Understood but maybe one of them decides that to take over the other they need those Xbox published games. Who does it hurt more Sony or Nintendo if the other platform does a deal with Xbox?
Mario / Zelda / Halo / cod / Skyrim and more on Nintendo via a gamepass would really have some people shifting console allegiance imho.
Honestly its not that it hurts the other platform because quite frankly it wouldnt. With or without gamepass the Xbox games would still come to both platforms. In this scenario the platform without gamepass makes more per sale of said xbox games than the platform with gamepass so it wouldn’t hurt anyone really.
As for Cod/ Halo/Mario/Zelda etc shifting ‘allegiances’ I dont agree. Much like how Xbox caters to a specific crowd,the same can be said for PS and NS. I honestly dont see Nintendo fans frothing at the mouth for COD or Halo and Skyrim didnt exactly set Nintendo platforms on fire when it was ported. The big kicker is Nintendo wouldnt change their sales policy,they release their games at whatever price and it stays there, they stick to their ethics and practices,can you really see them deciding to cannibalise their steady sales for a poor payout from Game Pass? Sorry but no…Its a ridiculous notion.
Granted bringing them all to PS would have a distinct impact, as in most who currently own a XSX would likely jump ship for the better exclusives plus access to their old Xbox library.
Only way Gamepass is hitting Nintendo platforms is if it only covers ‘Non-Switch’ games like say Cyberpunk and first party Xbox games.
For PS it would be even stricter,only Xbox first party stuff.
Sorry wall of text.