Dechaios said:
Nah that's not true. Generally weapons aren't "better" than one another or else the game wouldn't be balanced. The alternate weapons are there so you can find your own preferences and playstyle, simple as that.
Are you about to tell me that the Minigun is "better" than the Tomislav?
Or that the Flamethrower is "better" than the Degreaser?
What about the Bonesaw compared to Ubersaw?
Scattergun compared to Force-a-nature?
Normal wrench "better" than Southern Hospitality?
And don't you dare try to say that the normal fireaxe for Pyro is "better" than the Axetinguisher.
You get my point; a lot of the added weapons give perks and qualities that the original weapons just fall short of. The vanilla loadout is no longer the superior loadout and I really don't think it ever was.
I've only just seen this post so my apologies for only being able to respond so late.
At the minute the Mini-gun still reigns supreme, have not been impressed with the Tomislav, I don't think I've necessarily lost a "duel" with a Heavy armed with it.
Largely, I think the updated Pyro and the Medic weapons have been probably been the best of the bunch. So can easily concede that point regarding the axetinguisher and the degreaser as well as the ubersaw.
The scattergun is a far superior gun to the F-A-N.
I think the Jag may be the best wrench for the Engineer.
If I were to play the game in a more competitive mood, I would probably stick with almost all of the stock weapons.
I usually fiddle about with the others simply to add a little variety not due to the fact that the weapons are "better".
I may have to also concede on the 90% figure. May drop to 75%.