Support NeoGAF

tt_deeb · Feb 16, 2005

And that sixteen year old chick is a bitch but I'd hit it with a vengeance. Is she still in?

tralfazz · Feb 16, 2005

tt_deeb said:
Is the rock star guy still in? (I missed some parts)

Yes.

It's pretty easy to figure who the final 24 will be.

Both the 16 yr olds are in

MIMIC · Feb 17, 2005

It's on.

They all get "the chair"

Wellington · Feb 17, 2005

THE HOT BITCH MAKES IT THROUGH! YES!

<Dr. Dre> Man, she's only sixteen years old!

trilobyte · Feb 17, 2005

is it wrong?

Eminem · Feb 17, 2005

shut the fuck up faith, you fucking crying whore.

MIMIC · Feb 17, 2005

Eminem said:
shut the fuck up faith, you fucking crying whore.

I felt sorry for her.

EDIT: :lol...but her phone conversation was funny as hell.

MIMIC · Feb 17, 2005

*J'Nay gives her mother an ambiguous look*
Mother: "WHAT?!" *finds out her daugher made it* "Don't do that to me!"

:lol :lol :lol

Phoenix · Feb 17, 2005

"Hey, dirty, baby I got your money...."

tt_deeb · Feb 23, 2005

It's on.

I didn't see yesterdays. One of the guys that's in the top 24 is a cousin of a friend of mine.

MIMIC's been banned?

jiggle · Feb 24, 2005

eastcoaster: is it on yet? Spoiler please!

Wellington · Feb 24, 2005

I think it's cruel and unusual punishment to make them sing after they've been booted.

tralfazz · Feb 24, 2005

Wellington said:
I think it's cruel and unusual punishment to make them sing after they've been booted.

Yeah it's almost unwatchable, almost. If it was me and Seacrest asked me how I felt I'd say "Imagine how your boyfriend would feel if I killed you right now," and walk off stage.

Wellington · Feb 24, 2005

:lol!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Man what they did to Judd was ROUGH. :lol

Eminem · Feb 24, 2005

fucking website isn't updated. who got the boot? anyone, please?

Fatalah · Feb 24, 2005

Chinese girl and oil hair white girl is out.

Indian guy with acne out along with weird 50's singing guy Judd.

Constantine still in it! Pray for the soul of betty baby!

Eminem · Feb 24, 2005

thanks.

i wanted judd to go. i thought he and jared were the worst

jiggle · Feb 24, 2005

Who's the chinese girl and oil hair white girl?

Fatalah · Feb 24, 2005

She's the white one with the oily gelled hair....she's not that pretty.

The Chosen One · Feb 24, 2005

God, I hope Fran Dresser gets voted out soon. Her singing and especially her talking voice is extremely annoying.

I also think it's in poor taste to make the losers sing. But of course, this is Fox.

MIMIC · Feb 24, 2005

What they did to that Judd guy was ridiculous. :lol :lol

Gibbo · Feb 24, 2005

What did they do to him?

SteveMeister · Feb 24, 2005

Gibbo said:
What did they do to him?

They left 6 of the guys, including Judd, on the bench and called the other 6 down to the stage. Seacrest took two of the guys on stage at a time, and drawing it out like he always does, eventually told all 6 they were safe. He told the 6 on stage to go sit down, and then said "Judd. You're finished." (or something to that effect).

MIMIC · Feb 24, 2005

Gibbo said:
What did they do to him?

The final 12 guys were sitting in rows of 2 (6 in front and 6 in back). Judd was on the front row, and Ryan told them all to "relax."

He told the back row to come to the stage and form two rows of 2 on each side of him (3 in each row).

He systematically paired two guys against each other, judging who would stay and who would remain safe. The first pair of guys: safe; the second pair of guys: safe.

When he got to the last pair of guys, knowing that ONE of them would be going home, he surprised the entire fucking WORLD when he said that they were BOTH safe.

He let everyone stare at each other for a few seconds in a "what the fuck is going on" kind of way, and pointed to Judd (who he earlier told to "relax") and told him that he was going home.

That was extremely cruel :lol :lol (at first, I thought Ryan fucked up his cue cards)

Eminem · Feb 25, 2005

constantine is a badass:

Favorite male pop artist?
Jim Morrison.

Favorite female pop artist?
Janis Joplin.

If you couldn't sing, which talent would you most like to have?
Pro athlete.

What would people be surprised to learn about you?
Love sports

He is a slightly longer haired, more popular, better singing version of me.

MIMIC · Feb 25, 2005

Bo Bice:

What album would your friends be surprised you own?
Metallica.

He must hang out with a lot of black people.

What would people be surprised to learn about you?
I love to cook.

LMAO! I read that as "I love cock." :lol :lol

MIMIC · Mar 1, 2005

It's on. (and I just have to say this) Followed by "24"

SteveMeister · Mar 1, 2005

Bo was phenomenal tonight. Great stuff.

Constantine had the weakest performance.

sprsk · Mar 1, 2005

SteveMeister said:
Constantine had the weakest performance.

constantine sounded like the lead singer of a bad cover band. i agreed with simon on that one.

MIMIC · Mar 2, 2005

It's on.

Memles · Mar 2, 2005

Man...for someone so energetic last week, she's being completely outsand by the "Oohs" on this song.

MIMIC · Mar 2, 2005

sp0rsk said:
constantine sounded like the lead singer of a bad cover band. i agreed with simon on that one.

I don't listen to that type of music, but Constantine had me dancin

MIMIC · Mar 2, 2005

Mikalah DID the damn thang!

Fatalah · Mar 2, 2005

constantine was in rent too. he's too good for this show! TOO GOOD I TELLS YA!

SteveMeister · Mar 2, 2005

Fatalah said:
constantine was in rent too. he's too good for this show! TOO GOOD I TELLS YA!

If so, he didn't show it on Monday. Bo was far, far better.

MIMIC · Mar 3, 2005

:lol Wow...that was quick.

MIMIC · Mar 8, 2005

It's on.

Eminem · Mar 8, 2005

that was the first of bo's performances that i actually liked.

MIMIC · Mar 8, 2005

Eminem said:
that was the first of bo's performances that i actually liked.

:lol Yeah...same here.

Star Power · Mar 8, 2005

Bo is such a cool guy. I hope he wins, or at least gets to the top 5.

Constantine sucks.

tralfazz · Mar 8, 2005

Simon - "You have as much latin flair as a polar bear"

OWN3D! :lol

MIMIC · Mar 8, 2005

...what happened at the Oscars?

Star Power · Mar 8, 2005

MIMIC said:
...what happened at the Oscars?

He most likely meant Grammy's. But Jamie Foxx did win for the Ray movie..

MIMIC · Mar 8, 2005

:lol I hope Simon isn't TOO harsh on Travis.

MIMIC · Mar 8, 2005

Randy was right. The first part of Travis's performance was definitely NOT on pitch.

MIMIC · Mar 8, 2005

Mario can sing, but it's just that his singing VOICE is annoying. :lol

Star Power · Mar 8, 2005

I really hope Anwar fucks up and get's voted off. He's soo annoying

tralfazz · Mar 8, 2005

MIMIC said:
Randy was right. The first part of Travis's performance was definitely NOT on pitch.

It's the same problem Bobby had singing it. Dance so much you're out of breath to sing the song. I remeber him butchering it like that at the 1992 MTV awards.

Eminem · Mar 8, 2005

Constantine gets props for covering the motherfucking Police

Star Power · Mar 8, 2005

Constantine has like a 0 Octave range.

Support NeoGAF

American Idol: Season 4

Member

Member

Banned

BAAAALLLINNN'

Member

goddamit, Griese!

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Member

BAAAALLLINNN'

Member

BAAAALLLINNN'

goddamit, Griese!

Member

goddamit, Griese!

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Hang out with Steve.

Banned

goddamit, Griese!

Banned

Banned

Hang out with Steve.

force push the doodoo rock

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Hang out with Steve.

Banned

Banned

goddamit, Griese!

Banned

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

goddamit, Griese!

Member

Similar threads