Family of Robert Durst’s First Wife Sues Him for $100 Million in Her Disappearance
If you have not seen HBO's The Jinx, run-do not walk-to your nearest HBO-enabled device and watch it. It's the most fascinating documentary I've ever seen.
Kathleen McCormack Durst disappeared from her home in Westchester County nearly 34 years ago, on a cold January night, only months before she would have graduated from medical school. It was the beginning of an enduring mystery.
On Monday, Ms. Durst’s mother, Ann McCormack, who is 101, and three sisters — Carol Bamonte, Mary Hughes and Virginia McKeon — filed a $100 million lawsuit against the man they have long suspected of killing her: Robert A. Durst, her husband. The lawsuit contends that Mr. Durst violated the McCormack family’s right to sepulcher, a rarely used New York law granting family members the immediate right to possession of a body for burial.
“The family’s priority has been and continues to be to provide Kathleen with a proper and dignified burial,” Robert Abrams, a lawyer for the McCormack family, said.
The lawsuit contends that Mr. Durst “murdered Kathleen,” 29, his first wife. If successful, the lawsuit would strip Mr. Durst of much of his wealth; authorities put his net worth at about $100 million.
The lawsuit, filed in State Supreme Court in Mineola, N.Y., is only the latest development in Mr. Durst’s legal troubles since he agreed to cooperate with the producers of a six-part documentary, “The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst,” that was broadcast on HBO in February and March.
For a long time after Ms. Durst disappeared, Mr. Durst led a carefree, peripatetic life that took him from New York to Los Angeles to Houston and back again, fueled by a constant flow of cash from his estranged family’s real estate empire in New York City.
Mr. Durst, 72, has been in prison in New Orleans since March on a gun charge. He is expected to be sentenced on Dec. 17 to more than five years in prison after acknowledging his guilt in that case, according to people briefed on the negotiations but not authorized to discuss them.
Mr. Durst’s lawyer, Dick DeGuerin, declined to discuss the pending plea bargain. “We’re not going to comment on it until the day it happens,” he said.
The documentary, which explored his connection to the deaths of Ms. Berman, the decapitation of a boardinghouse neighbor in Texas, and the disappearance of his wife, concluded with Mr. Durst’s own whispered words: “What the hell did I do? Killed them all, of course.”
Less than 24 hours before the broadcast of the final episode, Mr. Durst was arrested in New Orleans on a first-degree-murder warrant from Los Angeles. Investigators discovered that Mr. Durst had a fake identification card, a latex mask, thousands of dollars in cash and a handgun in the pocket of a coat hanging in his hotel room.
Contrary to Mr. Durst’s calculation, the Los Angeles district attorney’s office had reopened the investigation into the murder of Ms. Berman, helped in part by information from the producers of “The Jinx.”
Investigators in Los Angeles had been tracking Mr. Durst’s movements and, fearing he was about to flee the country, obtained a murder warrant on March 11. Detectives found Mr. Durst three days later in New Orleans, where he had registered at a hotel under an assumed name.
After Ms. Durst’s disappearance, investigators initially made little headway. In “The Jinx,” Mr. Durst conceded that he had not told the truth about his whereabouts on the night his wife disappeared, but professed no knowledge of what happened. He obtained a divorce in 1990.
Mr. Durst sought his first wife’s $123,670 estate, but a Surrogate’s Court judge ruled in November 2001 that a portion would go to Ms. Durst’s mother and Mr. Durst’s share would be placed in escrow until the authorities determined whether he was culpable in Ms. Durst’s death. In 2013, Mr. Durst was again unsuccessful in obtaining a share of the estate.
If you have not seen HBO's The Jinx, run-do not walk-to your nearest HBO-enabled device and watch it. It's the most fascinating documentary I've ever seen.