Yes, they did. Maybe you should get a Backloggery account or something to keep track of your games?
Backloggery seems like it's just a website to track games you've played. I know I played it, and was fairly certain where I got it from. I need something that will allow me to redownload it easily if I wipe my system.
Found it, It's not in my gamefly website purchase history, I had to download the gamefly app, view my history in a certain way (has to be list view, others wont work) in order to download. Tempted to rebuy on Amazon just so it's easier to track.