• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

TikTok has shut down in the US (UP: TikTok is in the process of restoring service in the US)

od-chan

Member
As to be expected, there's some... interesting takes on reddit about all of this.
O0WYEK9.png
 

HoodWinked

Member
Ya not sure how this even works anymore. Cause the law went into effect and Trump isn't even president yet so he doesn't have the authority.

Only thing I can think of is that TikTok will operate illegally for today and pay whatever fee. And then will get an exec order for delay for in the coming days.
 
Last edited:

poppabk

Cheeks Spread for Digital Only Future
Ya not sure how this even works anymore. Cause the law went into effect and Trump isn't even president yet so he doesn't have the authority.

Only thing I can think of is that TikTok will operate illegally for today and pay whatever fee.
Think he told them he pinky swears not to cancel the fines once he gets into office.
 

ChuckeRearmed

Gold Member
What the hell? So THIS kinda shit is more important than fixing actual issues??? Minimum wage? Health care?
Minimum wage is a state issue, not the federal issue (for obvious reasons). And what about health care? It is already the biggest debt generator.

Ya not sure how this even works anymore. Cause the law went into effect and Trump isn't even president yet so he doesn't have the authority.
I think there was a legislation that allowed to extend the timeline for 90 days or something.
 
Last edited:
What the hell? So THIS kinda shit is more important than fixing actual issues??? Minimum wage? Health care?
I had a conversation about this shit with several friends of mine. I have NEVER seen such swift bipartisan government action to shut down a fucking social media app so fucking fast. And yet, no one gives a fuck about a minimum wage hike, healthcare, inflation, homelessness, etc. And YET, TikTok literally gets shut down!? Even those who want it banned are fucking using it. MAKE IT MAKE SENSE. All this talk about "CHINA HAS ALL THIS DATA" and not realizing, nor caring, that the US literally has 0 privacy laws/protections for it's citizens; Europe at least gives two shits with GDPR.

Yet, Facebook got a slap on the wrist with a $500k fine for the Cambridge Analytica shit; and Twitter now stating they can use your info for AI training without your consent. I am so fucking baffled.
 

od-chan

Member
I had a conversation about this shit with several friends of mine. I have NEVER seen such swift bipartisan government action to shut down a fucking social media app so fucking fast. And yet, no one gives a fuck about a minimum wage hike, healthcare, inflation, homelessness, etc. And YET, TikTok literally gets shut down!? Even those who want it banned are fucking using it. MAKE IT MAKE SENSE. All this talk about "CHINA HAS ALL THIS DATA" and not realizing, nor caring, that the US literally has 0 privacy laws/protections for it's citizens; Europe at least gives two shits with GDPR.

Yet, Facebook got a slap on the wrist with a $500k fine for the Cambridge Analytica shit; and Twitter now stating they can use your info for AI training without your consent. I am so fucking baffled.

I really mean no offense by this, but I'm amazed by some of the stuff I read on here. For some reason I assumed this was the kind of thing I would read on reddit or twitter and somehow surely gaf would be better, right? Really tells you more about me than about the people posting that.
 
There are other factors at play than money making here. China is actively making Western youth (including your daughters) dumber.


This is true, but banning Tik Tok or any other is the short-sighted answer to a deep problem that needs to be addressed with long-term societal actions.

People are becoming dumber with each passing year, losing their ability to focus and think critically. That starts in schools. It follows at home, with parents who don't encourage their kids to have a balanced life. I was lucky to grow up in the pre-internet era, I read a lot and discussed issues with actual friends instead of "followers".

Honest politicians, parents and teachers should start thinking seriously about youth, encourage them to grab a book (other than Harry Potter), and do activities that challenge their brains. Social media is the consequence of a bigger problem, not the cause.
 

Tams

Member
You're absolutely right. It's just anti-competitive under the guise of national security. Another example of this is back in 2020 Huawei for a brief period became the no. 1 cell phone maker in the world, yes even beating Samsung and Apple then suddenly they get banned. America will not allow any other country have any sort of influence over the world and these bans are proof of that.

Huawei literally had secret labs stealing IP and the UK foudn their coding in thwir network equipment to be shit (which itself is a security risk).
 

Tams

Member
Problem is, our apps (Facebook, IG, YouTube, Twitter, Threads) suck and their algorithms are even worse, plus those fuckers are probably selling my information anyway.

TikTok just…..works. It doesn’t show me anything I don’t want to see and keeps me in my lane. If the above apps actually did that maybe it wouldn’t be a big deal if TikTok was gone.


TikTok is like video Reddit. I only see and interact with my interests.

TikTok has been found to allow accounts to be created by underage people too, and then very quickly serving them up content such as self-harm and suicide.
 

Brigandier

Member
Cool now ban it in the UK too along with Snapchat and Facebook, Kids and young people in the UK are thick as pig shit and social media and dumb apps filled with these bullshitting influencers and "hack" videos brainwash people....
 
Last edited:
I don’t understand why people support decisions like this, which are made by a bunch of bureaucrats. The good thing is that they don’t understand technology very well, making it difficult to enforce such bans. Nowadays, we have VPNs and other tools to bypass these restrictions. Btw, I also don’t get why people use TikTok, but better be their decision than someone’s else.
 
Last edited:
I don’t understand why people support decisions like this, which are made by a bunch of bureaucrats. The good thing is that they don’t understand technology very well, making it difficult to enforce such bans. Nowadays, we have VPNs and other tools to bypass these restrictions. Btw, I also don’t get why people use TikTok, but better be their decision than someone’s else.
Ease of use, discoverability, etc.
 

ReBurn

Gold Member
I don’t understand why people support decisions like this, which are made by a bunch of bureaucrats. The good thing is that they don’t understand technology very well, making it difficult to enforce such bans. Nowadays, we have VPNs and other tools to bypass these restrictions. Btw, I also don’t get why people use TikTok, but better be their decision than someone’s else.
In this case the politicians seemed to understand the technology very well. VPN's won't help in the case of TikTok when the ban holds responsible the US-based app stores who distribute it and US-based companies like Oracle who provide the onshore network infrastructure. They probably can't do anything to Bytedance, but they can certainly penalize US-based partners until they refuse to work with them anymore.
 
Last edited:

Thaimasker

Member
Minimum wage is a state issue, not the federal issue (for obvious reasons). And what about health care? It is already the biggest debt generator.


I think there was a legislation that allowed to extend the timeline for 90 days or something.
What about Healthcare? The biggest scam in the u.s? The top Leaders on both sides say that it's trash and needs to be drastically changed but they'll not actually change it because health insurance companies are some of their biggest donors.
Top studies have shown The government wouldn't even need to put much more money into it, just get rid of the scam and we'll be in a much better place.

And that's not to mention trump plans to spend trillions of $ on other shit. It's not like we, the richest country are somehow the 1 country that can't afford it.

We have way more important issues to be solved than tiktok
 
Last edited:

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
What about Healthcare? The biggest scam in the u.s? The top Leaders on both sides say that it's trash and needs to be drastically changed but they'll not actually change it because health insurance companies are some of their biggest donors.
Top studies have shown The government wouldn't even need to put much more money into it, just get rid of the scam and we'll be in a much better place.

And that's not to mention trump plans to spend trillions of $ on other shit. It's not like we, the richest country are somehow the 1 country that can't afford it.
The US gov could make up tons of money if people got taxed more like in just about every other western or rich country. But the Us has pretty low income tax, goods/services state tax, capital gains tax, and the US is one of only a handful of countries that allow people to deduct mortgage interest expense of some sort.

The money is there. But the gov prefers people to hold onto more of their money instead pay a bit more tax to contribute to the greater good (like healthcare). Thats why the US is such a have and have not country compared to other places.

If the avg person (about 330M people) just paid a grand total of $100 more tax (however the federal or state gov wants to divide it out), that's $33B in tax revenue alone. $1,000 is $330B.
 
Last edited:

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
As to be expected, there's some... interesting takes on reddit about all of this.
O0WYEK9.png
This is basically how my conversation went with my female friend. Tiktok has latched on to bored housewives and feminists in a way even magazines couldn’t. They are being constantly brainwashed just like incels on twitter. But when i tell them that incel leaders like Andrew tate and fresh and fit were deplatformed as well. they don’t care. They turn to some other conspiracy theory about how America is exploiting its women in some kind of rape as a cottage industry or forcing them into being housewives or slaves to their male corporate managers.

No one is talking about this because women are untouchable when it comes to this discourse but the biggest damage done by tiktok is not to kids but women in their 30s and 40s. I’ve personally seen the toxic effects of this in my extended family and my friend is pretty much a left wing qnon now.
 
Last edited:

Cyberpunkd

Member
You're absolutely right. It's just anti-competitive under the guise of national security. Another example of this is back in 2020 Huawei for a brief period became the no. 1 cell phone maker in the world, yes even beating Samsung and Apple then suddenly they get banned. America will not allow any other country have any sort of influence over the world and these bans are proof of that.
Huawei got banned because it’s not a good idea your IT infrastructure is built and maintained by a company with links to the Chinese Army, just how naive can you be?
 

ChuckeRearmed

Gold Member
What about Healthcare? The biggest scam in the u.s? The top Leaders on both sides say that it's trash and needs to be drastically changed but they'll not actually change it because health insurance companies are some of their biggest donors.
Top studies have shown The government wouldn't even need to put much more money into it, just get rid of the scam and we'll be in a much better place.
They had the opportunity to repeal Obamacare but McCain - after years of campaigning against it - just blocked the repeal. Now it is close to impossible to fix it due to it being a politically suicidal topic ("he is taking away the health care!"). Obamacare created a huge regulatory barrier but there is no way out for a time being. But the chance to repeal it was 8 years. Not anymore.

????? I agree it should be a state issue, but there is certainly a Federal minimum wage which sets the floor.
No. The quality of life in each state is different so the federal minimum wage should not exist. It is similar to European union - you cannot enforce the minimum wage across regions/areas with different economy. It is just not good for business. For example in NL, the minimum monthly wage is 2k, while in Portugal it is 1k. Different countries with different economies. You can't enforce that with states either. States like California are much more expensive than for example Ohio.
 
Last edited:

No what? The Federal Minimum Wage exists. It sets the floor. It is absolutely a federal issue in terms of current legal conditions. There's no "no".



The quality of life in each state is different so the federal minimum wage should not exist.

Again, I agree with you, but it's not "a state issue".

It is similar to European union - you cannot enforce the minimum wage across regions/areas with different economy. It is just not good for business. For example in NL, the minimum monthly wage is 2k, while in Portugal it is 1k. Different countries with different economies. You can't enforce that with states either. States like California are much more expensive than for example Ohio.

Well, they are and they do. It is enforced in the United States. There are 15 States in the Union that are at the same level of the Federal Minimum Wage. Those states would likely have lower minimum wages if not for the Federal Government. Again, I agree with what you are saying - minimum wage absolutely should be an issue completely reserved for the states and the Federal Government should have no role. But they do. Not only do they have influence, but they are enforcing that with the States. No idea what you are talking about.


starting to feel like a stunt for Trump

All these social media companies all over his balls

Any day prior to that, Biden could have stolen the thunder. This gift was freely given, but now tears flow suggesting it was an elaborate trap. Ok. The social media companies are "all over his balls" because they opted to restrict first amendment rights, censor media and individuals, and promote lies for the past four years, including a senile sitting president. They want to attempt to avoid legal repercussion that is potentially coming. That's it.
 
Last edited:
Just because it exists, it does not mean it should exist that way.

Again, I agree. It shouldn't.

I assumed that you wanted to have a higher minimum wage right?

No. I do not want higher minimum wage for the sake of higher minimum wage. I prefer the market determine wages. Private interactions with employers and employees, it's not the government's business. Artificially inflating the minimum wage merely causes price increases across the board and reduces opportunity. Does setting the cost of food, fuel, or whatever it may be artificially low solve the issue of high price? No. Price/wage controls do not work as intended. Continuing to raise the minimum wage by decree simply reduces entry positions available for inexperienced and young workers.

My posts are merely refuting the idea that the Federal Government has no role (in the present legal environment), which it seemed from your posts that was what you were stating. Now it sounds like you are saying that you meant "they should not be involved". Not meaning to derail the thread or anything.

Let's start with changing it for restaurant workers, that have wage mandated at $1-2 per hour because of tips.

Sort of. Yes, the minimum for tipped wages is a little over $2.00. However, if tips + that wage do not exceed the "Federal Minimum", the employer must cover that gap. IE $7.25, or whatever number is arbitrarily set as the Federal Minimum. In other words, it's still the Federal Minimum Wage of $7.25 effectively. Typically, though, tipped employees exceed this number by a significant amount, but not in all cases.
 
Top Bottom