Final Impressions of Prince of Stride: Alternative
Prince of stride is a show that downright baffles me. Before I begin to delve deep into its flaws I want to make note of who made this show (Which, btw, I'm using MAL for this info, so if I make a mistake I'm sorry). You have the director, Atsuko Ishizuka who has directed other series I have enjoyed (No game no life & Pet Girl of Sakurasou) and has been episode director of some very good stuff otherwise (baring some exceptions). You also have script and Series compostion by Tau Kishimoto who has done another sports anime that we all seem to love: Haikyuu!! (among other things, I just wanted to use this as a comparison point). Basically what I'm trying to say with all this is that this series was worked on by competent people, yet the end result has probably been the least competent sports anime I have ever experienced.
I've found that sports anime tend to fall under 2 categories. Using the sport as the central identity and conflict of the characters (Effectively, the "sports anime Formula") or using the sport as backdrop for whatever else is going on (like what Suzuka did). PoS falls under the former along with titles such as the aforementioned Haikyuu!! and Kuroko's Basketball.
Prince of Stride is textbook in what the formula is: start out with a semi kooky intro of the main characters that also signifies how they are serious players in the sport, assemble the team (many of which have issues which need resolving prior to starting back up), practice, play a few games, add some drama about how the characters play, maybe lose a game or 2, and then eventually they end up on top. But unlike Kuroko's basketball or Haikyuu!! its not interesting.
This is what I meant by Hybrid x Heart and this are similar. They use established formula to a T, and yet they don't work. Characters are one note or poorly utilized, the story is rather boring and never gives you enough to carry you along, the events feel pointless despite being told "they have weight", and the who's what's where's and why's are poorly rationalized, etc etc. The camera angles don't do any justice in races either. The jumps, flips, and action of parkour relay racing is rarely given the proper gravity it has. Races end up feeling boring and drag on. None of them really even matter until the last 2, and with the way the show handles the other races, you shouldn't care about any other than those last 2.
I want to get onto visuals before I go on to the good (and fucking frustrating) thing I have to say about this show. This show is visually UGLY. I understand what they were going for here: super high contrast to make colours pop and to give it a quazi-neon look to potentially make the running look cool. It doesn't work. Too many bright white-tones, and too many crushed colours. If just looking at the characters causes your eyes to hurt, then something has gone horribly wrong. This is where I want to compare the visual style of No game No life and this. They both go for high contrast, highly bright colours but No Game No Life also backs that up with interesting effects, dense imagery, and interesting visual design. PoS does NONE of that, but instead tries to go overly simple yet fails. It felt very much like someone tried to go for a stock anime style, normalized how the characters looked and then cranked the contrast to 11 and called the artstyle a day. It HURT watching this show, and that is NOT okay. I repeat: This show is visually UGLY.
Now onto the good of the show. Episode 11 is the only good thing about this show. It still has the horrid art style and some questionable texturing in the beginning of the episode, but it actually handles the sports anime formula rather well. I'd compare this episode to a race in Yowamushi Pedal (only condensed into a single episode, and not spanning a whole season). You get inter-monologing and that weird psychic "I'm talking to you through the sport" stuff we always see in sports anime. It has good verticality and interesting use of 3d for speed and perspective in places, and in makes you care about who is winning this race and why. It was a truly interesting episode (especially coming off 2 horribly dumb episode centered around forcing Riku to stop whining about how he can't be faster than his brother and a pool episode that was both worthless and offensively annoying). Episode 11, despite not being perfect, showed that this team had what it took to make an interesting sports anime, and just chose not to. That is so fucking frustrating to think about.
But then episode 12 happens and decides to blue-ball us by having the final race be only the last half of the episode and not showing us the end of the race, and only telling us the results on a mag. cover. Boo to that. They also try to sequel hook it with a "our story isn't over, its only just begun" bs statement even though there is nothing left to adapt.
That's basically what I thought about Prince of Stride. I think with shows like this and Hybrid x Heart, we really need to start looking at anime formula shows (such as action-ecchi or sports) and seeing why the good ones work while the bad ones don't.
Don't watch Prince of Stride (unless you're DTL; there's enough Yaoi baiting in there). Its not worth your time.