Personally, I am struggling in how making Tingle unique would work. In his game appearances, he can draw maps, has Balloon Fight balloons, can drop bombs, cook, dig, and hire bodyguards to fight for him. Granted, I'm sure that if you implemented him as a puppet master ala Rosalina, he could be interesting, or if he had some sort of Rupee-collecting mechanic. And that would make him incredibly complex. Plus, just from a basic moveset standpoint, I'm heavily struggling thinking of something for him. He'd have to get a Villager-like treatment, where he fights accidentally, because even in the one game he does fight in (Rosy Rupeeland), he's so pathetically weak that he gets completely bodied even by the very first enemies. And you don't see him actually fight, it's a cute little dust cloud like Prince Sablé's AT has, so there's nothing to draw moves from. But that would pretty much deter from Villager's fighting style being unique, either.