A WMD that creates life to destroy life is indeed a pretty retarded concept.
you know what i realised, its probarly not intended but still funny, if you look at the androids in the alien series:
(A)sh, (B)ishop, (C)all, (D)avid
Well it's not as simple as that though is it. It's creating life that - it they do know what they're doing - is a highly mutated form of predator that was breeded specifically to destroy lite. So the purpose behind the specific creation of this life is because it's much more effective at destruction than anyone else is.
Just posted this in the other thread, but I'll stick it here as well as its easier to discuss and get some thoughts. This is basically how I think they should have done it at the moment.
I think the scope was there but they made a classic mistake in how they addressed the themes, which was trying to be too literal and too clever.
The origin of man is where all the problems open up, similar to BSG it was unneccessary and just requires so many leaps of logic to sustain the 'plan'.
They could still have explored God vs. his creation issues by keeping us and the Engineers separate. We created David, the Engineers have the ability to create new life by rapid mutations and are fascinated by different species. Space biologists, researching and collecting species, and they could have kept their form exactly the same as Alien.
The xenomorph was the result of them finding us long ago and taking some of us for the collection, which would explain the cave paintings. Unleashing a species which was more powerful than its creator and ultimately ends with their destruction.
We then go looking for what we once saw as a God and unknowingly make it all happen again.
So in the end there'll be a pack of rabid dogs (and whales), angry violent humans with exploding heads and a bunch of xenomorphs. Okay, sure, you've pretty much destroyed mankind as we know it, but what's the point with a planet that's even more hostile and filled with creatures even harder to kill? Are they planning to use this in a civil war against other Engineers? How will they take over the conquered regions? Develop a new virus?Well it's not as simple as that though is it. It's creating life that - it they do know what they're doing - is a highly mutated form of predator that was breeded specifically to destroy lite. So the purpose behind the specific creation of this life is because it's much more effective at destruction than anyone else is.
So in the end there'll be a pack of rabid dogs (and whales), angry violent humans with exploding heads and a bunch of xenomorphs. Okay, sure, you've pretty much destroyed mankind as we know it, but what's the point with a planet that's even more hostile and filled with creatures even harder to kill? Are they planning to use this in a civil war against other Engineers? How will they take over the conquered regions? Develop a new virus?
Kind of reminds me of that Simpsons episode. You know, let's release snakes to eat up the eggs, and then let's release snake eating gorilla's to eat the snakes. And then, I don't know anymore.
So in the end there'll be a pack of rabid dogs (and whales), angry violent humans with exploding heads and a bunch of xenomorphs. Okay, sure, you've pretty much destroyed mankind as we know it, but what's the point with a planet that's even more hostile and filled with creatures even harder to kill? Are they planning to use this in a civil war against other Engineers? How will they take over the conquered regions? Develop a new virus?
Kind of reminds me of that Simpsons episode. You know, let's release snakes to eat up the eggs, and then let's release snake eating gorilla's to eat the snakes. And then, I don't know anymore.
Am I the only one who is really looking forward to the sequel simply because it will be about only two characters? The two best characters.
A space adventure with Shaw and David. It's going to be so great.
Makes you wonder though why they were apparently planning (over millions and millions of years) to use humans, their own DNA match, as testing species. If it's against far-removed, different lifeforms, then why test your virus against yourself?Maybe a war against other life forms In other parts of the galaxy and maybe beyond.
Thoughts
.
Eh, my expectations for the movie were too high.
It wasn't bad movie in anyway but it just wasn't great either. Maybe I was expecting more of another claustrophobia, dark and gritty space horror film, this wasn't one![]()
I dont see the problems you guys mentioning that it is a build up for a sequal... why is there a problem with that? Can't you enjoy the movie without getting every answer?
Yes exactly. As you say, the foundations for something truly excellent are there.This is almost completely representative of how I felt about the film. I think I liked it more than you, but the extraneous dialogue with the Scottish doctor, the dialogue of the two co-pilots, the overbearing music, they're the three things I criticised immediately coming out of the cinema.
What's so frustrating to me is that I think I - and a number of you - could take the shooting script and turn it into something fantastic. I'd do something like I said a few posts above, just a few lines explaining different motivations, changing the appearance of the actual Engineers but still having the humanoid figures, taking out dialogue where it's unnecessary, taking out the Shaw as a child sequence... There's the foundations of a magnificent movie there.
- The Engineer ship flying off at the end was a little much. Am I right in understanding that is ostensibly Shaw and David flying off into space?
Oh c'mon he can instruct herAnd owing to the fact that its just David's head flying the fucking thing... what is he using his mouth on the steering wheel? I can already hear the cheesy sequel taglines. "When you're lost in space... sometimes you need a little head... The adventures of Shaw and David-Head continue"
1. Millions of years.Has this idea been brought up?:
Opening sequence Engineer seeds life on earth as part of a research process. That scene is the moment where the engineers for the first time succeed in creating life. The fact that he kills himself is odd, but could be chalked down to ceremony or that the goo would need DNA/building blocks to start with. At this point in history, they aren't trying to weaponize the goo. They're just trying to create life from scratch (like geneticists are doing now).
Earth = proof of concept.
Fast forward thousands of years. They've had time to perfect their genetics-skills to the point where they can weaponize it. Or they've known how to do it for ages, but only now have they found a reason to weaponize. And what better place to test it than their first proof of concept site? At this point they are unsure of how it works, and the reason they're sending it to earth is that they know that it's dangerous and don't want to test it on their home planet or somewhere it might spread. Earth around year zero is a perfect place, no interstellar travel, DNA is similar to their own etc.
And owing to the fact that its just David's head flying the fucking thing... what is he using his mouth on the steering wheel? I can already hear the cheesy sequel taglines. "When you're lost in space... sometimes you need a little head... The adventures of Shaw and David-Head continue"
Shrike_Priest said:Opening sequence Engineer seeds life on earth as part of a research process. That scene is the moment where the engineers for the first time succeed in creating life. The fact that he kills himself is odd, but could be chalked down to ceremony or that the goo would need DNA/building blocks to start with. At this point in history, they aren't trying to weaponize the goo. They're just trying to create life from scratch (like geneticists are doing now).
Haha, it did have a bit of Lollipop Chainsaw about it. I was referring more to the time it took them to seemingly get to another ship. It was like 'drive off into the distance, hit another launch pad, fly off' in about 10 seconds. Given how long it took them to get into the bowels of the first ship it seemed a little, I don't know.. off? Even if they ran straight there, Shaw is nursing an injury (apparently) and it's also possible that the other ships had Engineers in cryo in close proximity to the flight controls. I guess the whole crew wasn't exactly worried about any ramifications in the first place.. why stop now?
Also, I can imagine David using Shaw to 'fix himself' at a certain point, but that does seem a little far-fetched.
I still enjoyed it anyway. More questions than answers, but questions I would like answered nonetheless.
2. Why the star map and cave drawings?
I think it's a great concept that it's a big trap, but it implies that:I loved the theory that certain humans were imbued with the starmap location and that reaching it was the end of our evolutionary cycle which is why the engineers wanted to exterminate us. Very nega-Kubrick. It was a travesty how the film didn't discuss the relevancy or origin of the starmap
I haven't stopped thinking about the film since I saw it. It's a good sign.
I'm still really confused about this film's score. As others have mentioned, the main theme is really uplifting and seems to have come from a completely different type of movie.
Right from the opening sequence it just didn't fit at all. Replace it with something like Alien, Shining or 2001 and you have a completely different and more thematically relevant feeling when that title appears.
I remember thinking the same thing in the sequence where David switches on the nav-computer / star map. Switch out the music for something more fitting there and you'd have an incredibly effective scene. What's so uplifting? What I'm seeing is pretty damn sinister!
Negates what we see at the start.
I predict the alienverse has some original master race who's origin actually has a start point but we will never find out.
Id like to know more about the enginners but i doubt that will ever happen.
but what about the first engineer?
Possibly, it did give the impression of a weapon hold but that was also because it was mirroring the birthing chamber. Although creating a load of xenomorphs on Earth is a little pointless unless it was an elaborate test, wiping out what they created (even though they planned to do it 2000 years ago before we even had space travel) or just wanted a place to go on xenomorph safari. They'd shown that ship was not equipped to transport a load of them anywhere, or that the Engineers were capable of dealing with them.
A better theory I think is the plan was to round up humans onto the ship, infect them later in the new birthing chamber and then release them somewhere.
I think it's a great concept that it's a big trap, but it implies that:
1. They were already planning to kill us tens of thousands of years ago. Why didn't they do their WMD tests then?
2. They were seemingly going to kill us 2000 years ago, before we reached interstellar travel.
3. In the event that we do reach the target destination, as a fail-safe device, they were hoping that we would take these super-volatile canisters of black goo back home and then poison ourselves with it.
The WMD theory is what is suggested by the characters in the film, and it's the most obvious concept to explain the film, but when you get down to it, it's inconsistent and non-nonsensical. Either it's a red herring, or the writers simply got very messy with their script and changed their minds from time to time.
Egyptians and Incans weren't mature enough?1. Just because? I dunno, maybe they required matured humanoid lifeforms? I still think they wanted to harvest the surviving Xenos once Earth was overrun.
Imagine what would happen if a xenomorph got infected with the goo...would something even more violent and deadly be created?
I'm still really confused about this film's score. As others have mentioned, the main theme is really uplifting and seems to have come from a completely different type of movie.
Right from the opening sequence it just didn't fit at all. Replace it with something like Alien, Shining or 2001 and you have a completely different and more thematically relevant feeling when that title appears.
I remember thinking the same thing in the sequence where David switches on the nav-computer / star map. Switch out the music for something more fitting there and you'd have an incredibly effective scene. What's so uplifting? What I'm seeing is pretty damn sinister!
I loved watching the film but my god it's a huge mess. Crosby Stills and Nash accordion, magic Zelda computer flute, "hey sweetie" cobra penis, post-cesarean nonchalance...list is endless.