I registered with Nikkei to read this article just to find out that it's only available to owners of a payed account. Do you know what the article says in detail and what the reasoning for the gambling accusation is?
I know Pachinko is only legal because you can't win money with it, just lose it. I guess some other reason must apply if DQX were to be considered illegal gambling.
Edit: I usually don't go to server 1 as it's always crowded but as was explained to me players gamble there by their own rules. I guess winning of virtual goods is part of that gambling. Interesting but an understandable reasoning in light of the gatcha ruling. I wonder how SE could even prevent players from doing this 'illegal' gambling.
It's the author overextending this thought to the fact that there's grey market RMT going on. Portion that was on the 2ch threads:
ゲーム内の仮想通貨がユーザー間でやり取りが行われる行為のみであれば、これ自体は
問題ない。しかし、今回は「ダイス」といった確率を利用した機能があり、それと「RMT」が
密接に結びつく可能性が出てきている。それは、刑法の定める賭博罪が成立する要件を
満たす危険な状態になっている。
例えば、ヤフーオークションでは、50万ゴールドに対して、8万5000円という価格が付けら
れて販売されているものがある。これほど大きな金額を短期間に動かすための一つの手段
として、ダイスを使ったギャンブルが使われているのではないかと疑われているのだ。もし、
それが事実であると証明できれば、賭博罪が成立する可能性は高い。それに関わっている
ユーザーも賭博罪が適用可能であり、同時に、さらにそうした環境を認めているスクエニに
対しても原理的には適用可能だ。
He's arguing that /random rolling combined with RMT auctions creates a case for violation of gambling laws. You can see the major fail in his logic in the second paragraph: he's assuming gold to the tune of tens of thousands are being handled through these bets (when have you ever seen any of these things run bets much larger than 1000?), and further saying that these may be linked to RMT gangs!
I mean, you want to see any gold farmers you're likely to find them hunting あくま神官 or whomever drops まほうの鎧 recipes or any other rare item, more than you will doing bets that are barely profitable over time, if any. Not to mention the in-game repercussion of getting blacklisted by a huge number of players that will no longer 'hear' you when you want to gather people up for missions.
4gamer ran an article explaining this better if you want to read through that.
BTW, how are people doing regarding story quests so far? I got the 6th key emblem and
regained human form (which sucks)