Bought this game at launch yesterday, but couldnt get to it before this evening. Have just completed world 1 (not 100%) and must say I am really happy with it so far. A few thoughts:
- Like everybody else, I really like the cat suit. I am actually surprised by this as I thought it was just another gimmick, but the way it changes exploration with the climbing is actually superfun.
- Liked the toad-level actually, it was an interesting change of pace
- Really liked the racing on dino-level. Hope there are more levels like this later with higher difficulty
- The bowser fight was much more fun than normal mario boss-fights
Most importantly though, I feel this is a brilliant evelution of the more linear level design that started in the Galaxy-games, and while it probably also looses something, it now feels even more like a plattform mario game. Both Mario 64 and Sunshine went more in the adventure-game genre with more puzzles, exploration etc, but Galaxy and even moreso this takes it back to precision-based plattforming which is what the series was all about from the start. Not to say I doesnt LOVE Mario 64 and Sunshine as well, but I think overall, the series is better in this direction.
There are some things I dont like though, I know the music gets a lot of praise, but so far, I feel its a bit repetitive, and nowhere near Galaxy-level. I also think the first few levels were a bit boring, but I guess that is to be expected in a game which is meant to reach out to everyone.