there is no sarcasm in my voice when I say that it is heartening that, in spite of most of our differences, all of Toronto-GAF can come together and declare with one voice that Tim Hudak is a complete douchnozzle when it comes to public policy and Lord help us if he ever comes into any position of any actual power in this province.
He's the best troll in Canada, bar none.
Here's the thing: the laws that were created with "public safety and revenue generation in mind" date back to 1930 and have been systematically and quietly repealed over the last 80 years because they were wacky and overbearing. Want to get alcohol? Hope you have your alcohol license. Bought too much this month? You're cut off by the province. It's taken this long to get to a system that's still inherently broken.
You also still harp on selection like you haven't experienced anything else. You do know that retailers will fill the gap when others won't, right? If the majority of convenience stores stock only the most popular beers, there will also be the stores that strive to be the haven for selection and will make bank based on that. The difference is that the choice is open to literally anyone, not just the government.
In regards to the government, I think the laws that are in place are pretty realistic for a first world country. Alcohol consumption is unfortunately (like it or not) a privilege. Vehicles, firearms, cigarettes, prescription drugs (to a lesser extent), etc, are all somewhat restricted in various ways, but not completely prohibited. I would love to be able to go to a convenience store and get a box of .223, shop around for some new AR's, update my driver's licence, and maybe pick up a prescription or two, but that just ain't going to happen. To that point, look at cannabis. I've heard anecdotes from a police officer that they would rather deal with someone who got high than a drunk. Yet that's still illegal, so yea the legal system isn't perfect. Bars/restaurants unfortunately have to deal with the laws too. The smart serve course I took was pretty eye opening in terms of social issues created by alcohol. Like I said before, I could argue either way on laws, but I would prefer the government err on the side of caution (and maybe generate some revenue to offset the social issues at the same time).
The issue of selection at retailers we could debate infinitely, I think. Increased selection wasn't exactly my experience in the US and Quebec, just larger cans. The current selection at the LCBO/Beer Store suits my needs pretty well. I wish every location was more consistent, but overall I think they do pretty well. You're correct that retailers would no doubt capitalize on the niche market, but I still can't decide about how the prices would fluctuate. The brewers may up their prices and buying power is of course important. Given my poor experiences across many different markets in Toronto, I would hazard a guess that the consumer would get the short end of the stick, at least in terms of price. Letting a free market dictate price isn't always the best course of action.