• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

EDGE: The next Xbox: Always online, no second-hand games, 50GB Blu-ray and new kinect

jbug617

Banned
You'd have to assume that they wouldn't follow this course of action without a push from publishers, which begs the question, how will they react if Sony doesn't follow suit?

I remember one of the insiders of the next gen racing topic stated that there are rumors of Microsoft having 8 3rd party exclusives around launch window.
 

Deuterium

Member
I would think gamestop. Don't really know.

Wow, I never would have thought this. Certainly, I expect Gamestop has to be the leader for the Used game market...but I find it hard to imagine that Gamestop sells more NEW consoles then any of the following Companies; Amazon, Wallmart, Bestbuy, Target
 

Camp Lo

Banned
You'd have to assume that they wouldn't follow this course of action without a push from publishers, which begs the question, how will they react if Sony doesn't follow suit?

I think Sony has to follow suit or risk alienating themselves from third party but their first party is edging towards Nintendo strong... I think they'll do it

Wow, I never would have thought this. Certainly, I expect Gamestop has to be the leader for the Used game market...but I find it hard to imagine that Gamestop sells more NEW consoles then any of the following Companies; Amazon, Wallmart, Bestbuy, Target

All those trade ins towards new hardware/software. GS has to be on top of sales, used and new.
 

Matt

Member
I wasn't the one that brought it up but I guess you're going to blame me for it right?

This is a response to the idea that Windows 8 seems to be failing while it currently has almost 10 percent of the marketshare even through Steams statistics.

Here is what I'm responding to:

In what world is Steam a good place to go for statistics about the general PC community? If you have Steam installed, you are more likely to have Windows 8, not less.
 

timlot

Banned
Wow, talk about ass backwards thinking. How about not being able to sell your used car to buy a new one. Want a new house? Sure but you can't sell your old one. This crazy idea needs a congressional hearing. No nextgen gaming for me.
 
One thing is for certain, somebody is about to be FUCKED! Here are the three possible scenarios:

1) This article is true, but Sony doesn't also do this: Microsoft killed the Xbox
2) This article is true, but Sony is doing the same thing: Gamestop is DEAD
3) This article is false: Edge just trashed their business
 

Mesoian

Member
With Hulu Plus and Netflix I'm saying the actual monthly memberships for each service is included with Live. As we all know to well, most apps are locked behind the Gold wall, what if those apps were usable regardless if you were Gold or not. However, paying for Gold also paid for the service, so like the $7.99 a month it costs to actually access Netflix regardless of your means is just deferred and you get access since you are a Gold member.
Oh sure, that would be pretty excellent. Honestly I think it's one of the more devious things about Live, people think they're getting netflix or Hulu but are dismayed when they realize it's a seperate cost. But it will NEEEEEEEEEEVER happen, as it's a conflict of interest between the two companies (netflix and hulu). Live has always been a bit of a quagmire when it comes to what's offered versus what being said. 60 bucks a year isn't a lot of money, but you have to offer SOMETHING to make it interesting. I don't think microsoft can simply do what they did this generation and expect to compete, but I think that's what they'd do.
 

Hazelhurst

Member
Wow, talk about ass backwards thinking. How about not being able to sell your used car to buy a new one. Want a new house? Sure but you can't sell your old one. This crazy idea needs a congressional hearing. No nextgen gaming for me.

Have you ever bought anything on Steam, Apple's app store, and/or Google's android marketplace? If not, I respect you sticking with your principles.
 

QaaQer

Member
I remember one of the insiders of the next gen racing topic stated that there are rumors of Microsoft having 8 3rd party exclusives around launch window.

Exclusive as in not on ps3, xbox360, PC, and Orbis? Or exclusive as in, just not on Orbis?

Because if we are looking at games being released on every platform except Orbis because Orbis is the only next-gen platform to allow for used game sales, then that will be very interesting.
 

Hip Hop

Member
Wait, doesn't Gamestop have a good relationship with publishers? I mean, they get all these exclusive pre order bonuses all the time,

and aren't retailers the reason why online prices from Xbox and PSN aren't competitively priced, as they want to keep a good relation with retailers?

Doesn't make sense for Sony or MSoft to destroy Gamestop, or any other retailer that is in the used market business.
 

AzVal

Member
Okay suppose that all that is true, I have some questions

-Could this be reversed if proves a failure?
-Is this the kind of fuck up that could cost a generation to MS?
-how would the "Kinect-Casual" crew to t his?
-How would the Publishers side in term of exclusives?
 

FourMyle

Member
Have you ever bought anything on Steam, Apple's app store, and/or Google's android marketplace? If not, I respect you sticking with your principles.

As has been stated many, many times in this thread: Steam, the App store and the Droid marketplace ALL offered something over physical media. Steam with the regular and MASSIVE discounts, the App stores with the sheer accessibility, cheapness and variety of all the apps over physical release software which dealt with massive manufacturing costs.

Again, name something in "always online, no second hand games & no playing games on your friend's Xbox" that will benefit you and others as customers. And don't even fucking try to suggest that Microsoft is now going to become Steam 2.0 and match all their sales.
 

PKrockin

Member
Most weeks I live on an oil rig with spotty to no internet connection and no wifi. How the hell do you expect me to be able to use your console? Doing away with used games without the Steam's excuse of stopping rampant piracy is despicable as well. Go fuck yourself with a cactus, Microsoft. Last gen all it took for me to buy your console and a library of ~18 games was one good exclusive. You won't be getting my money again.
 

jbug617

Banned
Somebody brought this up in the other Edge topic and remember the Battlefield 4 leak (looking right so far) mention that the game will require an always on internet connection. Wouldn't that mean both consoles are aiming for that.
 
Somebody brought this up in the other Edge topic and remember the Battlefield 4 leak (looking right so far) mention that the game will require an always on internet connection. Wouldn't that mean both consoles are aiming for that.
If true, that could just be an assy EA/Origin thing. That would not surprise me.
 

border

Member
Windows 8 is doing well, it's projected so far to be on pace or faster selling than Windows 7.

Selling 10s of millions of anything in a month is what I would consider doing well.

Microsoft's sales numbers are overwhelmingly comprised of sales to computer OEMs, who buy a certain amount of licenses for future sales of PCs. OEMs buy millions of licenses at a time because they expect to sell millions of computers.

Yet over the holidays, PC sales are actually way down year-over-year.
 

QaaQer

Member
-How would the Publishers side in term of exclusives?

I'm guess the EA type publishers will love this, and do what they can to help it to succeed. They wont risk their businesses over it though. So if the consoles release, and PS4 without exclusives is still selling 2 to 1 or better over 720, the publishers will cave. If people don't care, and 720 has equal to or better sales, then this is the future.

I think one of the things people forget when looking at Steam and the PC is that the average PC gamer is older, with a job, and a credit card. B&M retail is vital for younger people without jobs and a credit card.
 
I'm surprised that 'M$' is not a banned term.

Not pleased with this rumor's "no second-hand games," as console prices tend not to hit PC prices unless games are second-hand. In addition, almost all of my last-gen games are second-hand, because it's next to impossible to find them new.

If I want to experience games I might have missed, but the initial run is done, how am I going to get them? Digitally? Sure, maybe, but A) not all games are available digitally, and B) digital prices on console stores are atrocious.



This is not their stance, it's a law, as I understand it. PC Software is not supposed to be resold. I could be mistaken.

You are mistaken. Go to eBay, there are hundreds or thousands of used PC games for sale.
 

FordGTGuy

Banned
Microsoft's sales numbers are overwhelmingly comprised of sales to computer OEMs, who buy a certain amount of licenses for future sales of PCs. OEMs buy millions of licenses at a time because they expect to sell millions of computers.

Yet over the holidays, PC sales are actually way down year-over-year.

I already showed evidence that Windows 8 almost already has 10% of the Steam community and still rising fast.

I completely realize this and if you'd like to continue this conversation leave me a PM otherwise I do not want to derail this thread.
 

AzVal

Member
I'm guess the EA type publishers will love this, and do what they can to help it to succeed. They wont risk their businesses over it though. So if the consoles release, and PS4 without exclusives is still selling 2 to 1 or better over 720, the publishers will cave. If people don't care, and 720 has equal to or better sales, then this is the future.

I think one of the things people forget when looking at Steam and the PC is that the average PC gamer is older, with a job, and a credit card. B&M retail is vital for younger people without jobs and a credit card.

So if its viable and Sony does it as well we could count with one hand the WiiU multiplats if any...
 
I'm really surprised at how people are just outright disbelieving the article. EDGE would throw their entire reputation out the window if it were blatant lies. It's not worth it for them to play PR games like this, be realistic.
And I'm surprised at all the people outright believing it when everything about it equals brand suicide. I don't believe MS would work as hard as they have to create a popular brand just to take it out back and put a bullet between its eyes. There is so much risk with this move and very little reward.
 
T

thepotatoman

Unconfirmed Member
If true this is completely idiotic and Microsoft (seriously) has shot themselves in the foot.

Nintendo and Sony are both going to succeed a lot due to this decision.

Can't wait to pay my mandatory Xbox Live subscription in order to play my games. Oh wait, I can. Also, great for countries with bandwith caps!

No thanks Microsoft.

The biggest reason to go Xbox 360 was the better online, but sony seems perfectly willing to blatantly copy every last element of Xbox Live, but couldn't because of hardware specifications (specifically the amount they set aside for OS purposes).

Without the Xbox Live advantage, who would choose Xbox with no used games and an online subscription price over a Playstation with neither of those drawbacks? Unless of course Playstation decides to follow suit.
 

Mesoian

Member
Okay suppose that all that is true, I have some questions

-Could this be reversed if proves a failure?
-Is this the kind of fuck up that could cost a generation to MS?
-how would the "Kinect-Casual" crew to t his?
-How would the Publishers side in term of exclusives?

-yes
-If handled incorrectly, yes
-Depends. Like stated before, it effects people who only buy the occational cheap game months after release as a treat or a bonus.
-Most publishers would side with it. However, most publishers are smart enough to see a bad deal coming, so if it's handled wrong initially, there would probably be a stark lack of exclusives going that way.
 

vg260

Member
As has been stated many, many times in this thread: Steam, the App store and the Droid marketplace ALL offered something over physical media. Steam with the regular and MASSIVE discounts, the App stores with the sheer accessibility, cheapness and variety of all the apps over physical release software which dealt with massive manufacturing costs.

Again, name something in "always online, no second hand games & no playing games on your friend's Xbox" that will benefit you and others as customers. And don't even fucking try to suggest that Microsoft is now going to become Steam 2.0 and match all their sales.

Do we know this for sure?
 

Duxxy3

Member
One thing is for certain, somebody is about to be FUCKED! Here are the three possible scenarios:

1) This article is true, but Sony doesn't also do this: Microsoft killed the Xbox
2) This article is true, but Sony is doing the same thing: Gamestop is DEAD
3) This article is false: Edge just trashed their business

Good way to break it down.
 
The outrage in this thread expresses exactly how I feel about region-locking. Why should I be blocked from playing games I've legitimately purchased? It's the same BS.

Not quite the same thing. After all, you can buy the other region's box to play the game. But don't get me wrong: region locking is stupid. It is not, however, as stupid or infuriating as this.
 

Reiko

Banned
One thing is for certain, somebody is about to be FUCKED! Here are the three possible scenarios:

1) This article is true, but Sony doesn't also do this: Microsoft killed the Xbox
2) This article is true, but Sony is doing the same thing: Gamestop is DEAD
3) This article is false: Edge just trashed their business

edge-wwe.gif



okay, what does that have to do with used games? One doesn't necessarily link to the other.

Maybe. I dunno.
 

Bgamer90

Banned
One thing is for certain, somebody is about to be FUCKED! Here are the three possible scenarios:

1) This article is true, but Sony doesn't also do this: Microsoft killed the Xbox
2) This article is true, but Sony is doing the same thing: Gamestop is DEAD
3) This article is false: Edge just trashed their business

Heh, yeah I have a feeling that this will cause some damage somehow.
 

alr1ght

bish gets all the credit :)
One thing is for certain, somebody is about to be FUCKED! Here are the three possible scenarios:

1) This article is true, but Sony doesn't also do this: Microsoft killed the Xbox
2) This article is true, but Sony is doing the same thing: Gamestop is DEAD
3) This article is false: Edge just trashed their business

The other thing for certain, consumers see no benefit.
 
So how many people are mad not because they can't buy used games, but because they can't sell their $60 games for $30 2 mins after they buy it?
 
T

thepotatoman

Unconfirmed Member
We don't know anything for sure. We don't know if any of this is legit as of yet, and won't until Microsoft says otherwise.

It just looks likely

The only way for microsoft to spin this into something not devastating is for them to say "but you guys like steam". That means emulating the best parts of steam too, which should include activation on multiple pieces of hardware. Since the console's always online anyway they can still limit account sharing pretty damn effectively.

I really do think they have incentive to at least give consumers that much. Microsoft isn't that foolish to piss off consumers even more for something so little.
 
Top Bottom