INC
Member
Last edited:
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
(*) Ali Salehi, a rendering engineer at Crytek contrasts the next Gen consoles in interview (Up: Tweets/Article removed)
- Thread starter Apollo Helios
- Start date
- Opinion
DynamiteCop!
Banned
Backfire
ClearMind
Report me for console warring (Xbot, Xbro etc.)
Ashoca
Banned
To be honest, after seeing his twitter and instagram, the credibility was already lost.
Or the console that needs most damage control?
Last edited:
Jimmyisback
Banned
Yeah it was full of weird statements. Series X power is only theoretical. PS5 can load games in under zero seconds. etc etc.
Apollo Helios
Member
Well that is one way to interpret that, an other interpretation being it was taken down by Sony's or Crytek's request.
Last edited:
Even if he did not sign a NDA I'm guessing he did not clear this interview with marketing department and is trying to avoid that call from HR about an unauthorized interview. He probably did not expect this to get this sort of attention oops. People these days really have to understand anything said online can go viral and your work will find out if it involves them.
ClearMind
Report me for console warring (Xbot, Xbro etc.)
The PS5 is gonna outsell the Series X with ease.
Psykodad
Banned
Right about what exactly?
DynamiteCop!
Banned
Which has so much to do with all the hardware damage control showing up around here trying to convince people they're stupid by properly identifying that more is more, and not that less is more.
Last edited:
INC
Member
Which one has the higher resolution and frame rate on 3rd party games?
Last edited:
Panajev2001a
GAF's Pleasant Genius
Wasn’t the argument from that side of the fence that the GitHub leak was actually valid “because” it had been taken down?
DynamiteCop!
Banned
Don't try to conflate internal document leaks as being the same as some guy running his mouth on the internet.
Jimmyisback
Banned
Github wasn't a Sony fanboy though. haha.
Panajev2001a
GAF's Pleasant Genius
It is easy to see why regardless of anything else Phil wanted to win the numbers war as it makes for a lot easier PR and aggressive word of mouth and the amount of people that are willing and can debate the minutiae and all is small and the amount of people that listen beyond the headline sound bite is even smaller
.That was both a useful target and a smart one, especially when the brand was built around having the performance crown since its launch.
The funny bit is that some of the people on that side of the fence were furiously arguing against Sony’s higher numbers before, calling them bullshit hype, like with PS2 vs DC and GCN arguing how theoretical peaks and sustained numbers where totally different things. I wonder how many, suspect more than one
.
Last edited:
ClearMind
Report me for console warring (Xbot, Xbro etc.)
The only damage control Im seeing is from xbox fanatics teethering on insanity because the PS5 is receiving a lot of praise.
Bernkastel
Ask me about my fanboy energy!
Why would Sony take down such an awesome PR piece ?
Edit : Apparently I cant reply to this thread because of this post.
Last edited:
Jimmyisback
Banned
hahaha. Yep.
Psykodad
Banned
Nobody is denying the better specs of XSX, so again, what are people supposedly going to be wrong about?
Btw, wasn't there a game last week that runs at higher framerate on Pro vs X?
Comments like yours will come back and bite you in the *bleep*.
Last edited:
INC
Member
Oooh u think I have a vested interest in one console?
I'm just answering your question dude x
CJY
Banned
Cool down bro, I think he was just answering your question
Ashoca
Banned
Are you talking about Resident Evil 3 Remake? Well, it runs on a much higher resolution on Xbox compared to PS4. Don't know why the japanese dev just used dynamic res then 1X version would run much better actually. But well, japanese dev don't care about xbox anyways.
Panajev2001a
GAF's Pleasant Genius
Do you have an actual point beyond this one liner driveby?
DynamiteCop!
Banned
Funny all this praise is coming from people heavily associated with the brand in one regard or another, statements of praise are being redacted, and statements from contractually obligated developers conflict with what they said previously.
Seems legit.
Panajev2001a
GAF's Pleasant Genius
“...It ruins my narrative... sssh, you are not supposed to use our logic against the points we want to make”
I am just following the same logic and enjoying how, out of convenience, you want to twist it to say one thing and its opposite too
. You need to kind of decide how that works and apply the same logic to both supporting statements.
Last edited:
Jimmyisback
Banned
Yeah don't take what he said with any grain of salt whatsoever. A fanboy musings are worthless but can be entertaining.
lepermessiah
Member
As far as I see it, a 17% delta in raw compute means diminishing returns, a few extra pixels and frames in some scenarios, not exactly anything revolutionary there, I/O efficiency and fast data transfer + SSD, however, das it. We will see.
Zoro7
Banned
I don’t agree. We have had a really detailed look into how the PS5 will operate. It’s a system built primarily on reducing bottlenecks.
ClearMind
Report me for console warring (Xbot, Xbro etc.)
Thats only true for the xbox side.
Bernkastel
can hook you up for that bullshit.The PS5 on the other hand is getting praise from third parties not associated with Sony in any way.
Panajev2001a
GAF's Pleasant Genius
Again, you followed up a one liner drive-by with insults now. I will repeat what I said before, do you have an actual point you wish to make and if so what is it?
DynamiteCop!
Banned
It's 18% minimum, and couple that with the RT uplift and it's a substantial difference. RT regardless of having dedicated hardware cuts into raster heavily, so having not only more RT hardware but higher raster capability is a stark advantage.
Ashoca
Banned
Detailed? I think a lot of details are missing. We don't even now the base clocks. We don't even know the range of the variable frequencies. Anyways, there is still plenty of time.
Bernkastel
Ask me about my fanboy energy!
Thats only true for the xbox side.
The PS5 on the other hand is getting praise from third parties not associated with Sony in any way.
Matt_Fox
Member
OP has changed the thread title or was it changed by mods?
The interviewee now says he wont stand by the interview?
Interview has been deleted from twitter?
Very fishy, what is going on here?!
Panajev2001a
GAF's Pleasant Genius
You mean shading as raster seems to see the opposite camp with the “advantage” (same number of ROPS and rasteriser logic at higher frequency). Still, the advantage does not have multiplier factors as you imply there.
Jimmyisback
Banned
Yep I won't be surprised if he's fired.
GHG
Member
Someone probably told him not to talk.
If anything that would mean he does actually have hands on experience with the two consoles despite what some people would like to believe.
CJY
Banned
I'm going to put my neck on the line and say that next-gen, PS5 games will almost universally have solid framerates and framepacing. It's to do with the variable clocks.
I think PS5 and its devkit is architected in a way that allows for very stable execution of a game. Devkit doesn't boost, so devs are optimising for example at a locked profile of 10.0TF/3.4Ghz, and when the game is run on the console, the clocks are unlocked and variable, boosting to the max for those split seconds when necessary. That means there is an extra performance ceiling on the console compared to the devkit. This will ensure steady framerates 99.9% of the time.
XSX might potentially have more unsteady framerates because they are using the old paradigm and devs will be fighting against that peak wall at all times througout development like in the current generation.
I hope nobody thinks I'm trying to shit on XSX, I'm just talking about old vs. new paradigm, and just theorizing. I'm pretty sure this is how it will play out though. XSX will produce more pixels.
I think PS5 and its devkit is architected in a way that allows for very stable execution of a game. Devkit doesn't boost, so devs are optimising for example at a locked profile of 10.0TF/3.4Ghz, and when the game is run on the console, the clocks are unlocked and variable, boosting to the max for those split seconds when necessary. That means there is an extra performance ceiling on the console compared to the devkit. This will ensure steady framerates 99.9% of the time.
XSX might potentially have more unsteady framerates because they are using the old paradigm and devs will be fighting against that peak wall at all times througout development like in the current generation.
I hope nobody thinks I'm trying to shit on XSX, I'm just talking about old vs. new paradigm, and just theorizing. I'm pretty sure this is how it will play out though. XSX will produce more pixels.
Last edited:
DynamiteCop!
Banned
You have no idea what the ROPs are but given the divergence in base compute and CU's it's no doubt a higher count. Also no one said anything about a multiplier. If RT cuts into your rasterization rendering capability having more of it is a substantial advantage because you can push higher RT ceilings before you run into a net negative in performance relative to the competitions hardware.
As if you're not fully aware of this.
Last edited:
geordiemp
Member
Your application of logic is quite fightening.
Point 1 : He cannot say that as it would break NDA
Point 2 : Taken down, probably due to NDA.....therefore not true ?
Really ? If there was no NDA then he is free to say what he likes. If he has NDA, it will be taken down and he will be repremanded.
Last edited:
ethomaz
Banned
A Sony fanboy will never post that shameful tweet.
Selective tweets?
Last edited:
geordiemp
Member
15 years ago or something he was a dev yes, and since then has posted lots of negative about Sony and is friends with Timdog. Yeah thats funny
He has not developed games for allot of years, against a Crytek guy who is a devloper NOW. If you cannot distinguish teh difference then there is no hope.
Fixed that for you. at least he can play games
Last edited:
MilkyJoe
Member
I think you're mistaking "butthurt" for "ridicule"
ethomaz
Banned
He did not break any NDA with what he talked.
Zoro7
Banned
Didn’t Cerny already address this? Max speeds will be accessible most of the time.
DynamiteCop!
Banned
Yeah but how low can each fall in the worst case scenario, that's something they're not so open about sharing.
MilkyJoe
Member
Or Sony are more active on the old damage control?
PSbigfan
Member
Maybe because you have mind
to think with it not a brain like the most of people here.
Last edited: