And yeah Jackman delivered a film score, by the book summer blockbuster. And even by those standards it's still unremarkable. There is nothing memorable from this score.
Let me make this comparison:
The Japanese restaurant I frequent has a dish called "Filet Mignon Sashimi".
It's simple, it's raw filet mignon cut slim, then pounded wafer-thin and then placed on a cold plate. It is then covered with a mixture of Ponzu Sauce, citrus juices and Sriracha. Now, to those uninitiated with oyster eating, it's a difficult pill to swallow. Out of let's say 10 of my friends, I would say that maybe 7 of them liked it when they tried it - the other 3 didn't and of those 3 that didn't care for it, they also dislike oysters because they tend to chew what they eat before they swallow it and the texture bothers them. For those that can get past the texture and enjoy all the flavors before swallowing, they can palate the morsel, masticate it once or twice while appreciating everything as a whole, then swallow the bite and momentarily have another. The mixture of the liquid on the raw meat chemically cures it within a matter of minutes to where it is edible and safe to eat; but that's just not something you can explain to the uninitiated.
That's much the same as music appreciation, because it is so different to the human ear between individuals as to what is great, what is amazing and what is mediocre.
The score to Uncharted 4 is amazing to me; it
literally made me feel as though I was playing a AAA, summer-blockbuster movie and the understated tones and the piano themes resounded within me and made me feel the emotional beats in a way that Edmondson could not.
But again, that's just my ear and also my opinion.