i finished GXP. now i long for death's sweet embrace. but here are a few thoughts:
1. I'm pretty sure Seiryo, the pink-haired dude, might have been the best thing about this show. Sure, his routine got kind of old at times, but his journey from GP instructor to pirate captain was somehow more interesting than whatever the fuck Seina was doing, and his voice actor was funny as hell.
2. This is not merely a shitty comedy, this is a shitty comedy trying to tell a story. There are episodes with barely any jokes at all, instead giving you huge exposition dumps that really aren't required and fumbling attempts at drama.
3. You can actually feel the material being stretched thin over 26 episodes. Jokes get repeated over and over again, plot progression is at a snail's pace, there's so many awkward, lingering shots to fill time. The show would still be generally unfunny, but it'd be a hell of a lot more tolerable at 13 episodes to cover the same amount of story. And maybe the animation wouldn't be garbage.
4. The big bad from one of the only good episodes of the show, Tarant Shank, disappears for like five episodes only to be defeated in two minutes in the prelude to Seina's return home to visit his parents. Then he comes back as a cyborg to be beaten by Seiryo of all people. Then the show expects us to take him seriously as a threat when he returns AGAIN to fight Seina when Seina pilots a giant robot. Then he ONCE AGAIN returns at Seina's wedding, where he is defeated in 30 seconds by Seina. Intentionally. I've never seen a show outright take a piss on someone they set up as final boss material, but god damn. I actually felt sorry for this guy.
5. When Seina goes to visit Tenchi, it just sort of highlights how bland his harem is by comparison. Tenchi gets all these women with crazy Sonic the Hedgehog hair and distinctive personalities, Seina gets Loud, Quiet, In Between, and Loli (though to be fair Loli actually stood out as a decent character design). I've also noticed what annoys me so much about his harem: they seem like they'd fucking die without him in their lives. The second-to-last episode actually pretty much supports this as they all mope around and cry, which is kinda disgusting to watch. Yeah, Tenchi's harem could be clingy and stuff, but they did seem largely independent.
6. This show actually tried to create drama by Seina questioning his Marry Them All ending with some weird internal thoughts about how all of them would be heartbroken. And then the lady in charge drags him over to see all the girls in their wedding dresses, basically says "This is a harem anime, you dumb fuck" and then they get married. After some girls kidnap and rape Seina.
7. This may be petty to nitpick the story of this show of all things, but it actually seems like it wants to be taken seriously at times. So, let's look at it this way: the space pirates kidnap the Designated Mascot and take him to their home base. Their home base is built on a planet where there just so happens to be a Gundam buried in a mountain. Only Seina is able to pilot this Gundam, which he uses to destroy the space pirates. Bull. Shit.