Support NeoGAF

[Gbraga]

What isn't clicking for you? The combat? The quests?

I honestly don't know. It started when I saw a billion points of interest in the second area, but then I just decided to stop going after every single one of them, and my enjoyment hasn't really improved at all.

I decided to drop it from Death March to Easy to see if spamming a button just to get to the story segments would make me like it more, loaded my previous Death March save 10 minutes later, it was awful on lower difficulties, the combat is actually fun.

If I absolutely had to put my finger on the reason, perhaps doing many side quests for different people, and then when I finally decide to go back to the main quest, it's the same shit as any other sidequest, people asking me to do shit for them and telling me their whole life before I can get 5 minutes of relevant main quest info.

Even playing as Ciri, which I was very excited about, turned out to be awful imo, her gameplay is shallow as hell, it was absolutely boring, and the game didn't give a shit about my decisions.

Little girl: "Want to know why I'm here?"
Me: "No, shut up"
Moments later Ciri starts talking about it with her, as if I did ask her what happened. I DIDN'T KNOW AND I DIDN'T CARE, GAME PLS.

So if I understand it right, you enjoyed playing it when you were in White Orchid, but you couldn't enjoy it when the open world part starts in Velen?
If so, then just do some main quest and side quest if you can. Don't force yourself to explore everything if you don't want to.

Yeah, I guess I should follow your advice. I'm currently going through the Baron's quest. People seem really fond of it, so we'll see.

So far my favorite is the side quest

Spoiler

with the werewolf that killed his wife.

 

[Alucrid]

i should probably play some gwent right?

 

[His Majesty]

Turn PoI's off.

 

[Applesauce]

i should probably play some gwent right?

I was going to after I beat the game last night but apparently there are special cards you can win throughout the main quest that are unavailable now. So I'm going to just play a new game and focus on getting all the Gwent cards and roflstomping with an OP deck. Hope they add NG+ in the near future I don't really want to hunt for witcher gear again.

 

[VicDaMoan03]

So I'm over 10 hours in and haven't learned gwent, alchamy, or crafting. Am I going to be in trouble if I keep going on without these?

 

[Blade30]

I honestly don't know. It started when I saw a billion points of interest in the second area, but then I just decided to stop going after every single one of them, and my enjoyment hasn't really improved at all.

Turn off the POI, everyone else or many others like myself included turned it off and it made the gameplay (pacing) much better. I haven't done everything on my first playthrough and I don't think anyone should do it, since it would be too much (length) and a bit too dragged out, but I'll do it on my next playthrough when the expansions get released.

 

[Turin Turambar]

So I'm over 10 hours in and haven't learned gwent, alchamy, or crafting. Am I going to be in trouble if I keep going on without these?

It depends on the difficulty you are playing, and how you good are!

 

[UnluckyKate]

So I'm over 10 hours in and haven't learned gwent, alchamy, or crafting. Am I going to be in trouble if I keep going on without these?

No. Gwent is 100% optional. alchemy and crafting will definetly help you in combat to get better consumable and gear. But it's dead easy really : it show you what you need and if you have it or not so you can write it down and buy the stuff from vendors so don't worry.

But look into basic oil to fight monsters and potions. This game is about preparations and the use of potions, oils and bombs in battle. Not just swordplay

 

[aku:jiki]

If I absolutely had to put my finger on the reason, perhaps doing many side quests for different people, and then when I finally decide to go back to the main quest, it's the same shit as any other sidequest, people asking me to do shit for them and telling me their whole life before I can get 5 minutes of relevant main quest info.

Can tell you right there that this is not the game for you. In order for this game to reach its fullest potential, you have to be open to actually caring about fictional characters and their stories. If all you want is a quick bullet point checklist of the most important plot points, this isn't it.

So I'm over 10 hours in and haven't learned gwent, alchamy, or crafting. Am I going to be in trouble if I keep going on without these?

You didn't learn how to look at a list of ingredients and, if they're marked green, press the "make thing" button? These are not complex systems, man.

 

[His Majesty]

Turn off the POI, everyone else or many others like myself included turned it off and it made the gameplay (pacing) much better. I haven't done everything on my first playthrough and I don't think anyone should do it, since it would be too much (length) and a bit too dragged out, but I'll do it on my next playthrough when the expansions get released.

I think just hunting all the question marks would ruin the game for me. I turned them off right from the beginning and just stumbled organically upon a treasure chest or an abandoned village once in a time, feels much better. I don't think CDProjekt should have included the PoI markers in the game to be honest. You're missing out on a great experience if you take the shopping list approach to this game.

 

[Majukun]

so,where do i find the new cards?

 

[Gbraga]

I think just hunting all the question marks would ruin the game for me. I turned them off right from the beginning and just stumbled organically upon a treasure chest or an abandoned village once in a time, feels much better. I don't think CDProjekt should have included the PoI markers in the game to be honest. You're missing out on a great experience if you take the shopping list approach to this game.

Turn off the POI, everyone else or many others like myself included turned it off and it made the gameplay (pacing) much better. I haven't done everything on my first playthrough and I don't think anyone should do it, since it would be too much (length) and a bit too dragged out, but I'll do it on my next playthrough when the expansions get released.

Will do, thanks guys.

Can tell you right there that this is not the game for you. In order for this game to reach its fullest potential, you have to be open to actually caring about fictional characters and their stories. If all you want is a quick bullet point checklist of the most important plot points, this isn't it.

Perhaps... I wish you weren't right, but you probably are.

I cared about Keira, I care about Yen, Vesemir, Ciri, and especially Geralt himself, I even cared about that Witcher who was unfairly blamed for the kid's disappearance in White Orchard, but I really can't give two shits about the Baron or that woman from the tower side quest (what a shitty level design that quest had, Jesus. It was like moving inside a doll house)

 

[TheFatMan]

I think just hunting all the question marks would ruin the game for me. I turned them off right from the beginning and just stumbled organically upon a treasure chest or an abandoned village once in a time, feels much better. I don't think CDProjekt should have included the PoI markers in the game to be honest. You're missing out on a great experience if you take the shopping list approach to this game.

I did all of the ? in Velen/Novigrad after beating the main story and found myself getting tired of playing REALLY quick. I cannot stress enough that you should focus on main story and side story missions and don't spend all of your time in ? POIs. You know, unless your really into that kind of thing.

 

[Elsolar]

so,where do i find the new cards?

They aren't new cards, they're alternate skins for existing non-faction-specific cards. They can be enabled or disabled though the "Downloadable Content" section of the options menu.

 

[Data West]

2 hard crashes to the XMB within an hour of each other.

This shit's testing me at this point.

 

[Slixshot]

Started The Witcher this morning. This game is wonderful. You can see that these guys put so much thought into everything about the game. Love it!

 

[thequickandthedead]

Is the official strategy guide recommended?

 

[aku:jiki]

Wait, is the armor you get from completing Master Armorers randomized or did Yoana really just insult Geralt deeply by crafting a fucking Witch Hunter outfit for him? I really like her but I was about to murder her right there.

I think just hunting all the question marks would ruin the game for me. I turned them off right from the beginning and just stumbled organically upon a treasure chest or an abandoned village once in a time, feels much better. I don't think CDProjekt should have included the PoI markers in the game to be honest. You're missing out on a great experience if you take the shopping list approach to this game.

The thing with people praising turning off POIs is that those of you who did never noticed how much unmarked content the game actually has. You can have a fine exploration experience with them on, there's quite a bit of unmarked quests, chests and NPCs to find alongside the marked ones. Sure, the majority of the major stuff has a marker but there definitely is enough unmarked stuff to find to keep the player enticed.

The real bummer with the POIs is how lazy they got with them on Skellige. Fucking all of them are useless smuggler caches...

 

[Elysium-777]

I did, but

Spoiler

Menge got angry attacking me. No matter if I choose the treasure or Dandelion option, he always got angry.

Oh, in regards to Menge.

Spoiler

There is no way to resolve that peacefully. Either he attacks you during the conversation, or if you manage to get him friendly, Triss will kill him anyway two seconds later.

 

[Super Stardust]

Turn PoI's off.

This, they take away the excitement from exploring

 

[phaze]

Thanks, think I'm fine with just playing Witcher 2 then and skipping the first? It not having native controller support has me hesitant if I want to try with my MMO controller setup.

Yeah outside of introducing you to Witchers, Triss, Dandelion and Zoltan, the story there is self contained and mostly fan-fictiony anyway. Just watch the CG outro that introduces the plot of the second game.

 

[dreamfall]

New Gwent cards- MUST COLLECT THEM ALL!

 

[LonelyGreyWolf]

The guards of Novigrad are so useless. Murderers and bandits everywhere and they never even lift a finger, lol.

 

[Turin Turambar]

New Gwent cards- MUST COLLECT THEM ALL!

They are "skins".

I know:

 

[bonesmccoy]

High Stakes

Spoiler

doing it at level 15, seems I'm locked in. Hope there isn't more combat after fighting the elf, guessing there is though with Sasha looking to complicate things

1st match was really weird, the guy absolutely battered me, got his score above mine with me having used all my cards, then he did something that lowered his own score and caused me to win :s

First guy smashed me. Scorches, spies, hero cards. Thankfully the mission didn't end there. RESPEK.

 

[Anustart]

Does shadow play not work with this? I've tried a couple times to save some stuff but I get notta.

 

[Veritigo_X]

High Stakes

Spoiler

doing it at level 15, seems I'm locked in. Hope there isn't more combat after fighting the elf, guessing there is though with Sasha looking to complicate things

1st match was really weird, the guy absolutely battered me, got his score above mine with me having used all my cards, then he did something that lowered his own score and caused me to win :s

I completed that quest at a lower level than that actually. End of quest spoilers:

Spoiler

The combat is rough but it's definitely doable. You've got the fistfight with the half-elf and then an actual fight with a group of people later on. For that fight you should just avoid getting hit and have Sasha do all the work. She can easily handle them all.

 

[lordfuzzybutt]

Well after days of delaying the inevitable ending I finally finished the game tonight.

What a ride. What a damn ride.

Feeling a bit hollow right now.

Bed time I guess.

Wake me up when Witcher 4 is released.

 

[Regret Upon Approval]

Very late game clip of Ciri.

Spoiler

You can tell from all the dead enemies I was having fun with this part.

http://imgur.com/LsXa1Tt

Spoiler

Agreed it's a wonderful ending for Ciri and Geralt honestly. It's the truest expression of their devotion to each other, Ciri can finally be free and Geralt embraces her wishes and lets her go, the sword you give her being symbolic of that. It's a shame she never underwent the mutations though, I guess being of the elder blood she doesn't need them but I thought it would have been super cool for her to glance up out of her hood and have the witcher eyes.

Spoiler

The mutations have 30% survival rate. Sounds fun

Spoiler

I think it might be the closest to a canon ending, especially considering a potential Witcher 4.

Spoiler

Don't think she needs mutations. She is more powerful than Geralt already.

 

[LonelyGreyWolf]

Wake me up when Witcher 4 is released.

No need, 30 hours worth of expansion packs are coming.

 

[TraBuch]

Upgraded Igni is beastly, even on the hardest difficulty. The alternate version of it stunlocks pretty much every enemy I've come up against except for wraiths. And then when my stamina runs out, they're still burning and can't do anything while my stamina recharges to full and I can just use it again.

 

[Carbonox]

Those new cards just reinforce Yen is the GOAT. Just look at her. Don't care for Triss one bit but Yen is my bae.

On to the final missions of the game I think. Sad times. The last couple of set pieces were awesome. I NEED a Ciri game in the future. She's so much fun and probably my favourite female character of the generation so far along with Yen.

 

[abundant]

Upgraded Igni is beastly, even on the hardest difficulty. The alternate version of it stunlocks pretty much every enemy I've come up against except for wraiths. And then when my stamina runs out, they're still burning and can't do anything while my stamina recharges to full and I can just use it again.

This + Griffin Armor & Ability is OP. Anything that burns dies in seconds, no matter what level they are.

 

[Lrrr]

How are you all enjoying the game thus far?
Has the patch/update fixed a lot of the issues - like the XP one I heard about?

 

[CarbonFire]

Very late game clip of Ciri.

Spoiler

You can tell from all the dead enemies I was having fun with this part.

http://imgur.com/LsXa1Tt

That was their

Spoiler

HL2 march up the tower with the Amped Gravity gun

moment. And yes, it was glorious. Handing

Spoiler

Caranthir his ass as you out-teleport him

felt so good.

Honestly if we do eventually get a new Witcher game after Cyberpunk 2077, I'd much prefer a new protagonist and new side characters. Possibly in a different time period, either in the far past where witchers thrived, or far enough in the future where the world has changed (think RDR) and passed the lifespans of most of the current characters.

 

[Deleted member 80556]

Whoa, what the heck, the music volume on PS4 somehow got boosted, now I can barely hear dialogues.

 

[frontovik]

Not a fan of the new card designs, so I'm glad that there's an option to disable them.

 

[Papercuts]

Not a fan of the new card designs, so I'm glad that there's an option to disable them.

Is it pick and choose or does it force them all? I only would really want to use the new geralt one.

 

[Deleted member 80556]

Whoa, now I don't even have battle music, it just sticks to the ambient music. Arggh.

 

[Inferno313]

Just finished

Spoiler

The Battle of Kaer Morhan

Fuck man... :'(

But damn if that wasn't one of the most intense missions since ME2's finale.

 

[Tcab96]

Anyone have the White Raffard decoction? If so, how'd you get it? I'd like to get it before new game plus rolls around.

 

[Vulcano's assistant]

Did a patch just happen between yesterday and today? The whore tattoo from the Witcher 2 just appeared out of nowhere on Geralt's neck today.

 

[ebevan91]

Very late game clip of Ciri.

Spoiler

You can tell from all the dead enemies I was having fun with this part.

http://imgur.com/LsXa1Tt

Spoiler

As Ciri, I was roflstomping all of those Wild Hunt hounds and warriors. As Geralt, I was really struggling, then I realized all I had to do was just keep running *d'oh*.

 

[sjay1994]

I am the king of polish card games

 

[frontovik]

Is it pick and choose or does it force them all? I only would really want to use the new geralt one.

It's my understanding that that you can't be selective. So it is all or nothing.

 

[CHC]

I honestly don't know. It started when I saw a billion points of interest in the second area, but then I just decided to stop going after every single one of them, and my enjoyment hasn't really improved at all.

I decided to drop it from Death March to Easy to see if spamming a button just to get to the story segments would make me like it more, loaded my previous Death March save 10 minutes later, it was awful on lower difficulties, the combat is actually fun.

If I absolutely had to put my finger on the reason, perhaps doing many side quests for different people, and then when I finally decide to go back to the main quest, it's the same shit as any other sidequest, people asking me to do shit for them and telling me their whole life before I can get 5 minutes of relevant main quest info.

Honestly it sounds like you're just rushing and in the process doing yourself a disservice. It's summer, it's nice out, maybe this just isn't the right time for you to play this game. Maybe you have other things on your mind or other games you'd rather play right now? I don't know.

Anyway, I would suggest turning off the minimap, or at the very least the points of interest, clearing A LOT of time, and just... sinking into the game. If you're playing it just for the next story related reveal, you're going to hate it. There is a story and it is good, but there is a lot more to appreaciate than that.

Just try to play it like you're actually a Witcher, actually in the world, roaming around on horseback doing what needs to be done, while in the background you try to find time to resolve your own personal shit (the main story). It'll probably be a lot more enjoyable than feeling like you NEED to get through the main story and that everything else is "in the way" or is some kind of distraction. The game is more the story of the world and it's desperate inhabitants than it is about Geralt and Ciri. They happen to be the main characters, but they're really just a lens through which you explore these war-torn kingdoms and all the stories there.

 

[erawsd]

I think just hunting all the question marks would ruin the game for me. I turned them off right from the beginning and just stumbled organically upon a treasure chest or an abandoned village once in a time, feels much better. I don't think CDProjekt should have included the PoI markers in the game to be honest. You're missing out on a great experience if you take the shopping list approach to this game.

I agree, they really should have left those POI out and entirely up to player discovery just like the random "!" quests.

 

[LonelyGreyWolf]

Whoa, what the heck, the music volume on PS4 somehow got boosted, now I can barely hear dialogues.

Either a strange glitch or just something temporary with some certain dialogue? Never heard of that happening before. In either case, you can set music, sound effect and dialogue volume in the settings.

 

[Gbraga]

Honestly it sounds like you're just rushing and in the process doing yourself a disservice. It's summer, it's nice out, maybe this just isn't the right time for you to play this game. Maybe you have other things on your mind or other games you'd rather play right now? I don't know.

Anyway, I would suggest turning off the minimap, or at the very least the points of interest, clearing A LOT of time, and just... sinking into the game. If you're playing it just for the next story related reveal, you're going to hate it. There is a story and it is good, but there is a lot more to appreaciate than that.

Just try to play it like you're actually a Witcher, actually in the world, roaming around on horseback doing what needs to be done, while in the background you try to find time to resolve your own personal shit (the main story). It'll probably be a lot more enjoyable than feeling like you NEED to get through the main story and that everything else is "in the way" or is some kind of distraction. The game is more the story of the world and it's desperate inhabitants than it is about Geralt and Ciri. They happen to be the main characters, but they're really just a lens through which you explore these war-torn kingdoms and all the stories there.

I do get that, and it's a perfect way to describe my enjoyment from White Orchard, I let Vesemir sit on that tavern for hours and hours and I didn't really care about advancing the main quest, it's just that once you're bored with the game and forcing yourself to play it, you just want it to move forward as quickly as possible. I do agree with you that it isn't the "right way" to play the game, it's just that it's the only one I can force myself to right now. It's hard to get into the world when I just want it to be over, but maybe I'll take a break from it for a few more days, just watch some stuff on Netflix and never touch a game, or just play something else, because I absolutely agree that it's a disservice to myself to play it that way, who knows, maybe when I come back I'll enjoy it a lot more for no reason.

Might be a good chance for me to catch up with Life is Strange.

 

[Ahmad_742009]

Need help guys.

Spoiler

Count Reuven's Treeasure
I ran out of those antidotes Reuven gave me. How can I get some ?