• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

EDGE: The next Xbox: Always online, no second-hand games, 50GB Blu-ray and new kinect

Nothing that hasn't already come out.

Jesus Christ Microsoft...

7MxtMt7.gif
 
Next-gen (current gen?) is a clusterfuck. Of epic proportions. The industry is crashing before our very eyes.

I wish 3rd parties had actually supported the WiiU in any form or fashion. Then at least we'd have an alternative to no used games. Assuming the PS4 follows Microsoft's lead.

I wonder what 3rd parties will do when the XBox, and perhaps PS4, bomb at retail. They "abandoned" the WiiU pretty fast...
 

ascii42

Member
The main reason are for anti-piracy, to enforce anti-used games and to is to ensure Xbox consumers are able to buy into other, non-gaming MS services.

From a game maker perspective (who will also be happy about anti-piracy and anti-use games), it ensure that all users will have current patch levels. Knowing they'll always be online means that they can incorporate this into game designs. Not just multiplay gaming, but daily / weekly challenges, special modes etc, available to all.

True, and they could have something like Playstation Plus's automatic updates as well.
 
The main reason are for anti-piracy, to enforce anti-used games and to is to ensure Xbox consumers are able to buy into other, non-gaming MS services.

From a game maker perspective (who will also be happy about anti-piracy and anti-use games), it ensure that all users will have current patch levels. Knowing they'll always be online means that they can incorporate this into game designs. Not just multiplay gaming, but daily / weekly challenges, special modes etc, available to all.

That last part sounds great, the rest, not so much.
I'm looking forward to the first report of some dufus that buys one, doesn't have internet to apply to it and didn't know before hand.
 

Respawn

Banned
The main reason are for anti-piracy, to enforce anti-used games and to is to ensure Xbox consumers are able to buy into other, non-gaming MS services.

From a game maker perspective (who will also be happy about anti-piracy and anti-use games), it ensure that all users will have current patch levels. Knowing they'll always be online means that they can incorporate this into game designs. Not just multiplay gaming, but daily / weekly challenges, special modes etc, available to all.

Hmm I guess all that piracy on 360 really ruffled some feathers.
 

ascii42

Member
Next-gen (current gen?) is a clusterfuck. Of epic proportions. The industry is crashing before our very eyes.

I wish 3rd parties had actually supported the WiiU in any form or fashion. Then at least we'd have an alternative to no used games. Assuming the PS4 follows Microsoft's lead.

I wonder what 3rd parties will do when the XBox, and perhaps PS4, bomb at retail. They "abandoned" the WiiU pretty fast...

Well, they've got to go somewhere...
 

rdrr gnr

Member
The main reason are for anti-piracy, to enforce anti-used games and to is to ensure Xbox consumers are able to buy into other, non-gaming MS services.

From a game maker perspective (who will also be happy about anti-piracy and anti-use games), it ensure that all users will have current patch levels. Knowing they'll always be online means that they can incorporate this into game designs. Not just multiplay gaming, but daily / weekly challenges, special modes etc, available to all.
Why do these necessarily follow? Who is to take it anything beyond just pure DRM?

Edit:SP
 
In regard to Sony and everything that's been made available up till now, IMO it would be better to expect a similar policy than not.

So always online & no used games?

As of today I can say that's the goal. If MS changes their mind, which I would definitely not tell anyone to get their hopes up, then that's another story.
 
The main reason are for anti-piracy, to enforce anti-used games and to is to ensure Xbox consumers are able to buy into other, non-gaming MS services.

From a game maker perspective (who will also be happy about anti-piracy and anti-use games), it ensure that all users will have current patch levels. Knowing they'll always be online means that they can incorporate this into game designs. Not just multiplay gaming, but daily / weekly challenges, special modes etc, available to all.

...and - let´s say - 8 years later ... we can`t play our games anymore, because the certification servers got shut down!

I definitely won`t invest money in games with an expiration date.
 

Spongebob

Banned
In regard to Sony and everything that's been made available up till now, IMO it would be better to expect a similar policy than not.



As of today I can say that's the goal. If MS changes their mind, which I would definitely not tell anyone to get their hopes up, then that's another story.

Both Sony and MS can fuck off if they go through with this.
 

PG2G

Member
The two groups who benefit from blocking used games are the console manufacturers and the publishers, as neither get a cut from second hand sales..

The two groups who are negatively effected are consumers and retailers.

Let's say MS does block used games and Sony doesn't.

If Sony allows used games, they could piss off publishers. Some games might not be released on their platform. But they would please retailers, who would be more likely to push their hardware and games.

For MS, they might see more games on their platform, but would have soured the retail relationship. So unless they'd sweeten it by allowing a much bigger margin on Xbox products over Sony/Nintendo ones, they could be looking at lower retail sales.

It makes far more sense to keep your retail partners happy, rather than your content providers. This has always been Nintendo's strategy, which has seen enormous retails success for them (it's the main reason they've been slow to embrace digital distribution, as they want to appease their long term retail channel partners).

There are only a small number of retailers in each country, but hundreds of game makers. If Activation didn't support your platform, another company would fill the vacuum left. If GameStop or similar major retail channel doesn't support your platform, you would have a far harder time getting market penetration of the console and see fewer games sold.

Personally, I just can't see how MS could do this if Sony doesn't. Interesting times ahead.

Not sure that this is true. This is targeted at a specific retailer, Gamestop. The Amazons, Best Buys, and Targets of the world would likely see a boost from this rather than be hurt by it.
 

CLEEK

Member
Why do these necessarily follow? Whose to take it anything beyond just pure DRM?

They don't. They're just something that devs can do knowing that all the players will be online. With the 360, online is like caching to HDD. You can't expect all gamers to have it, so have to work around it. Mandating online will allow for novel game ideas.
 
As of today I can say that's the goal. If MS changes their mind, which I would definitely not tell anyone to get their hopes up, then that's another story.

Oh god, the freak outs you are creating.

Delicious.

images
 

Reiko

Banned
In regard to Sony and everything that's been made available up till now, IMO it would be better to expect a similar policy than not.



As of today I can say that's the goal. If MS changes their mind, which I would definitely not tell anyone to get their hopes up, then that's another story.


MS & Sony next gen market share:

the-joker-burning-mon83ubz.jpg
 

Mrbob

Member
Next-gen (current gen?) is a clusterfuck. Of epic proportions. The industry is crashing before our very eyes.

I wish 3rd parties had actually supported the WiiU in any form or fashion. Then at least we'd have an alternative to no used games. Assuming the PS4 follows Microsoft's lead.

I wonder what 3rd parties will do when the XBox, and perhaps PS4, bomb at retail. They "abandoned" the WiiU pretty fast...

Steambox.

Also, you are being over dramatic. I'd rather have no used games than live with Nintendo's online and OS infrastructure.
 
Next-gen (current gen?) is a clusterfuck. Of epic proportions. The industry is crashing before our very eyes.

I wish 3rd parties had actually supported the WiiU in any form or fashion. Then at least we'd have an alternative to no used games. Assuming the PS4 follows Microsoft's lead.

I wonder what 3rd parties will do when the XBox, and perhaps PS4, bomb at retail. They "abandoned" the WiiU pretty fast...

Are you kidding me? Nintendo is still the worst offender with its online business strategy. Screw them.
 

Varg

Banned
Hmm I guess all that piracy on 360 really ruffled some feathers.
The piracy scene on the 360 is bigger then a lot of people realize. Its to the point that people have two 360s, one legit and one modded. It is incredibly easy to flash the system and to download the games. You can even go online with the modded Xbox and no one would know. Quick YouTube vid or link to a popular site and you'll be getting free games within an hour.
 

Petrae

Member
Not at all surprised by this confirmation trend. It's like Luke hearing the news from Vader and being in complete denial... until that fateful confirmation.

Things will get more interesting now as we move forward.
 
In regard to Sony and everything that's been made available up till now, IMO it would be better to expect a similar policy than not.



As of today I can say that's the goal. If MS changes their mind, which I would definitely not tell anyone to get their hopes up, then that's another story.

Wow, what's happening to you games industry :/
 

~Kinggi~

Banned
Stuff like this really explains why you have companies like Crytek saying they are transitioning completely to a Free-to-Play model. I mean freaking Crytek. FTP need always online for the most part. In fact, expect a ton of FTP shit, that'll attract the gamers to an always online digital environment......
 

CLEEK

Member
Not sure that this is true. This is targeted at a specific retailer, Gamestop. The Amazons, Best Buys, and Targets of the world would likely see a boost from this rather than be hurt by it.

Just Gamestop in the US, maybe. In Australia, you can buy games and hardware from Target and Kmart, but they carry a very limited range. The two biggest retailers by far (JB HiFi and EB Games) all have extensive used games sections. If they didn't stock your console or games, the retail presence of them would be tiny.
 

Eusis

Member
Welp, unless Microsoft changes course or Sony sees the reaction as an example of what NOT to do I guess there's a good chance I'll be Wii U/PC/Handheld next gen.
 

rdrr gnr

Member
Stuff like this really explains why you have companies like Crytek saying they are transitioning completely to a Free-to-Play model. I mean freaking Crytek. FTP need always online for the most part. In fact, expect a ton of FTP shit, that'll attract the gamers to an always online digital environment......
F2P will have its problems if too many games decide to go that way.
 

AniHawk

Member
Yeah, Valve would never block used game sales!

they'd at least offer affordable games from the start though.

anyway, people have to understand that sony and microsoft are done making video game consoles. they've taken those as far as they wanted. now they're making living room consoles. it's all about controlling entertainment in your living room, and video games are a subset of that.
 

rdrr gnr

Member
they'd at least offer affordable games from the start though.

anyway, people have to understand that sony and microsoft are done making video game consoles. they've taken those as far as they wanted. now they're making living room consoles. it's all about controlling entertainment in your living room, and video games are a subset of that.
That's been the case for years. But context matters: How they do it is important.
 

Eusis

Member
I do wonder if that's a factor for dipping sales this year though? It seems like interest is just being lost, but it may well be people are just playing a lot of these games on their modded 360 unless they NEED to be online, and even then...

Reminds me of how the DS and PSP started to go out. And I'm guessing they and maybe Sony feel the only way to prevent this to go hardcore, even though that'll probably set people off to want to do this MORE. :/
Your upset because an online connection is required and no used games. What's your solution?



Brilliant!
Don't think that'll necessarily require always online, and for used games it's been well covered how bad it got for PC (doing crazy DRM-type crap while we were still on 8-bit consoles at that.) However I do wonder how much game modding will be doable on the Steambox and if people can just get their other Steam games working through Wine, as otherwise just a good PC seems infinitely preferable to me.
 

CLEEK

Member
Please let's not do this again. If the Steambox functions as a PC-like console then it'll still have prices that are amazing compared to the consoles.

So the best option if you want to avoid a console that doesn't allow for used games sales is to buy the Steambox (a console that won't allow used games sales)? Nice one.

And Steam sales don't help matters if you like to buy games new. I can buy cheap console games at retail if I wait for them to go on sale.

You need to change your name, dude.
 

~Kinggi~

Banned
Things MS and Sony might attempt to win favor with this news;

FTP games, expanded with DLC if wanted.
Rental services, monthly payments for game access same as PS+
Cheap hardware price, subsidized methods focusing on services to offset costs.
Discounts for Live subscribers on Digital Direct games released same day as retail.
Multiple versions of same game accross the MS ecosystem for windows 8 users and xbox users...

I dont know, this still isnt turning me on. I want to own shit. If i cant im going steambox for legacy software and cheap prices.
 

AniHawk

Member
That's been the case for years. But context matters: How they do it is important.

they were still trojan horsing it to a degree with the 360 and ps3. it wasn't until the last 3 years or so that they made a bigger push in that direction.

this time they'll be able to launch with a new message, image, and product. it'll be different from the start.
 

Reiko

Banned
Sony: Killzone 4!

Crowd: Yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!! Oh shit! Day one!

Sony: Always Online.

Crowd: Boooooooooo!!!! Fuck that!!!!

Switch the first part with (MS: Halo 5!)
 

~Kinggi~

Banned
Sony: Killzone 4!

Crowd: Yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!! Oh shit! Day one!

Sony: Always Online.

Crowd: Boooooooooo!!!! Fuck that!!!!

Always online announcement i imagine is going to be the thing revealed as journalists get their hands on final review builds after everyone preorders. I dont foresee any of them announcing this as there isnt much positive way to spin it. They will be maximizing that hype and riding it to launch. I would be very surprised if they outright admit to this in an announcement where a stage and audience is present.
 
Hmm, the problem that I see here is if MS and Sony both do this then what is the alternative?

PCs already don't allow for used games and are usually always online by default so there's not much to combat there, Nintendo looks to getting left out of the party once again and any other hardware makers, like Apple or Valve, would most likely have the same policies in place. So where would gamers turn?

MS and Sony (if Sony is really on board) know that after the initial fuss hardcore gamers will cave and buy their systems which is exactly why they're doing this. It will make them tons of extra money and there's no one to stop them or protect gamers from themselves. If you want a good example of how this works out just check the mobile carrier industry. They're constantly making their services less customer friendly and basically telling you if you don't like it then go screw yourself.
 
Top Bottom