*UNMARKED SPOILERS ALL BOOKS* Game of Thrones |OT| - Season 4 - Sundays on HBO

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah. I thought the newest preview chapter was terrible. But probably not fair to judge it out of context.
 
So, I'm reading the first few chapters of book 1, and damn it's so different from the German version. German is such a clunky language lol.

Also, interesting tidbit, the German translation split the books into several ones. Like, AGOT is actually 2 books in German.
 
It's so nice to see so many with their number of posts per page settings set to 100.

PhoenixDark said:
There's no reason not to take it at face value, at least in regard to having a milk mother. If we are to believe Jon is Lyanna's child the obvious question becomes "how did Ned feed an infant during a horse ride from the Tower of Joy to Starfall." If Lyanna was pregnant she no doubt had a handmaiden (one or more), which is where Wylla must have come in.

Then there's the issue of Ashara jumping out the window. Did she do it due to Ned killing her brother? Or...did she do it because Ned told her the infant was his, thus causing love ridden Ashara Dayne to kill herself in grief?
Click to expand...

The midwife/wet nurse and milk brothers part is totally believable and Wylla being in that position for Lyanna (and in turn providing a cover story for Ned having an infant with him) is what I subscribe to. I like the theory that Ashara isn't actually dead and she's actually Septa Lemore.


todd360 said:
I really hate cat. I'm still salty that shes still alive (kinda).

Its mostly the way she treats Jon. I mean I can understand that hes a living symbol of Ned cheating on her (even though he probably didn't), but its not his fault. Its like she places the blame on Jon instead of Ned. He was trying to say goodbye to Bran in the first season and Cat is just like get the F out of here scum. Wtf is wrong with her.
Click to expand...

I don't know, she seems to be the jealous sort but I don't know if I'd blame her too much for hating Jon, I'm pretty sure most women wouldn't take too kindly of their husbands bringing back a baby he made with some other woman, even worse when he looks more like a Stark than any of her and Ned's kids besides Arya. I'm kind of hoping Cat finds out R+L=J, maybe even Stoneheart's heart would bleed a little. It seems she and Jon have some unfinished business.

Selner said:
Do think it's possible they will actually film parts of the the two seasons concurrently? With the younger actors aging, it might make sense. LIke they could flim the majority of Bran's scenes for both seasons.

That could possibly be why they asked for a two season renewel.

Hasn't it already been said the Martin has told the show folks how things end? In broad strokes anyway. So they are capable of finishing the TV show without the books.
Click to expand...

They're already apparently filming for six months out of the year, doing both seasons at once would probably be straining things quite a bit and possibly hurt the show creatively since they wouldn't have time to breathe and review. Plus there's weather/season issues.
 
Violater said:
Whelp see you in 4 or so years.
Click to expand...

Not quite. George R R martin said that he has finished writing the winds of winter. They are editing it now which can take a while and this started a couple of month ago.

Remember the AFOC and ADWD was written as one book but was edited into two. That is why the events in both books are occuring at the same time.
 
Red Arremer said:
So, I'm reading the first few chapters of book 1, and damn it's so different from the German version. German is such a clunky language lol.

Also, interesting tidbit, the German translation split the books into several ones. Like, AGOT is actually 2 books in German.
Click to expand...

I've also seen the English version of A Feast split in two volumes. I guess it just depends on the publisher.

I'm a member of Kindle master race. Incredibly better than carrying several pounds of paper around.
 
gspec said:
Not quite. George R R martin said that he has finished writing the winds of winter. They are editing it now which can take a while and this started a couple of month ago.

Remember the AFOC and ADWD was written as one book but was edited into two. That is why the events in both books are occuring at the same time.
Click to expand...
Did not know they were in editing phase...that is great news.
 
gspec said:
Not quite. George R R martin said that he has finished writing the winds of winter. They are editing the it now which can take a while and this started a couple of month ago.

Remember the AFOC and ADWD was written as one book but was edited into two. That is why the events in both books are occuring at the same time.
Click to expand...

He's said no such thing yet, he just talked about the manuscript and what he expected the unedited length to be. There was a lot more to AFfC and ADWD being made into two books than just editing, there wouldn't have been a six year gap between the two. The big issue IIRC was the whole "Meereenese Knot" business along with a lot of rewriting.
 
gspec said:
Not quite. George R R martin said that he has finished writing the winds of winter.
Click to expand...

2EaxFVq.gif
 
Red Arremer said:
Also, interesting tidbit, the German translation split the books into several ones. Like, AGOT is actually 2 books in German.
Click to expand...

ASOS and ADWD were both split in two for their paperback releases in the UK. Although I'm sure your instance was to do with getting a translation out in a timely manner, whereas ours was mainly that publishers like money.
 
Kerned said:
I doubt it. The producers have said that 10 episodes per season is the most they can do. I know that you are only talking about filming, but I have to imagine the extra work involved to do even that would strain their resources too much.

Besides, Bran will be a tree soon, so I don't think anyone is worried about Isaac looking too old. :)
Click to expand...
Yeah, all things totaled David and Dan work on a season for 11 and a half months. There simply isn't time to add more filming in the same year.
 
Hasphat'sAnts said:
Cornballer posting the warning after every page.

Such dedication.
Click to expand...

Yeah, even PM'ing people to play it safe and just stick to the book thread. I still feel more in tune with the show watchers, but I don't want to inadvertently post anything, so I'll just stick to lurking that thread. But Cornballer doing a solid job with these threads, the walking dead thread etc.
 
Altazor said:
I still can't believe how people don't realize this is the unmarked spoilers thread. It's in CAPS in the damn thread title and there are HUGE RED LETTERS AT THE TOP OF EACH PAGE INFORMING PEOPLE THIS IS THE UNMARKED SPOILERS THREAD.

I know it's a bit rant-ish, but you really can't complain when there's little margin for error.
Click to expand...

In that guys defence, the top post saying 'BOOK SPOILERS' also says 'Jon Snow is dead'.
 
gspec said:
Not quite. George R R martin said that he has finished writing the winds of winter. They are editing it now which can take a while and this started a couple of month ago.

Remember the AFOC and ADWD was written as one book but was edited into two. That is why the events in both books are occuring at the same time.
Click to expand...
Link?
Source?

BTW just broke down and read a preview chapter soo goood.gif
 
RedShift said:
In that guys defence, the top post saying 'BOOK SPOILERS' also says 'Jon Snow is dead'.
Click to expand...

yeah, I know. It was a very unfortunate first-post, I have to say... but still, it wasn't the first case in this very same thread. In any case, that spoiler isn't necessarily true... or is it?
 
RedShift said:
In that guys defence, the top post saying 'BOOK SPOILERS' also says 'Jon Snow is dead'.
Click to expand...

I dunno, the titles are drastically different this season. You have to read over *UNMARKED SPOILERS ALL BOOKS* before you even see Game of Thrones on this thread, while GoT shows up first in the no spoiler thread. The threads required a closer look to distinguish last year, not so much this year. If anyone is that worried about spoilers, they should be able to take the 1/2 a second to see if it says unmarked spoilers in caps first or game of thrones first.

NekoFever said:
Guys, let's just pretend that TWOW is finished and see how good it feels.
Click to expand...

It will only feel good until you realize it won't be out for a long time and then it will feel worse than before.
 
PHOENIXZERO said:
He's said no such thing yet, he just talked about the manuscript and what he expected the unedited length to be. There was a lot more to AFfC and ADWD being made into two books than just editing, there wouldn't have been a six year gap between the two. The big issue IIRC was the whole "Meereenese Knot" business along with a lot of rewriting.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I think you are correct. I must have misunderstood or was just very hopeful. But I thought he said that it was content completed with some rewriting and editing being needed.
 
Morrigan Targaryen said:
Jaqen did have the colour treatment but it was very subtle. I'm glad they don't use flamboyant blue hair either though. What might be interesting on paper can look goofy on screen.


I think I missed something... what happened?
Click to expand...

Just blue would've looked silly but I'm sure if they really wanted to do it they could've done it in a way to make it not look goofy. IMO a midnight blue with his already dark hair could've worked without being overly campy/cheesy and it'd be subtle enough to where it's not distractingly goofy.
 
gspec said:
Yeah, I think you are correct. I must have misunderstood or was just very hopeful. But I thought he said that it was content completed with some rewriting and editing being needed.
Click to expand...

I think everyone wishes the book was in the editing phase. =\ Hopefully it makes it out by late next year.

EDIT: D'oh, I meant to edit this into my last post and I guess there's no delete post option... Oh well.
 
gspec said:
Sorry. This may be where i got my info and got confused or very hopeful.

http://www.idigitaltimes.com/articl...-winter-release-date-update-george-martin.htm
Click to expand...

That was never confirmed, and Martin and Elio confirmed a couple weeks ago that TWOW was not finished. However Martin had a BBC interview today where he said he was "well into TWOW; can't link now.

Also his publisher was telling bloggers at Comic Con last year that 2015 is the window for TWOW. I'd be very surprised if it doesn't come out next year. His schedule is empty for most of the early months, and there's really no time for him to miss this deadline. TWOW content could presumably be in next season (Bran).

Summer or fall 2015, imo.
 
PhoenixDark said:
That was never confirmed, and Martin and Elio confirmed a couple weeks ago that TWOW was not finished. However Martin had a BBC interview today where he said he was "well into TWOW; can't link now.

Also his publisher was telling bloggers at Comic Con last year that 2015 is the window for TWOW. I'd be very surprised if it doesn't come out next year. His schedule is empty for most of the early months, and there's really no time for him to miss this deadline. TWOW content could presumably be in next season (Bran).

Summer or fall 2015, imo.
Click to expand...

Is he writing (adding content) or editing? This is the question. He keeps saying that he has a manuscript of 1000 or more pages. If this is true then he is editing it.
 
NekoFever said:
ASOS and ADWD were both split in two for their paperback releases in the UK. Although I'm sure your instance was to do with getting a translation out in a timely manner, whereas ours was mainly that publishers like money.
Click to expand...

Here all 5 books have been split into 2 books each. So the German version has 10 books, really. They also have titles that completely deviate from the originals - only Storm of Swords (pt1) and Dance with Dragons (pt2) have been directly translated. The other parts have been named differently ("The Queen of the Dragons" for ASOS pt2 and "The Son of the Griffin" for ADWD pt1). AGOT for instance was split into, translating the titles back into English, "The Lords of Winterfell" and "The Legacy of Winterfell".

Also, not the translation was the issue. Well, I guess it sorta is, but it isn't a matter of the time. German readers are used to translations taking time, and they're still fairly swift (we usually get a translation within 3-6 months depending on the author).

There's a few curiosities about the German book publishing industry, though. The one that affects our books as opposed to other countries' directly is that the paper is significantly thicker and better quality (even with paperbacks). That makes books already thicker by nature.

Additionally, German is a very extensive language - we capitalize every noun, which makes texts naturally longer, the grammar is longer, and many words also are longer by nature. That's also why so many German translations of games are shitty - we have to make due with the text boxes/cutscenes (if dubbed), and with such an elaborate language, it just is bloated.

It doesn't surprise me the books were split apart, but it just was a bit difficult for me getting back into the lore with the show, especially since I never read some of the books in their entirety that way (aside from missing ADWD entirely).
 
Randdalf said:
I actually posted some extrapolating earlier in the thread. I think at the current rate, TWOW needs to be ready by season 7, but I would hope it be ready much earlier.
Click to expand...
Thanks. I was looking for your post earlier, but I couldn't find it:
Randdalf said:
Just for fun I expanded that chart (roughly, I just copy pasted Storm) with AFFC and ADWD added and by drawing a line of best fit through the points found that at the current rate they're progressing through the story TWOW will start almost exactly with the first episode of season 7. I think it's more likely to be half of season 6 and all of season 7, but you never know. Plus, some stories have been moved really far forward (Bran).
Click to expand...
 
Randdalf said:
I actually posted some extrapolating earlier in the thread. I think at the current rate, TWOW needs to be ready by season 7, but I would hope it be ready much earlier.
Click to expand...

Season 4 is the end of 3 and a lot of books 4 and 5 will be lumped in. There is no way they make it through season 5 and 6 on just books 4 and 5. I don't think there is enough good material to justify it.
 
demosthenes said:
Season 4 is the end of 3 and a lot of books 4 and 5 will be lumped in. There is no way they make it through season 5 and 6 on just books 4 and 5. I don't think there is enough good material to justify it.
Click to expand...

I agree. There is no way that we won't be firmly into TWoW territory by season 6. The show is surpassing the books, it is known.
 
**** WARNING! **** HERE BE SPOILED DRAGONS AND BOOKS! ****

I am actually arguing with a bookthumper about this very matter as we speak. He is absolutely convinced that the show will have at least 10 seasons, and doesn't believe me if I'm telling him that if they draw stuff out for the sake of making the show last longer (and GRRM catching up in writing), the viewership will plummet by the millions they gained.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

George R R Martin developing multiple sequel projects to A Game of Thrones for HBO
2
65
814
BennyBlanco replied
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms trailer (Game of Thrones spinoff)
44
859
Shubh_C63 replied
Picard Season 2 Sucked.... BUT.... (ENDING SEASON SPOILERS AHEAD)
13
469
Avid Reading Horse replied
Game of Thrones getting a new spinoff: A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. Premieres January.
2
93
1K
BennyBlanco replied
INVINCIBLE Season 4 teaser, coming March 2026
5
300
Lightbreak replied
Top Bottom