Youll have to settle for Maoyuu Maou Yuusha. Not a terrible consolation prize but not the same caliber. Demon king is a cutie anyway.
If that's what I have to settle, no thanks. The relationship in Spice And Wolf was great, the banter and evolution of their feelings for each other was absolutely brilliant.
In Maoyuu, we have unnecessarily large tits, paired with boob physics, and a squeeing fem mc trying too hard to be moe whenever she's near the protagonist.
Good thing the author wrote Log Horizon (at least if I recall correctly), because this show had good economics but I didn't like a single recurring character.
I want Spice And Wolf 3. I'll sell my soul for it.