• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Super "NeoGAF Arcade Stick Thread" II TURBO

ban25

Member
Does anyone here have experience with Hori Kuro buttons? I'm most familiar with Sanwas, but I have one of the new Kais on order and it comes with the Kuros. I took to Google and read a dozen or so comparisons and it seems that the Kuros can have a sticking/squeaking issue. I was a click away from ordering some Sanwas but think I'm going to force myself to at least give the Kuros a fair shake before doing so. I do like the idea of them being more "tactile" feeling that some have mentioned.

Does anyone like the Kuros? Has anyone modded them (filing/etc.) to eliminate sticking/squeaking/etc?

EDIT: I'm really looking forward to trying the Hayabusa.

My impression of the kuros is that they are mushy and require more force to depress compared to the Sanwa OBSF-30s. The Kuro plungers also tend to wiggle a bit, which adds noise and occasionally throws off my execution.

I have both the HRAP4/PS4 and the original Fighting Edge, and interestingly enough, the Kuros in the FE actually feel quite a bit better (less mushy, less prone to wiggle) than the ones in the HRAP4. That said, I still prefer the OBSF-30s.

The Hayabusa level is fine, I actually prefer it over the JLF.
 

hitsugi

Member
Those of you that have used silent sanwa buttons - is there any difference in the feel between them and the standard sanwas? Might be a worthy investment for me..
 

Bar81

Member
Are these just drop in replacements for the buttons on the VLX and other HRAP sticks? Or is soldering required?
 

mdsfx

Member
Those of you that have used silent sanwa buttons - is there any difference in the feel between them and the standard sanwas? Might be a worthy investment for me..

They don't depress as far and feel every so slightly "squishy" at the bottom of the press, but I got used to them very quickly. It's all I use along with a silent jlf in both of my sticks.
 

ban25

Member
Those of you that have used silent sanwa buttons - is there any difference in the feel between them and the standard sanwas? Might be a worthy investment for me..

If you are picky like me, I would stay away from them because they are sure to feel at least slightly different. Arcade Shock has silent 30mm Sanwas in stock and I was considering picking them up before I found standard versions at akishop.
 
I can't wait for my two VLX Kuro PS3/PS4 sticks to come!! Super excited. I haven't kept a stick long term since the NES Advantage. I did dabble in the earlier Fightsticks and the HRAP4 though. I think these may be the two sticks to rule them all!! I was thinking of building a custom stand with matching aesthetics for my set of two sticks. How cool would that be :)

If the VLX Diamond is just polished steel could you not just strip the paint and polish the steel up to get the same effect on the new VLX Kuro PS3/PS4 sticks?

Also what extras should I buy for my new sticks?? I'm new to upgrading and I understand that replacing the buttons with Swana is popular - which ones do I ideally want (I love red) and any other upgrades to look out for?? I understand that new Hori joystick is very solid. Should I buy the bags? I can't find the link yet...

Are silent Swana or Hori parts worth it?

Oh and which online stores do I want to shop at? Just Arcade Shock??
 

hitsugi

Member
I'd be surprised if they're still taking pre-orders next week.

I'm kind of surprised they're still taking pre-orders now, actually.

If you are picky like me, I would stay away from them because they are sure to feel at least slightly different. Arcade Shock has silent 30mm Sanwas in stock and I was considering picking them up before I found standard versions at akishop.

Thanks, guess I'll go for the regular Sanwas then. I need that feeling.
 

Grifter

Member
So torn. I've wanted a VLX since checking out Hori's booth at Evo years back, just wasn't sure how I'd be able to haul it back from with me.

I'm not sure how I'd use it. Has anyone played with a VLX on their lap?
 

Skilletor

Member
So torn. I've wanted a VLX since checking out Hori's booth at Evo years back, just wasn't sure how I'd be able to haul it back from with me.

I'm not sure how I'd use it. Has anyone played with a VLX on their lap?

I do, but I'm 6'4, 250. Feels great to me.
 
Have not used an arcade stick since around 1995 but have a couple of very noobish questions...

Just got back into fighting games and pre ordered a Hori Kai because I have been told it makes the experience better.

Q: When I play mk9 on a 360 pad I have a bad time doing the "forward, forward" motion mid combo. I always seem to initiate a jump instead of a dash. Will an arcade stick help with precision of directional movement?

How about facilitating less mashing and more precise button pressing?

And yes I know, practice is the key to all of this.
 

ban25

Member
Q: When I play mk9 on a 360 pad I have a bad time doing the "forward, forward" motion mid combo. I always seem to initiate a jump instead of a dash. Will an arcade stick help with precision of directional movement?

How about facilitating less mashing and more precise button pressing?

The square gate on the Hayabusa will give you very precise directionals, so you shouldn't have any trouble accidentally hitting up. Given that there are no diagonals in MK inputs (that I recall, usually it's DF+P, etc), you should have a very good experience on it.

Some people prefer an Octagonal gate for SF and others, but there isn't one available for the Hayabusa without modding, as far as I know.

The buttons on an arcade stick require less force to activate and the layout permits you to rest your fingers across the buttons, so you should be able to improve your execution with a stick.

Note that if you are just making the transition from a pad, there's going to be a learning curve. I made the transition in the PS1 era (Namco Arcade Stick and Sega HSS-0136 FTW!), and it took several weeks to get back to where I was on a pad. Once you get to that point, you keep getting better, so the effort is worth it.
 
The square gate on the Hayabusa will give you very precise directionals, so you shouldn't have any trouble accidentally hitting up. Given that there are no diagonals in MK inputs (that I recall, usually it's DF+P, etc), you should have a very good experience on it.

Some people prefer an Octagonal gate for SF and others, but there isn't one available for the Hayabusa without modding, as far as I know.

The buttons on an arcade stick require less force to activate and the layout permits you to rest your fingers across the buttons, so you should be able to improve your execution with a stick.

Note that if you are just making the transition from a pad, there's going to be a learning curve. I made the transition in the PS1 era (Namco Arcade Stick and Sega HSS-0136 FTW!), and it took several weeks to get back to where I was on a pad. Once you get to that point, you keep getting better, so the effort is worth it.

Thank you very much for this
 

Fitts

Member
My impression of the kuros is that they are mushy and require more force to depress compared to the Sanwa OBSF-30s. The Kuro plungers also tend to wiggle a bit, which adds noise and occasionally throws off my execution.

I have both the HRAP4/PS4 and the original Fighting Edge, and interestingly enough, the Kuros in the FE actually feel quite a bit better (less mushy, less prone to wiggle) than the ones in the HRAP4. That said, I still prefer the OBSF-30s.

The Hayabusa level is fine, I actually prefer it over the JLF.

Thanks!

That bit about them feeling different between the HRAP and FE may account for the varying opinions that I'm finding. I guess I'm just going to have to find out for myself if they'll need to be replaced or not.
 

Yaari

Member
That VLX Kuro is absolutely stunning, but it will be 324 EUR to import one. Then probably 80 EUR on top of it for custom fees. So I guess I'll go with the RAP4 Kai instead.

Would have definitely considered the Kuro if it were to be sold within Europe but I don't want to do with the ridiculous costs on top of the stick itself.
 

ban25

Member
Thanks!

That bit about them feeling different between the HRAP and FE may account for the varying opinions that I'm finding. I guess I'm just going to have to find out for myself if they'll need to be replaced or not.

Yeah I recommend giving them a try before you order replacements. If you like the Kuros, you'll save yourself ~$30-40 on replacements and if not, you'll still be able to play on them while you wait.
 

FrankWza

Member
does the vlx have the same spacing as the kai? looks like only the fe has the same amount of space between the stick and buttons. is that right?
 
That VLX Kuro is absolutely stunning, but it will be 324 EUR to import one. Then probably 80 EUR on top of it for custom fees. So I guess I'll go with the RAP4 Kai instead.

Would have definitely considered the Kuro if it were to be sold within Europe but I don't want to do with the ridiculous costs on top of the stick itself.

Was the VLX diamond ever available in Europe? I'm holding out for a brushed steel version of the new VLX and because I don't want to spend $500+ on sticks right now. Hopefully I won't regret it.
 

Yaari

Member
Was the VLX diamond ever available in Europe? I'm holding out for a brushed steel version of the new VLX and because I don't want to spend $500+ on sticks right now. Hopefully I won't regret it.

Well, I'm new to this but according to what I've read it was never an option for the VLX releases.
 

TetsujinZ

Member
So torn. I've wanted a VLX since checking out Hori's booth at Evo years back, just wasn't sure how I'd be able to haul it back from with me.

I'm not sure how I'd use it. Has anyone played with a VLX on their lap?

I have the OG VLX and use it primarily on a table. Lap play is unwieldy for me, not only because of the size/weight, but also because of the wrist rest area (i.e., the slant on the front of the stick). That area is designed for your wrists to naturally slope downward when your hands are at the controls, but that doesn't work very well if the stick positioned low and close to the body, such as on the lap. You can mitigate this to an extent by pushing the stick out towards your knees, but then the stick gets a little harder to balance due to its weight.
 

ZeroX03

Banned
Could someone please give me insight on how to remove the wiring from the buttons on the USF4 TE2? I'm sweating bullets as I feel as though I'm going to rip out the wires. Any help would be greatly appreciated. MarkMan?
 

Skilletor

Member
Could someone please give me insight on how to remove the wiring from the buttons on the USF4 TE2? I'm sweating bullets as I feel as though I'm going to rip out the wires. Any help would be greatly appreciated. MarkMan?

There's a pushbutton on the quick disconnects. It was discussed earlier in the thread, but I can't find the post right now. I'm pretty sure I posted a link to an SRK thread about it, though.

Edit:

Here it is:

There's actually a button for the QDs to get them to slip off. I had the same problem.

http://forums.shoryuken.com/discussion/190326/official-usfiv-ggxrd-p4u-te2-thread/p10

(2nd post)

Noir layout da bes, btw.
 

Grifter

Member
I have the OG VLX and use it primarily on a table. Lap play is unwieldy for me, not only because of the size/weight, but also because of the wrist rest area (i.e., the slant on the front of the stick). That area is designed for your wrists to naturally slope downward when your hands are at the controls, but that doesn't work very well if the stick positioned low and close to the body, such as on the lap. You can mitigate this to an extent by pushing the stick out towards your knees, but then the stick gets a little harder to balance due to its weight.
That's exactly my concern. I've used sit-down cabs for fighters and this form is great at that height given the way the controls would protrude over my legs. This shape seems odd for other uses with the slope at the wrist-rest area, and the horizontal size makes it awkward for placement in a seated setup or even floor setup. Can't position it between my legs.

Don't get me wrong, I'm sure I'd love it, just gotta be discerning considering the cost.
 
I have the OG VLX and use it primarily on a table. Lap play is unwieldy for me, not only because of the size/weight, but also because of the wrist rest area (i.e., the slant on the front of the stick). That area is designed for your wrists to naturally slope downward when your hands are at the controls, but that doesn't work very well if the stick positioned low and close to the body, such as on the lap. You can mitigate this to an extent by pushing the stick out towards your knees, but then the stick gets a little harder to balance due to its weight.

I pretty much have the same sentiments. When I use my VLX on a table, it's my favorite to use. When I play it on my lap it's probably my least favorite. That's why I wouldn't take it to tournaments when I attended more often in the past. The weight and size is a pain in the ass, but it was the comfort level from the way you described it that was the biggest problem for me.
 

MarkMan

loves Arcade Sticks
Could someone please give me insight on how to remove the wiring from the buttons on the USF4 TE2? I'm sweating bullets as I feel as though I'm going to rip out the wires. Any help would be greatly appreciated. MarkMan?

Please refer to Skilletor's post! Let me know if there are any other questions.
 

MarkMan

loves Arcade Sticks
te_madcatz.jpg


This cool guy just celebrated it’s 6th birthday (Street Fighter IV & this product launched in Feb. of 2009). It helped create a legacy and new age within the fighting game community for Mad Catz​. This past weekend at Cannes Winter Clash, the winner of the Ultra Street Fighter​ IV tournament (Poongko, S. Korea) used the original SF4 Tournament Edition FightStick to claim victory. It’s been a wild ride. You ain’t seen nothing yet.

What's your favorite arcade stick related memory since SF4 launched?
 

Yes Boss!

Member
Favorite arcade stick related memory is seeing Hori first release the Taito style VLX and then actually grab the Taito/Vewlix branding for the second release of the DIA version (!!) Wish other companies chased the arcade official stuff as hardcore.

That and my EX-SE, which seems will never be topped, ever.
 

InfiniteNine

Rolling Girl
Are their any artwork mod supplies for the 4 Kai out anywhere yet? I'm looking forward to the stick but I like the other model's red top, so I think going custom here might be better for me.
 

Fitts

Member
Looks like the HRAP Kai's are out of stock now.

Glad I got in when the gettin' was good.

I'm going to stay cautiously optimistic, but it may have been oversold. We won't know until order updates start going out. Hopefully we'll receive notification today.
 

vg260

Member
Looks like the HRAP Kai's are out of stock now.

Glad I got in when the gettin' was good.

From my experience with Amazon with the buy button still active and no change in early pre-order shipping status, all that means is that it missed it's listed release date of today, which is not surprising. They could still very easily have enough in their initial allocation.
 

Chaos

Member
Not liking the look of the cord compartment door on the Kai at the top of the stick.
Heard it might be flimsy according to the HRAP Xbox one stick ?
 
Top Bottom