So in your opinion (or the opinion of anyone else reading this), would it be better to read the two books merged into one, or read them each separately? If spoilers aren't an issue, then the only problem would be how it affects pacing.
It's probably not worth the trouble. Just read the books separately.
Man, I wonder how much of the stuff that fans pick up on GRRM actually intended. If it was just one or two posts like those, I'd believe it, but there are so many posts that go so deeply into themes and character arcs and relationships that it just seems impossible that this story is just THAT thought out.
Because of internet forums a lot of people are piecing together secrets that Martin only intended 1/100 people to get. Remember, back in '96 when GoT first came out this was a non-issue and he could throw out tonnes of hints and be confident almost nobody would "get" it.
In order to counter this development, in ADWD he added tons of obfuscation and red herrings. The Pink Letter is something of a masterpiece, it's obviously not entirely true, but makes just enough sense to make you wonder what is going on. Marvelous