Game is awesome. Going to try to give some honest impressions just to counter the tide of hype (and there is some over-hypingevery game has flaws, even this one):
+ Startup screen looks sweet and the 1080p factor is definitely noticeable.
+ Waiting for Nintendo to get of their asses and come up with a decent story intro. As in still waiting.
+ New overworld style is rad. Not going to spoil it, but the changes vs. the Super Mario World formula are definitely keepers.
+ They get right to it with the cat suit. I'll just say this: I almost cried when I finally lost it two levels later.
+ Playing offense with the cat suit and thinking out of the box in terms of progressing through the level with the claws is a game-changer.
- Yes, I can see how some are calling it a port of a 3DS game. It's not fair, but there sure are some glaring similarities. So, although the combination of ideas is totally original, many of the individual mechanics I've seen before in various iterations throughout the Super Mario games of yore. Other than the cat suit, so far it still feels like playing an HD 3D Land, which isn't the worst thing ever.
- After playing Knack on PS4 for two hours right up to midnight, I had that sad feeling again. You know, that feeling the first time you played Twilight Princess after playing games like Oblivion. What's weird is, if I hadn't gotten the PS4, the graphics would probably be blowing me away, because they are at least a notch or two above anything on the PS3 or 360. But if you put 3D World head-to-head with Knack, just for things like particle effects and lighting and shaders and aliasing and all the other technical aspects that I'm not informed enough to elucidate, Nintendo can't compete with Sony. Not now, and not until they stop releasing consoles that don't have the horsepower of the latest PCs. It just makes me wonder what would happen if Nintendo stopped acting like Apple and allowed their games to be played on other consoles. How good would the PS4 port of Super Mario 3D World look? Like a Pixar movie, because that's how Knack looks for a good portion of the game . . .
->justJer's2cents<-