But where do we draw the line at what is "brain dead" "dumb" or "Broken?"
Broken = has no counters outside of X-Factor
Brain Dead = advantageous if your plan succeeds or your plan fails on multiple levels, very difficult to fail with
I don't really use the term "dumb", so I have no definition there.
So to me, Tron's j.H is neither broken nor brain dead. I c.M'd Tron Bonne into oblivion throughout Vanilla. The only Tron I ever had problems with was Al_Rikir (he was at Canada Cup, top 8 I think with Tron), and that's because he's super good and actually uses her full toolset like j.L, j.S, and TK'd Bonne Strike.
She-Hulk I only had experience with when she was backed by Gustaff Fire, so I can't give an intelligent response about her. Gustaff Fire was likely the problem, and not She-Hulk. Her slide made me salty in Vanilla, but probably because I couldn't rush her down or do anything else (Vanilla Dormammu's keepaway was ass).
Vergil with extensive meter is borderline broken, but not quite because he's very susceptible to snap ins against opponents who don't get hit by Helm Breaker.
Here's what I would like removed from the game:
Spencer does Bionic Arm. I reaction block then decide to try to do Hyper Stars and Stripes. If I wait too long before I input the DP hyper, I get qcb hyper. Since Bionic Arm is so damn fast and since most Spencers do it when they're within 1/4 or 1/3 of the screen, my Hyper Stars and Stripes turns into Hyper Charging Star and I get hit plus lose the meter.
I don't know what it's called (move buffer?), but remove/reduce it please. No reason why I should be holding back, PAUSE/go to neutral, then do a full DP motion and still get qcb.
This definitely needs fixing. If you do qcf hyper and DHC into qcf hyper after resetting to neutral
and waiting half a second, you'll get a dp hyper. WAT?
Also, block with Dormammu, release 1D2C = oops I teleported on top of my opponent and died. FUCK. So tired of that happening, and I don't have time to make a HCB motion.
Why do you always pick on characters that I like? Leave Spencer, Dante, and Nova alone please.
Why do you like the characters with the most brain dead stuff? ;-) Except for Dante. I'm okay with Dante in his current form minus the bold cancel nonsense.