Switch 2 Pro Controller Felt Amazing… Until It Didn’t

The guy with the Youtube vid, I know he seems like a baby spreading FOMO with his hand in the cast/guard thing, but when I actually watched the video the other day, the case he made for why it happened made sense. Now we're seeing repeated occurrence. There might be something to it.

I was going to get one of these when people said the dpad was fixed, but now that I know it's not. This isn't something I'll ever have to worry about. I would be much happier sending Nintendo money and being able to turn on my Switch 2 from across the room, but first world problems.
The shitty d-pad is probably my biggest gripe about the controller. I also don't like how satiny smooth the concaved part of the sticks are.
 
I have put in a good amount of time on my S2 (and a lot of that time with Splatoon 3, so heavy gyro usage) and that pro controller is fucking sexy, I love it. I can see it vying for top controller of all time for me at this rate. So obviously no, I haven't had any issues that the OP described.
 
Well, just tried the Switch 1 Pro Controller for a few hours and zero pain or discomfort.

Then I tried the switch 2 pro controller, pain started coming back.

Switched back to the switch 1 pro controller, pain went away.

In my case, the difference in width and height made all the difference.

Glad the switch 1 pro controller works as good as I remember.
Even though I have no issue with the Pro 2 I am glad Nintendo still supported using the Pro 1 with the console for people like you that have these issues. It just really sucks that you can't wake the device out of sleep with the Pro 1 (unless that has changed), and Nintendo should really patch that.

Also sorry for the double post, just saw this comment after my first post.
 
Last edited:
4 days with the most amazing controller ever made so far (amazing sticks and grip buttons), I'm one day before it harms my hand and stops being that amazing
 
My biggest issue is the texture. At first it had this sort of rubbery grippy texture on it but it soon fades away and becomes SUPER SLIPPERY. I still enjoy the controller but I have to wonder what Nintendo was thinking with this coating. My DualSense Edge 'rubber' texture on the grips still feels amazing to this day and I've put that thing through hundreds of hours of use. My Switch 2 Pro controller is already slippery and feels like it slides around your hands. Factor in not having REAL paddles and instead having those little buttons where the paddles would have been, it makes pressing them a bit annoying cuz the controller moves around your hand too much so you never have the confidence to hit those buttons perfectly at all times.
 
IMG-6655.jpg
IMG-6654.jpg

Here's a comparison between both controllers. Maybe my hands are too big for the Pro 2 controller? My thumb reaches all the way on both so that's not the issue. I think maybe the smaller width and shorter grips are the culprits.
 
In case anyone is interested, I asked ChatGPT to compare my hand placement in both images for both controllers and here's what it said:
53XsJ8oaD3leiYgF.png

One great idea it suggested is to buy a Switch 2 Pro Controller grip to make it bigger and bulkier, that should help. I searched all over and looks like that doesn't exist yet, but the closest I found is this one on amazon, excited to see if that helps:
 
The tumbsticks feel too mushy to me for playing smash.

Idk how to say it but they don't have enough tension I think. The 8bitdo sticks do feel better
 
When I first got my Switch 2 and started playing with the new pro controller, I wasn't impressed. The only new feature is the GL/GR buttons, and I don't like them and will probably never ever use them. In general, it felt a little different and odd in my hands. I can't think of the word for the finish on the plastic, but it almost felt like it was covered by a layer of fine baby powder. Felt kinda slippery.

But all it took was some getting used to. After a few days the battery was out so I plugged it in and left to charge and went back to my old Switch 1 pro controller. Now that feels weird to me, I'm so used to the slippery new controller, the old one feels like it's covered in sticky sugar candy residue. (I took a wet wipe to it very thoroughly, it's not!)
 
Last edited:
I just got the pro controller and haven't tried it yet as I don't have my switch 2 yet but my first impressions are that it is a controller for ants
 
Top Bottom