I actually quite enjoyed the 2nd episode on several levels!
As a huge horror buff I devour horror films like they're candy. With that comes my weakness for horror sequels. I've seen all the Friday the 13ths, Children of the Corn DTVs, Hellraisers, Wishmasters, etc. There's a morbid curiousity in me to see how another director/writer takes on the source material. Many of these times the sequels are bad, but it's fun to pick it apart and see what worked and what didn't.
Evil Dead is one of those rare horror series that's had its creator still attached throughout the films (reboot aside). The only other standout horror series that's really had this was Night of the Living Dead and Phantasm (that will be changing with the 5th movie though). Raimi has a very distinctive style in all aspects: writing, camera work, editing, action choreography, pacing. You see a single scene and you know it's got his fingers all in it. So like watching all those horror sequels it was a morbid curiousity to see someone else dabble in another's creation.
It's pretty clear that Bassett's eye isn't nearly as strong as Raimi's. Some of his camera work came off as shoddy rather than stylish, and I felt the deadites in his episode lacked the fun of Raimi's despite the entertaining situations the character were put in. Also this episode should've helped satisfy the non CG gore crowd that hated those effects in the pilot. The all natural gore spewed pretty stong in this time!
The dialogue here flowed differently than Raimi's. Closer to actual conversations than a Sunday comic panel. Didn't hate, just was a little odd for Ash. Still lots of funny moments, especially at that dinner scene. The lines from the deadites were sorely lacking for me though. I didn't get a sense of that gleeful, wicked torment that Raimi's deadites had, but that's only judging from this one episode. My fear in the future is them relegating the occassional deadtie encounter into something like a stereotypical Buffy the Vampire Slayer vampire encounter.
As for the show's length. I'm totaly fine with it. I do wish it was closer to 30 minutes as opposed to 25. For those wanting an hour show, want are you wanting? More Amanda Fisher investigations? Lucy Lawless walking around? Pedro flirting with Kelly more? More wating until the next set piece? A lengthy Ash monologue where he delves into his past? Since that's what you would be getting with a show that length. Ever been into a thread for an hour long horror show on GAF before? Usually the main complaints are on the same thing: A certain character or side story that drags down the main plot, or even a moment in the main story that drags out far longer than it should've. Admittedly, I am contemplating on holding off on the rest of the season after the next episode so I could watch everything as one long, epic Evil Dead movie. That'll take a lot of sheer willpower though.
Some quick thoughts (SPOILERS):
- Where'd the CG missing hand go? Lol.
- First thing I thought of when I saw the boss deadite was Jeffrey Jones in Howard the Duck. Couldn't unsee. Wish he had Jones' voice.
- Liked how they're playing around with the opening title and theme. Hope that continues.
- Music choices in this episode were spot on. I just wish Joseph LoDuca had more time to shine.
- The deadite car scene was a lot of fun, but the bossite's dialogue really only amounted to "I hate you". Ooh scary.
- Cute tribute to AoD's windmill gag.
- The whole dinner sequence was fantastic. Different for Evil Dead. When that "punch" line happened I had a big "holy shit" look on my face.
- Bruce always joked about how Ash was reeeally fast at reloading the shotgun in AoD. Now we almost see it in action.
- I loved how the MiMite's tone of voice was really close to Evil Dead 1's deadites.
- As much as I love ED1's music, I hope they don't abuse the Ash & Linda theme every time a deadite wants to get all sobby and human.
- That Mimite kill!
- Kelly seemed to be getting over that real quick. Hey Kelly! Did you know the man without a hand is responsible for you current situation?
- I hope down the road after a decapatation, a body or head randomly comes back to life and Ash just jokingly says something in the lines that he forgot to mention that cutting head off doesn't always mean the end of the possession.