• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

2012 NBA Offseason |OT3| The Barclays Center is covered in rust

Blackace

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
giri said:
Except for bron to do what makes him "great" he needs to dominate the ball all game. Essentially what Melo does.

I get the others, they're complementary pieces, but saying you'd take bron but not melo is just bias for bias sake.
Click to expand...
Except melo has regressed as scorer

Dude is still awesome but doesn't seem as natural or in the flow of the game that used to

Could be a coaching issue
 
G

giri

Member
Blackace said:
Except melo has regressed as scorer

Dude is still awesome but doesn't seem as natural or in the flow of the game that used to

Could be a coaching issue
Click to expand...

I'd have agreed before last season. In Denver he was good at playing in the flow, and not needing to iso to get his.

Last seasons was pretty hard to watch though.
 
Blackace

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
giri said:
I'd have agreed before last season. In Denver he was good at playing in the flow, and not needing to iso to get his.

Last seasons was pretty hard to watch though.
Click to expand...
He looked Ok this summer. So he could come back


Maybe playing with Kidd will help

Melo needs a floor general
SoulPlaya said:
No.
Click to expand...
I know you are a Laker fan now

But don't be a "Laker" fan
 
O

Omega

Banned
theignoramus said:
you either build a defensive team around Melo like the 2000 76ers (but even Ivy gave you more effort on the defensive end and 5 assists a game) or you put him somewhere where he isnt the top dog. hes seems fine when hes deferring to other players, like at the Olympics.
Click to expand...

pretty much

Melo is a fantastic player and you would be out of your mind to argue otherwise.

He's just not a franchise player/#1 option
 
T

T Dollarz

Member
I think Melo can be the best player on a team, but needs someone close to his talent level at one or two other positions. He just doesn't have that now. Amare is not that guy anymore. He needs a distributor. Put Rondo on the Knicks and that team is in the conference finals. They could also use a tad more players to upgrade the role players. But yeah, they're about a point guard short and would need Amare to actually play good.
 
Blackace

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
Clint Beastwood said:
pretty much

Melo is a fantastic player and you would be out of your mind to argue otherwise.

He's just not a franchise player/#1 option
Click to expand...
This isn't true even franchise players like bird needed good PGs to win.
 
G

giri

Member
Tyler the Creature said:
I think Melo can be the best player on a team, but needs someone close to his talent level at one or two other positions. He just doesn't have that now. Amare is not that guy anymore. He needs a distributor. Put Rondo on the Knicks and that team is in the conference finals. They could also use a tad more players to upgrade the role players. But yeah, they're about a point guard short and would need Amare to actually play good.
Click to expand...

So does just about every chip team for the last decade.
 
T

theignoramus

Member
Im still just kind of baffled the Knicks didnt keep J-Lin. and that they think Raymond Felton is going to actually make their team better. Not even trolling, lol. Can the Knicks afford Jose Calderon? He's 10 million a year, but he wants out of Tdot now that Lowry's our starting point man. whatever flaws the guy has, he's still an elite distributor and a solid perimeter shooter.
 
Blackace

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
theignoramus said:
Im still just kind of baffled the Knicks didnt keep J-Lin. and that they think Raymond Felton is going to actually make their team better. Not even trolling, lol. Can the Knicks afford Jose Calderon? He's 10 million a year, but he wants out of Tdot now that Lowry's our starting point man. whatever flaws the guy has, he's still an elite distributor and a solid perimeter shooter.
Click to expand...
He could fit well
 
Z

Zeus Molecules

illegal immigrants are stealing our air
theignoramus said:
Im still just kind of baffled the Knicks didnt keep J-Lin. and that they think Raymond Felton is going to actually make their team better. Not even trolling, lol. Can the Knicks afford Jose Calderon? He's 10 million a year, but he wants out of Tdot now that Lowry's our starting point man. whatever flaws the guy has, he's still an elite distributor and a solid perimeter shooter.
Click to expand...

The more I think about Lin the more I think they let him go to appease the Ego's of other players on the team. Keep in mind they did bring Kidd to mentor him but to pay him 15 million on year 3 while there trying to tell other players to sign for less to help to keep the team under the cap wouldn't happen.
 
T

T Dollarz

Member
Do you guys think Melo is a better player now than he was in say '07 with Denver? I'd say the styles were different, but ultimately lead to him being a good but not GREAT player.
 
G

giri

Member
theignoramus said:
Im still just kind of baffled the Knicks didnt keep J-Lin. and that they think Raymond Felton is going to actually make their team better. Not even trolling, lol. Can the Knicks afford Jose Calderon? He's 10 million a year, but he wants out of Tdot now that Lowry's our starting point man. whatever flaws the guy has, he's still an elite distributor and a solid perimeter shooter.
Click to expand...

Blackace said:
He could fit well
Click to expand...


I don't think it's so much a anti-Lin thing as a, they're sort of sick of over paying role players to appease crowds. Didn't they get Felton for a fair bit less?

Knicks also do need defense out of their PG, with Amare backing the PG up, so calderon wouldn't fit well at all.

Jose also seems to have lost a step also, and he didn't have much to begin with. Not that his game is really based on athleticism.
 
M

MorisUkunRasik

Member
Tyler the Creature said:
Do you guys think Melo is a better player now than he was in say '07 with Denver? I'd say the styles were different, but ultimately lead to him being a good but not GREAT player.
Click to expand...

He was better in 06/07 and 07/08 than he has been in either 10/11 or 11/12, there's not a huge difference though 11/12 was a particularly bad year for him.

Healthy he can still ball, 10/11 proved he can still get his in a shitty offense even if it doesn't translate to wins.
 
T

The Frankman

Banned
giri said:
I think that team needs one to get them to gel as a team. But yeah, he needs a strong PG.
Click to expand...
The decision to deal Chauncey was needed, but boy Knicks had no backup plan at PG. Kidd definitely will help and don't sleep in Felton; keep in mind he's got mad respect from Amare for 2010. Carmelo maybe starts dissing Felton, Amare swoops in.
Clint Beastwood said:
pretty much

Melo is a fantastic player and you would be out of your mind to argue otherwise.

He's just not a franchise player/#1 option
Click to expand...
Yeah, you got to surround him with defenders and some other alphas. I really like the moves Knicks made in FA.
Tyler the Creature said:
I think Melo can be the best player on a team, but needs someone close to his talent level at one or two other positions. He just doesn't have that now. Amare is not that guy anymore. He needs a distributor. Put Rondo on the Knicks and that team is in the conference finals. They could also use a tad more players to upgrade the role players. But yeah, they're about a point guard short and would need Amare to actually play good.
Click to expand...
Amar'e I think can regain some of his mojo, dude has put in work all summer long (as opposed to the lockout where he couldn't pick up a basketball). The thing is Amar'e NEEDS to demand to ball, he was passive last year due to Zombie-itis. But you think Carmelo's respecting Rondo? Dude alienated Ray Allen, you need a vet with rings (preferably) at PG to get Carmelo to fall in line (Billups, Kidd).
 
P

pilonv1

Member
d7f5813afc4b11e19be31231381b5339_7.jpg


Hot stuff
 
T

The Frankman

Banned
Tyler the Creature said:
Nah, he can't have an aged point guard. Needs a young guy to run the floor.
Click to expand...
felton.jpg

"That's why I'm bringing back the JANK DRIBBLE yo!"
MorisUkunRasik said:
Do Knick fans expect Kidd to be anything more than a voice to rip into Felton when he gets too free?
Click to expand...
Don't worry, if Felton does Mike Woodson will glue his ass to the bench.

Remember, this is a much different team than what Felton had in 2010. He may not even be 3rd option on the starters.

EDIT: lemme qualify what Syphon said by saying Kidd can do that for 15-20 minutes a game.
 
I

ItWasMeantToBe19

Banned
I think I should be able to argue about how Al Jefferson is better than Melo at this point.

Nah, he can't have an aged point guard. Needs a young guy to run the floor.
Click to expand...

Ty Lawson became one of the best PGs in the NBA after Melo was traded, not sure it was that much of a coincidence.
 
M

MorisUkunRasik

Member
Syphon Filter said:
he can still play defense,pass and rebound.if you leave him open on 3s he will make them.
Click to expand...

He can pass, hit an open 3 at a good rate and he still rebounds well for his position.

He can't do much else, he looked done all of last season. I hate to think of what he would look like without leveling up his 3 point shot these last few years. He's reiant on it these days.

He's going to be the backup's back up though right?
 
T

The Frankman

Banned
MorisUkunRasik said:
He can pass, hit an open 3 at a good rate and he still rebounds well for his position.

He can't do much else, he looked done all of last season. I hate to think of what he would look like without leveling up his 3 point shot these last few years. He's reiant on it these days.

He's going to be the backup's back up though right?
Click to expand...
He looked done because like most of Dallas he was out of basketball shape and the lockout schedule killed him. Actually having days off, no b2b2b's and a solid 3rd PG should help him.

Felton
Kidd
Prignoli
 
Blackace

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
The Frankman said:
He looked done because like most of Dallas he was out of basketball shape and the lockout schedule killed him. Actually having days off, no b2b2b's and a solid 3rd PG should help him.

Felton
Kidd
Prignoli
Click to expand...

no one on Dallas looked like never Fullton
 
T

The Frankman

Banned
Blackace said:
no one on Dallas looked like never Fullton
Click to expand...
... wtf did you mean to type?

If you saying no one on Dallas ever looked like Felton, you're right. RayRay wasn't about that Portland life. Playing on that team made him realize how much he missed NY.

rfeltoncopy-1.jpg


...

I'm not even trolling, he legit said this.
 
M

MorisUkunRasik

Member
The Frankman said:
He looked done because like most of Dallas he was out of basketball shape and the lockout schedule killed him. Actually having days off, no b2b2b's and a solid 3rd PG should help him.

Felton
Kidd
Prignoli
Click to expand...

You can blame part of it on chip hangover, but a good amount of it is the fact that Kidd was 18 when straight outta compton dropped.


edit: My mistake he was actually "only" 16.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

  • Locked
PATH Tunnels Seen as Fragile in Bomb Attack
2
613
goodcow replied
Top Bottom