TWD1 did it all first and at the time, it was completely unique experience.
Now to look into this thing called Life is Strange, I might have heard about this game A FEW TIMES while reading these Steam threads...