-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End |OT| You're gonna miss this ass
- Thread starter BaraSailey
- Start date
RespectThySole
Member
UC1: 7/10
UC2: 9.5/10
UC3: 7.5/10
UC4: 8/10
TLoU: 9/10
UC2: 9.5/10
UC3: 7.5/10
UC4: 8/10
TLoU: 9/10
Elitist1945
Member
I'd jump in on the ratings game, but I think they're all 10/10 so no diversity there.
Net_Wrecker
Member
I love the game but a 10 is something that starts strong, and finishes strong. Something I can return to over and over playing the entire experience without feeling bored or frustrated for lengthy periods. TLOU has a really slow opening 90 minutes to 2 hours before it becomes "OMG." I understand that it's setting the scene for what's to come, but these are just my super personal preferences. Similarly, UC2 has a really rough last few sections which is why I wouldn't rate that campaign a 10 either (my UC2 replays usually stop before the combat in Shambhala)
CrichtonKicks
Member
I adore the platforming in UC4. It's definitely not a challenge but I just find that the combination of movesets, animation blending, and the multiple pathways makes it a joy to control.
I would definitely agree with that. In terms of combat I think they nailed a lot of what they were attempting to do in UC3. And the story definitely seems like a bit of a do-over on what they were attempting to portray in UC3. Only this time they got it right.
It's funny- I know in some of the pre-release material people felt like they were glossing over UC3, presumably because it was made by a different team. But so many of the key elements of UC4 character arcs and revelations come directly out of UC3.
Honestly, Chapters 17-20 are the best
romance in a game IMO. And I think it's pretty incredible that it was done with a couple who are already married.
I'd agree with all of this.
It's odd because combat has finally become a highlight in an Uncharted game, but they finally decided to show some restraint when it comes to encounter rate. I felt like we got some really good encounter scenarios here. Some matching or being even better than those of UC2's.
I'd give UC4 a 10. But I agree with the rest. UC1 is awful.
SoraanTribal
Member
I agree with you. While I still probably prefer Uncharted 2 as an overall package, it's not leaps and bounds better than Uncharted 3. And there's certain things I prefer in UC3 over 2. I'm not finished with Uncharted 4 yet, so I don't know where it'll end up placing in my personal list, but as of right now, definitely preferred UC2 and 3 over this so far.
the_batman
Banned
UC2 had great pacing really. 3 was the game where a lot of people complained about it.
Almost mirrors my ratings. Brofist.
Ascenion
Member
Whoa now. Think about what you're saying here. I mean TLOU is damn good. You could've just written 15 or something. Saying that implies things, serious things, revolutionary things.
ViewtifulJC
Banned
UC1: 4/10
UC2: 7/10
UC3: 5/10
UC4: 8/10
TLOU: 10/10
UC2: 7/10
UC3: 5/10
UC4: 8/10
TLOU: 10/10
I agree, I had this same problem.
Like, Sam was free for two years and didn't even contract Nate, then when he finally does gives him this bullshit story to convince him to come risk his life and marriage for a treasure he doesn't care about anymore. Family or no, after 15 years of thinking he was dead I would have been a lot more pissed off. Though it is still a minor thing overall, and after nearly losing Sam again and their little heart to heart it is understandable to just let go and move on.
I don't know why people hate on UC1 so much. It is an older game so obviously the games following will have improved gameplay, but compared to other games at the time period I think it was damn good. And story wise it is my favourite of the first three.
UC2 definitely had better pacing than 3, and more interesting encounters overall, but I still enjoyed the 3rd one a lot. The set pieces were gorgeous and the chase scene on horseback was one of the funnest sequences imo, but I do agree that the villains in the 3rd were not nearly as good as in the 2nd, and the 3rd had the worst boss fight of all of them.
5 is average, dammit.
There is a large difference in quality between these to me, and the difference between an 8 and a 9 is not actually that big.
ComputerBlue
Member
UC1 - 8/10
UC2 - 10/10
UC3 - 9/10
UC4 - 8/10
TLOU - 10/10
UC2 - 10/10
UC3 - 9/10
UC4 - 8/10
TLOU - 10/10
the_batman
Banned
5 isn't average, 5 is an F. 7 is average.
A quote from one of his reviews. "The graphics are so good they're bad."
Damn, I thought I was being harsh on UC1 lol.
If I were to boil my problems with Uncharted 4 down to one point, it'd be that the game feels like it was designed without its core mechanics in mind. Almost every chapter is structured to fill in as much story and voicework as possible at the expense of everything else. It has action segments instead of action levels. What's most annoying is that the movement, shooting and stealth options are improved over the previous games, yet there's typically only a couple of minutes of combat for every 20-30 minutes of walking, climbing and cutscenes. People keep commenting on chapters 10 & 11 and that's because that's one of the rare parts of the game where you're actively playing it more than you are watching it and going through the motions.
MegaSackman
Member
Nice, now I understand that U2 >= U4 with basics statistics.
Here's mine:
U1 = 9 (at the time, now would be an 8 or less)
U2 = 10
U3 = 9.5
U4 = 10 (the best one for me)
*TLOU = 10
Here's mine:
U1 = 9 (at the time, now would be an 8 or less)
U2 = 10
U3 = 9.5
U4 = 10 (the best one for me)
*TLOU = 10
I'd love to see your ratings for 90% of other games if those are getting 4s and 5s.
Hehe, which is why I specifically asked for your opinions the other day. Brofist.
Ascenion
Member
This hearkens back to my comment about Uncharted 2 being the culmination of balance between Hennig and Druckmann while Uncharted 3 was Hennig unchecked and Uncharted 4 would likely be Druckmann unchecked. Funny now that if you combined 3 and 4 you'd probably get the greatness of 2 again.
Tinfoilhatsron
Banned
Seriously? 5 is the middle number on the scale from 1 to 10. Deal with it.
Unless you are being sarcastic.
potatohead
Member
I had more fun with it the second time, because I was just messing around. It really has some "oomph" to it, feels like what you think a 4x4 should feel like in a game (even though I don't think it's actually a 4x4 in the game, I think only rear-wheel XD).
I freaking wish....
I want them to add vehicles to the multiplayer too, but the way it is designed feels like there is just no room for them
I'd dig a racing DLC mini-game for sure....
Naw mang, I completely disagree.
They've really created a perfect arcade driving model here. They've made simulations of grip on multiple surfaces, that you can really feel easily, that's not so easy.
Winch was the weakest part I think. I sincerely suggest trying to play to the limits of what the car is capable of, just drive it all over the place, maybe it'll make a difference.
johnnydrama
Banned
Uncharted DF - Screen tearing/10
Uncharted 2 - Awful boss/10
Uncharted 3 - Biased British critics/10
The Last of Us - Ladders/10
Uncharted 4 - Gone Home/10
Uncharted 2 - Awful boss/10
Uncharted 3 - Biased British critics/10
The Last of Us - Ladders/10
Uncharted 4 - Gone Home/10
Translating a grading scale 1/1 with a review never made sense to me. 1-6 are never used, lol. What makes a game a 2 versus a 6?
Each number should mean something...when testing if you get a 50% you don't know half the material which is awful. They're harsher for a reason.
ViewtifulJC
Banned
4/10 is bad, 5/10 is just eh. I like to use the full scale when available. UC1 is damn near unplayable in 2016(and it wasnt that good in 2007 frankly), and UC3 strengths are mitigated by its many, many weaknesses.
other games I played this year for example:
XCOM 2: 9/10
Dark Souls 3: 8/10
Street Fighter V: 8/10(the core game...the product itself is terrible lol)
Uncharted 4: 8/10
Ratchet & Clank: 7/10
Doom: 7/10
Rise of the Tomb Raider PC: 7/10
Star Fox Zero: 7/10
Hyper Light Drifter: 7/10
Superhot!: 6/10
Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam: 6/10
Quantum Break: 5/10
the_batman
Banned
i'm going by percentages and how grades are given, so 5 out of 10 is 50 percent which is an F on a grade scale. 6 is a D, 7 is a C, 8 is a B, 9 is an A, and 10 is an A+
a game would be lower than 5 if it's worse than a dud, something that's broken or abysmal.
Well I think 4 is a better game than 2, so I disagree. I love the push for a more story driven Uncharted. Also, Amy didn't work on TLOU which is easily their best work. (imo)
With that said, I wouldn't have minded a couple more encounters because they were so well designed in this game.
Tinfoilhatsron
Banned
Grade scales vary by person and or site mate. Eurogamer will actually use the full scale. Ign seems to go by the A to F scale. So just translate his ratings into your own scale. Not that hard.
That's what I was thinking. If UC3 is a 5/10, I wonder what he'd give games like Army of Two, Straglehold, R.I.P.D, Rambo, Lost Planet 3, Scourge, Binary Domain, Kane & Lynch, Sam & Max, Bionic Commando, The Godfather etc.
Fair enough, I like to use the full scale too. Whatever scale you use 4 is basically terrible, which UC1 definitely is not in my opinion (even in 2016). It was considered a top tier game in 2007 :/
Exactly. Even if you don't like UC1/UC3 it's pretty clear they are quality productions, so 4 or 5 is harsh. Those games you mentioned would be like 1s and 3s in comparison if you really used the full scale.
the_batman
Banned
come on, UC1 isn't THAT bad..
Vire
Member
This is what GAF consensus will probably go down as by years end.
To me I'd say a game that's broken or abysmal should just be a 1. Like a game being broken in its core shouldn't get a random 4 or something.
This type of thing feels similar to why a game reviewer giving something a 7 is seen as 'bad' by many people, since the scale is never actually used lower than that properly. Just how I've always looked at it anyway.
OrbitalBeard
Member
I'd bump Uncharted 4 up to a 9, but damn, I completely agree otherwise.
It really is. Oddly enough, I've still played the thing three times, so even though I dislike it, I keep coming back because I love the characters.
Net_Wrecker
Member
Classic UC1 is probably more of a 4 or 5/10 in 2016, but the HD Collection version (definitive version) gets bumped to a 6 IMO. It's flawed but playable and the presentation of what Uncharted will be known as is already fully formed.
UC3 is more of a 4 or 5 though. I think I went soft on that one because we're still too close to UC4 and I'm experiencing the Zelda Effect right now. Come back to me in 3 months for untainted scores.
UC3 is more of a 4 or 5 though. I think I went soft on that one because we're still too close to UC4 and I'm experiencing the Zelda Effect right now. Come back to me in 3 months for untainted scores.
Similar threads
- Locked