I only skimmed through that "review" but I thought she made a bunch of completely stupid comments. Such as:
First, mighty hypocritical to complain about alleged slut-shaming and then engaging in ad-hominems (e.g. calling detractors "puritanical").
Second, the blog isn't about slut shaming at all, what a complete nonsense. The blog doe snot shame or ridicule or deride women who engage in sexuality of their own agency, it rolls its eyes at the ridiculous skimpy armours drawn (usually by men and/or for the male gaze) on women supposedly engaged in combat. "Shes just drawn that way", indeed. And as if it's not possible to look
cool or
sexy without being half-naked? *eye roll*
And here we have a strawman. She almost admits that it's one, by saying it's not quite the argument people are presenting, yet she proceeds to refute the argument anyway. Go figure.
I don't have a problem with this line per se, but I do have a problem with those who bitch about the Polygon review. Do you agree with Amanda here? If so, why is it okay to "give" points to a game because you love its art, but not okay to dock points if it bothers you? I wonder.
And lastly, while everyone focusses on the sorceress, she's not even really the problem here. If she had been the only character like that, fine. But other than the elf and princess Vivian (who's just "blank-eyed" and useless), oh and I'm sorry the orc cook lady in Bilbaron, every single female character is sexualized to a ridiculous extent. Morgan, ass-mermaid, chained see-through damsel, creepy spikey-boobplate spread-eagle moaning monk (who's honestly the worst for me even though she's fully covered), not to mention the sheer
volume of near-hentai unlockable artworks from the side-quests all depicting nearly naked females.... I groaned in dismay every time I found a new one because it never stops. (Yeah, but there's Roland so it's totally fine amirite? Come on...)
Sorry, I didn't want to get into this debate again but I'm sick of the contempt shown at those who have a problem with the art (in other words, you started it
). While I love the game, I happen to be one of them, and this doesn't make me a raging feminazi. Btw, I showed this art to other people (guys who are not familiar with the "controversy") and they all agreed it was blatant objectification and two guys even used the words "borderline porn". You don't have a problem with that, fine, but stop pretending it's not there, or handwaving it with
Roland and the dwarf, or "
it's ok since it's just pastiche", it's getting tiresome.