• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

UK PoliGAF: General election thread of LibCon Coalitionage

Status
Not open for further replies.

industrian

will gently cradle you as time slowly ticks away.
Manos: The Hans of Fate said:
He should go wacky and fire off the Tridents, then you can create new jobs to replace the old missiles. :)

And new jobs to clean up and rebuild the Tory constituencies that got hit! Win-win!
 

phisheep

NeoGAF's Chief Barrister
I expect a Con/Lib coalition, or at least some sort of arrangement. Can't see Libs entering coalition with Labour and retaining any honour - or credible plans for deficit reduction.
 

Mr Nash

square pies = communism
So I'm guessing England doesn't have a Single Transferable Vote system (though it seems Scotland and N. Ireland do)? Something like that would have probably helped the Liberal Democrats be better represented in parliament, though most politicians loath STV so the chances of it being implemented are slim and none.
 

Xavien

Member
gap between tories and Lab+Lib = 15

Mr Nash said:
So I'm guessing England doesn't have a Single Transferable Vote system (though it seems Scotland and N. Ireland do)? Something like that would have probably helped the Liberal Democrats be better represented in parliament, though most politicians loath STV so the chances of it being implemented are slim and none.

Yep, no STV. LD are for STV and if Lab can ally with LD, LD might be able to push for STV as its in both Labour and LD interests (as they hold 50+% of the popular vote together and they have quite an overlap in policy issues).

Ofcourse the Tories would never accept it and they'll lose any chance of gaining a majority ever again.
 

scotcheggz

Member
Mr Nash said:
So I'm guessing England doesn't have a Single Transferable Vote system (though it seems Scotland and N. Ireland do)? Something like that would have probably helped the Liberal Democrats be better represented in parliament, though most politicians loath STV so the chances of it being implemented are slim and none.

Spot on. This why any sane person wants a government that supports voting reform.
 

dakster

Neo Member
phisheep said:
I expect a Con/Lib coalition, or at least some sort of arrangement. Can't see Libs entering coalition with Labour and retaining any honour - or credible plans for deficit reduction.


I agree with this.




Christ I'm meant to be up in an hour and a half, need to get some sleep.
 

Varion

Member
Mr Nash said:
So I'm guessing England doesn't have a Single Transferable Vote system (though it seems Scotland and N. Ireland do)? Something like that would have probably helped the Liberal Democrats be better represented in parliament, though most politicians loath STV so the chances of it being implemented are slim and none.
Exactly. Wanting STV is one of the major reasons a lot of people in this thread voted Lib Dem.
 

dschalter

Member
Xavien said:
gap between tories and Lab+Lib = 15



Yep, no STV. LD are for STV and if Lab can ally with LD, LD might be able to push for STV as its in both Labour and LD interests (as they hold 50+% of the popular vote together and they have quite an overlap in policy issues).

Ofcourse the Tories would never accept it and they'll lose any chance of gaining a majority ever again.

Pointing out the gap is sort of silly though, because people vote for reasons other than ideology. If you tried to combine the two parties somehow you'd get a huge number of defectors (not saying it would happen, just saying the Lib+Lab combining to prove a point is silly).
 

Xavien

Member
phisheep said:
I expect a Con/Lib coalition, or at least some sort of arrangement. Can't see Libs entering coalition with Labour and retaining any honour - or credible plans for deficit reduction.

Would never happen, Tory would never agree to STV and LD wants STV so they can have a fair representation in parliament.
 

Withnail

Member
Does anybody else find the paving stones really patronising? I'm sure the only people watching now are political nerds who fully understand the situation.
 

Xavien

Member
dschalter said:
Pointing out the gap is sort of silly though, because people vote for reasons other than ideology. If you tried to combine the two parties somehow you'd get a huge number of defectors (not saying it would happen, just saying the Lib+Lab combining to prove a point is silly).

I was saying about a coalition parliament between labour and LD for the foreseeable future if STV was to be adopted. Not that Labour and LD would combine parties.
 

giga

Member
So I have no clue about the UK election system or politics. What’s going on or what’s going to happen? I hear stuff about Conservatives winning? I’m assuming these guys are “lite” Republicans?
 

industrian

will gently cradle you as time slowly ticks away.
giga said:
So I have no clue about the UK election system or politics. What’s going on or what’s going to happen? I hear stuff about Conservatives winning? I’m assuming these guys are “lite” Republicans?

Both the USA parties would probably be considered on equal footing with our Conservatives.
 

phisheep

NeoGAF's Chief Barrister
giga said:
So I have no clue about the UK election system or politics. What’s going on or what’s going to happen? I hear stuff about Conservatives winning? I’m assuming these guys are “lite” Republicans?

That's the common assumption, but in reality the Conservatives are pretty much equivalent to the Democrats and everyone else (in US terms) is pinko commie leftists.
 

defel

Member
There will be huge pressure from the labour base to step aside and let the tories/lib dems take power rather than surrender and accept a new voting system. If Labour accept a new voting system then we may get labour for another 5 years but we'll never get a labour majority again.
 

industrian

will gently cradle you as time slowly ticks away.
"Winning Labour candidate in Barking Margaret Hodge tells BNP to "get out and stay out" of the east London constituency, the BBC's Dominic Hurst reports. In her victory speech she says Labour has "smashed" the BNP's attempt to win there and calls it a victory over "fascist politics". The BNP came third and the Conservatives second."
 

sohois

Member
MY constituency still hasn't announced. It seems like the results have dried up for the rest of the seats as well, so i'm gonna go to bed finally.
 

Xavien

Member
defel1111 said:
There will be huge pressure from the labour base to step aside and let the tories/lib dems take power rather than surrender and accept a new voting system. If Labour accept a new voting system then we may get labour for another 5 years but we'll never get a labour majority again.

How'd you think that? Conservatives suffer under STV, not labour...?
 
phisheep said:
That's the common assumption, but in reality the Conservatives are pretty much equivalent to the Democrats and everyone else (in US terms) is pinko commie leftists.
Yeah, which is what makes it funny for most Americans watching, with a working knowledge of English politics, get the feeling that the General Election is sort of like a very active Democratic primary. :lol
 

defel

Member
Xavien said:
How'd you think that? Conservatives suffer under STV, not labour...?

Im not big on voting systems but afaik if labour accept PR then it will be the end of Labour AND the Tories as we know it.
 

industrian

will gently cradle you as time slowly ticks away.
I find it funny that I get the London news when watching on the BBC Website. Unless they've changed, the BBC Scotland woman is hot.
 

Varion

Member
"I'm afraid we've usurped your usual breakfast schedule because the election is so fascinating!"

It's okay Dimbleby, you can usurp my breakfast schedule any day.
 
defel1111 said:
There will be huge pressure from the labour base to step aside and let the tories/lib dems take power rather than surrender and accept a new voting system. If Labour accept a new voting system then we may get labour for another 5 years but we'll never get a labour majority again.

STV means we'll never get a Tory majority again and the Tory's don't snatch power in an election they looked nailed on to win. Most Labour party members would jump at the chance of that.
 

Xavien

Member
defel1111 said:
Im not big on voting systems but afaik if labour accept PR then it will be the end of Labour AND the Tories as we know it.

But the tories rely on large sums of money (they have more party funds than any other party in the UK) to push through in battleground seats, with STV that advantage mostly goes away.
 
Big Ass Ramp said:
Hi, I'm really clueless, but who is projected to be the prime minister after all of this?

I think technically in a hung parliament Gordon Brown stays on, but there are already rumblings that Labour will try and replace him in that situation as Nick Clegg won't make a coalition with him, but might if they have a new leader.
 

defel

Member
But arent Lib Dems pushing for PR not STV? Wouldnt that be more damaging for labour? I think im missing something.
 

industrian

will gently cradle you as time slowly ticks away.
Big Ass Ramp said:
Hi, I'm really clueless, but who is projected to be the prime minister after all of this?

David Cameron will have the mandate to declare himself Prime Minister it if the Tories have the most seats. Unless the Labour and Liberal Democrats can put forward a coalition that has 326 combined MPs then it's not happening for Gordon Brown or Nick Clegg.
 

Big-ass Ramp

hella bullets that's true
industrian said:
David Cameron will have the mandate to declare himself Prime Minister it if the Tories have the most seats. Unless the Labour and Liberal Democrats can put forward a coalition that has 326 combined MPs then it's not happening for Gordon Brown or Nick Clegg.

Hmm, ok, thank you very much.
 

industrian

will gently cradle you as time slowly ticks away.
This dude sounds like every breath he takes will be his last.

killer_clank said:
Surely Dimbleby will die soon?

He'll go into his incubation chamber after this for the next 5 years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom