Sorry my making my post so weighted towards one side.
I only mildly did weight lifting/training and most of my losses were purely from a dietary change.
I was eating 1600-1800 calories when I should have been on 2500+ (to maintain my weight) with light cardio and I was feeling awful AND not losing any weight.
So for me my experiences line up with what I currently believe now, which is that my metabolism just slowed slowed slowed to match what I was intaking irregardless of the fact I was doing some cardio.
I could be completely wrong on this premise (and perhaps the calorie deficit was too large at that time for me). But it was incredibly depressing to be eating less than usual and keep my weight with low energy.
Also my diet has never consisted of soda/fast food/carby snacks/candy in any quantity which made it even worse for me. Felt I was eating right, but looking back I was just eating too much food.
Sutton Dagger said:
I would also argue that developing muscle is essential to maintaining a healthy bodyweight. Weights are an important aspect of overall fitness, I can't imagine not doing my weight training.
I agree that having muscle on you is good. My point was just for fat loss diet is the larger factor. I think 'negligible' was the wrong word.
OG Kush said:
Exercise doesn't make you lose weight? What is this bullshit I'm reading here? It might not work as well as a really low-carb diet or something but hell yeah it still works!
The best thing to do is to have a combination of both diet and exercise. Exercise does increase metabolic rate and a good cardio workout can start burning through your fat supplies.
I agree. A good diet with activity is much better for
health.
Eric WK said:
Yeah, that's pretty much nonsense and one of the most bizarre things I've ever read. Yes, diet is much more important for the purpose of weight loss than exercise but you can not change your diet at all and increased activity will allow you to lose weight if you're at a caloric deficit. You can do one, the other or both - they all work just at different rates based on any number of variables.
I sort of lumped my response to this in my first post. I'm not an expert by any means and all I have to go on is my own experience (however improperly documented it may be), and what I read from sources I think might make sense. Sadly there is a ton of old/misinformation/snake oil salesmen on this topic.
I'm not telling you guys to stop lifting or exercising by any means.
This go around on keto I'm making sure to add in some light weight training with full body exercises and dumbells to make sure I feel great and strong, but not to help lose my weight.
5days in 5lbs lost. Drinking 6 cups+ water per day. Start seems like the same as I went around last time so I'm really glad. Was only lightly 'keto sick' for a day and I'm feeling clear headed and fine now.