teh_pwn said:
Hell, even I agree with a lot of this. Because of my initial postings in this thread focusing solely on carbohydrate and insulin I'm sort of recognized as the low carb guy. Now i see the insulin-carbohydrate hypothesis of fat gain as a subset of several things you can do to fix your metabolism.
To put it simply, I think obesity is a disorder of the metabolism. I think this revolves around the hypothalamus because it regulates both hunger and calories burned. Sure avoiding carbohydrate can improve insulin sensitivity, particularly the carbohydrate fructose. But I think exercise can as well, as well as improving gut flora, increasing omega3 fats, getting plenty of vitamin D, etc. It doesn't mean you can do P90X and drink Gatorade and expect to lose fat, but I think the improvements of insulin sensitivity from exercise allows more foods in the diet.
I think once people fix their metabolism, their body fat % setpoint is shifted back to a healthy 8-14% allowing a wider variety of "bad" foods. It takes time to damage it again to shift it back to become insulin/leptin resistant. That's why I think you can find tribes that eat mostly yams and fish, whereas someone that already has metabolic syndrome would gain fat in response to yams. Or a simpler example, why some people can drink soft drinks heavily and suddenly start gaining fat rapidly in their late teens/early 20s. It's like how Lustig talks about in "Sugar the bitter truth"...it's the chronic consumption of lots of fructose that does the damage, not acute.
I appreciate you posting this, and also agree with a lot of it. My body fat (according to naval method) is currently around 13% (from 25% when I was at my highest). My body just feels so much different now in terms of eating and the energy I get from food, even bad food.. and I have no doubt that is a result of my body producing insulin differently (less) as a result of my metabolism and body fat %. Though I also understand low carb works and is very good for people who have a really hard time with carbs not metabolizing well, and should be an option for them.
teh_pwn said:
Rubenov said:
Sugar alcohols man, how do they work? Should I count them or not? After some searching I still don't know what to do.
Personally I would count them. They may not induce as much of an insulin response as sugar, but they're known to cause digestive issues. Personally I'd avoid. If you need sweets, go with artificial or real stuff in moderation.
yeah, exactly.. as someone who is having a real hard time giving up diet soda (aspartame), stay away from sugar alcohols as much as freaking possible. Even with diet soda I feel 100 times better just drinking water... for me it's mainly the routine combined with the caffeine that is so hard for me to get rid of.
harSon said:
Does anyone know of an accurate 'Calorie intake/day to maintain/lose weight' calculator? Or does such a thing even exist? The one's I've used thus far have all had considerable differences results wise.
Doesn't exist without calories out. Also one thing I've learned in my year or so journey is that you have to look at your goals.. are you just looking to lose weight, or are you looking to lose fat. For example, in my 50lbs that I lost, I actually lost 21 pounds of lean body mass......
That was most definitely not my intent. I still have fat to lose (at 13% or so), but I have to approach it in a way right now that I'm NOT losing LBM also. It means looking less at the scale, and looking more at my body fat.
Ettenra said:
elrechazao said:
People tell me that too. They don't see me naked, let's just leave it there. If you still have fat deposits, the only way to lose them is lose more fat and build muscle. Don't let people tell you what you should be at...they're just used to seeing the fat you.
I'm dealing with this now too. Family members who spent years telling me to lose weight are now harping on me for continuing to lose weight. At 5''4' 155 I've still got a serious lovehandle problem, which is the most glaring attribute I wanted to correct so badly when I was obese. They'll all be singing a different tune when I'm done
Pretty sure everyone gets this. I went to my daughter's gymnastics practice the other day and one of her coaches said "OMG you look so SKINNY!" and I corrected her and said "I look fit!" I hate it when people comment saying skinny. To me skinny implies unhealthy and underweight.
But one thing.. well, for me at least that I've realized... is that probably about 5-10 pounds before I hit my goal I should have stopped telling people I still had 5-10 pounds to go.. again, what I wish I would have known earlier.. because it's not the weight you should care about (if you're looking at overall fitness). If you are 180lbs with 18% body fat, you have 147.6 pounds of lean body mass. That means you have 147.6 pounds at the bare minimum that you DON'T WANT TO LOWER. But here's the kicker.. say you've stayed 180 pounds, and now have 153 pounds of LBM. You now have only 15% body fat without "losing weight". You've still managed to turn 5 pounds of fat into 5 pounds of LBM and more than likely look significantly better (healthier, fit, etc).
I mean obese is obese, overweight is overweight, and most of us won't end up with the build of a pro wrestler or lean football player. But IMHO, once you start approaching the bottom portion of the "overweight" area of the BMI scale, you are much better in taking the focus off of overall pounds, and start shifting it to body fat percentage and keeping track of your lean body mass. a tape measure costs like 75¢ and while not perfect, the naval method takes like two seconds to figure out and is at least better than nothing.
I mean you are looking very fit more than likely, so to be honest, telling people that you still have weight to lose does seem kind of crazy. Yes Americans especially have a messed up view of what a healthy weight is (as evidenced by
this recent study), but if you are say 180lbs, you can still be in great shape and 180lbs or be in incredible shape only losing 5 more total pounds. Or be in great shape keeping your current say 147lbs of LBM and going to like 2% body fat. So avoid the uncomfortable nature of people telling you you'll be too skinny, and if you feel the need to tell them you're not done, just inform them that like "I'm still working on getting my body fat percentage down". Granted in america again, they'll probably still think you're crazy and that while you're at 18% they'll probably think you are only 8%........ :\ but at least then you'll know that they are ignorant (if they are) and you won't feel awkward about people calling you too skinny.. etc.