MasterCornholio
Member
Maybe you should finally accept it.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Digital Foundry: Marvel's Spider-Man 2 - Digital Foundry Tech Review - The Next Big Leap For PS5?
- Thread starter adamsapple
- Start date
Maybe you should finally accept it.
kruis
Exposing the sinister cartel of retailers who allow companies to pay for advertising space.
The audio track is the sound of a bustling town, the visuals show what New York must have been like during the covid lockdown...
As others have said: there's a huge difference between making a complete game and a 3 minute UE5 demo. Tens of thousands amateur 3D modelers can throw something impressive together using UE5, yet very few studios capable of making a complete game as impressive as Spider-Man 2. Pause and ponder on why this is before you post more UE5 demo videos you found on Youtube.
Buggy Loop
Member
Is there such a thing as a twitter video that doesn't look like shit? I wonder sometimes if I'm missing a setting because I'm not a user, but, they always look like they're running 480p if even that when you go full screen. Made for cellphones only? Youtube is pretty bad, but leagues better. I don't understand why there would be any video promo on twitter with that quality.
Last edited:
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
Kuwitzzer
Member
Go play your demo instead then. Spider Man 2 is a real game, not just some demo that has nothing beside graphics in it.
Last edited:
lol on a 4090..
with that shitty reflections it was already running at 25fps on a ps5,
(not even mentioning it being a tech demo and not having any sort of game systems, that small detail doesn't seem to compute for some)
Last edited:
Tarnpanzer
Member
My backlog is full, no problem in waiting.
Disco Dave
Member
John Linneman? So that means it's not open world and not "children's bullshit". Good good.
From what? DLSS already lowers the resolution and upscales it.
saintjules
Gold Member
The audacity this guy put his user name on these images as if he created these scenes with Venom.
But yeah, this one looks good
Last edited:
He does not say that you see the BVH. He says that the different room interiors are stored in the BVH, so that the rays passing through the windows can trace into them. Why do you think this is not possible?
SolidQ
Member
UE5 is bad engine for now too heavy for console and have mediocre graphic.
Spider Man 2 RT looks cool, and don't need 4090 for those reflections. That mean good optimisation, other devs too lazy make optimisations
That simple game in 1440p, show how heavy engine if you have worse than 7900XT/4080
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
Imagine what those mad lads could do with a PS5 Pro and its extra horsepower
Sethbacca
Member
Coming back to these after to some mid gen patches gonna be fun.
Puscifer
Member
LiquidMetal14
hide your water-based mammals
Good Lord that first shot of the wing flying mechanic and showing the city and the density plus quickness of how the fast the world keeps up. This is some new gen stuff here these guys are showing. Make a brother jealous on PC.
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
mckmas8808
Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
It helps when you're on your 3rd PS5 game too. Insomniac are some of the best and most efficient developers on Planet Earth!!! Not only do they make great games, but their tech is top notch and they don't need 6 years to make one game.
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
DLSS can save us from $70's 900/1008p plus is optional.
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
Embedded twitter links run at 480p. if you view it on twitter, they run at higher res. but you need to be a twitter subscriber to upload in 4k.
saintjules
Gold Member
Performance + fidelity running together at 60fps would be a dream.
Mortisfacio
Member
Do the trees have different render modes depending on distance? Most the park areas look almost 2d in some of the traversal clips and clean up a bit when you land.
LiquidMetal14
hide your water-based mammals
Finished the video, nothing else to say but that Insomniac are at the peak of developers around the world with the like of CDPR and Sony Santa Monica. Just stunning work in the overall picture and considering this is just a PS5 pulling this off. Truly amazing effort.
SolidQ
Member
Add new RT feature, or maybe path tracing, they show how cdproject super weak at optimisation
Last edited:
Sethbacca
Member
Stop. I can only get so hard.
Lysandros
Member
You can take PS4 to PS4 PRO as a model...
winjer
Gold Member
Those interiors are just a 3d mesh, with low poly count to keep the performance.
Since those interiors have no reflections, there is nothing to used in a BVH. And according to DF, this gam only uses RT for reflections.
The exterior of the town has it's BVH, but it's probably doing it on a lower quality LoD.
This reflection will show up on the glass, and then blended as a transparency with the interior.
But the thing I was talking about is that a BVH is not geometry.
A BVH is a bounding volume that encompasses geometry. And it has several levels, to have a finer bound over each object. Creating a tree of nodes.
BVHs work by quickly eliminating large portions of the scene from consideration when tracing a ray or detecting collisions.
When tracing a ray through a scene, the ray tracer would first check to see if it intersects the bounding volume of the root node. If it does, then the ray tracer would recursively check the bounding volumes of the child nodes, and so on.
If the ray does not intersect the bounding volume of a node, then the ray tracer would skip all of the objects in that node's subtree.
JerryinSoCal
Member
The only disappointment is that he didn't compare it to the PS4 version instead, this is a sequel to that game not the remaster. The leap would have been much bigger had he focused on that vs a game that already got some PS5 upgrades to begin with.
Crayon
Member
If you've got to compare it to the matrix demo running on a serious pc then it obviously turned out looking pretty good. It's not mind blowing but I'm not so sure if we are going to see real games reaching even the low-res choppy level of the matrix any time soon. Maybe, maybe not.
This is insomniac. If there is any developer that knows what they are doing with this hardware, they are on the short list.
That's neither here nor there, though. As of now, matrix demo on a hot pc is the most popular comparison to SM2 and that's telling.
This is insomniac. If there is any developer that knows what they are doing with this hardware, they are on the short list.
That's neither here nor there, though. As of now, matrix demo on a hot pc is the most popular comparison to SM2 and that's telling.
Physiognomonics
Member
Running on a hardware 4 times more expensive and consuming 3 times more energy. This is what's impressive in SM2.
darthkarki
Member
Comparisons to the remaster are definitely fascinating, but I'd love to see some comprehensive comparisons to the original Spider-Man running on a PS4 amateur. Did DF cover that at all in the video? I'm not going to watch till after I play the game.
I think we're a bit spoiled by the fact they were able to put out a mini sequel and a remaster of the original in the same timeframe we would normally go from a game to its sequel. Those had some very nice improvements, but also make the full impact of what Spider-Man 2 is doing less immediately noticeable. If we instead ignore those and pretend all we have is Spider-Man on the original PS4 and Spider-Man 2 on PS5, it's pretty remarkable:
I think we're a bit spoiled by the fact they were able to put out a mini sequel and a remaster of the original in the same timeframe we would normally go from a game to its sequel. Those had some very nice improvements, but also make the full impact of what Spider-Man 2 is doing less immediately noticeable. If we instead ignore those and pretend all we have is Spider-Man on the original PS4 and Spider-Man 2 on PS5, it's pretty remarkable:
- Greatly improved graphics all around (assets, textures, lighting, ray tracing, animation, muscle deformation, spline-based hair, etc...).
- Long loading screens (remember that? It wasn't terrible for the time, but the original had a lot of loading) completely removed.
- From a single 1080p 30fps mode to a plethora of options allowing up to 4K or 80+ fps depending on your selection.
- Mid-gen PS4 Pro support.
- Full next gen support via the remaster.
- An entire extra game in Miles Morales.
ChorizoPicozo
Member
that tells you how everything....every single aspect of game has to come together to achieve "universal acclaimed"
Gaiff
SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
This is how pathetic things have become.
Fanboys warring because of a 1 second button press lol. A programmer had to get out of bed to put this to rest. Some really wanted a gotcha moment to prove that the game has loadings. Pathetic. Even if it did, you basically don't even notice because it's less than 2 seconds.
Fanboys warring because of a 1 second button press lol. A programmer had to get out of bed to put this to rest. Some really wanted a gotcha moment to prove that the game has loadings. Pathetic. Even if it did, you basically don't even notice because it's less than 2 seconds.
Last edited:
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
"Way more impressive"? Definitely not. Better looking characters? Perhaps (though Peter's hair looks better than just about any hair in FW), there is always raytracing on (Forbidden West isn't taxed like this), and SM2 has to deal with more npcs/traffic. Loading is also faster in SM2 (Forbidden West isn't a slouch, though)!
The bottom line is we can appreciate one without playing down the other, because both games are impressive and do things the other does not.
Last edited:
Nope. Tech director confirmed that they aren't doing that and he wanted it changed because people would make this assumption but was overruled for usability
Gaiff
SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
Senua
Member
Better textures, lighting, art direction. And we can definitely compare them because any new first party game will be compared to the reigning graphics champ on the system, and that is still forbidden west
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
And Spider-Man 2 has better reflections, faster loading, and more happening on-screen. Both games do things the other doesn't, but that's because they are two very different experiences.
Last edited:
Mortisfacio
Member
OK, after watching the Digital Foundry review I'm actually less impressed about the visuals. Lot of pop in, 2D environment textures and overall "flat" look to the city (primarily buildings). Even slower walking scenes, like at 19:35 you just watch the non-textured buildings pop in their textures bit by bit. Water and window ray trace reflections look good, at least.
it was running 25fps on PS5 because it had unlimited traffic.
With traffic reduced its alot better. Secondly Lumen has gotten drastically more efficient in 5.3 than in 5.0 so no the fps will actually be better even with the new reflections.
Senua
Member
The buildings are what stick out to me the most
Mortisfacio
Member
Yah even after the pop in they still look pretty bland, but they're especially bad before the textures load
Skifi28
Member
Do we have any actual numbers in our hands or just could/should/would? Majority of real UE5 products so far have been a disaster performance wise.
The audio track is the sound of a bustling town, the visuals show what New York must have been like during the covid lockdown...
As others have said: there's a huge difference between making a complete game and a 3 minute UE5 demo. Tens of thousands amateur 3D modelers can throw something impressive together using UE5, yet very few studios capable of making a complete game as impressive as Spider-Man 2. Pause and ponder on why this is before you post more UE5 demo videos you found on Youtube.
Come again, is this supposed to be an implication that its empty (Video below)? Anyway, I will play SM2 and enjoy it and yet be critical of its visual and tech in display. Another thing John didn't go into is the NPC characters in the street, from what i have seen, they are pretty lackluster. There's so many thing John just glossed over that would have added to the quality and depth of this video. Building textures, LOD pop in, geometry, etc.
Missed opportunity to clarify the visual fidelity of the game.
Last edited: