Why is Shenmue such a revered game (besides being one of the best looking games for its time on Deadcast)?
For me it's how real it all felt because of the way you could explore this world with so much detail in it. Plus stuff like having in-game passage of time where NPCs had their own schedules they followed, being able to talk to them. Kinda like Animal Crossing but with more gamey stuff like mysteries/puzzles to solve, action elements, and an over-arching narrative.