OmegaDL50
Member
Hmmm... GAF players, what are your thoughts about the remastered OST? I began to listen to it by curiosity, and I'm not quite convinced by what I'm hearing. The Remastered version of "A Fleeting Dream / Someday the Dream Will End" in particular made me cringe actually.
I've posted this before but...
The original wasn't a real recording. The resonance and reverb sounded really fake, the performance was wooden and the piano soundset sounded a bit "metallic".
New one is much more natural. I'm glad they didn't change much but just upgraded the track's sonic qualities because the original soundtrack for Final Fantasy X and X-2 are in PSF2 format, which is not unlike a midi synthesis which uses set of soundbank samples and is not a studio recording saved to a wave form or mpeg audio or even ADX which some games with pre-recorded music with live instruments are done.
You can read up on it here - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portable_Sound_Format
The fact that FFX and X-2 HD Remaster are now using higher quality instrumentation and not using the PS2-engine based synth is a significant improvement.
The original FFX does have streamed audio with live recordings for 10+ tracks though. For some reason, Mostly the Hymn of the Faith. Surprisingly To Zanarkand wasn't one of them. (Yes the Piano intro from FFX wasn't real piano but rather basically PSF-based midi synthesis instead of a live piano recording)
Based on the Besaid and Battle Themes, the remasters seem to mostly be using VSTis and only a few live instruments, but today's high-end samples and soundsets are so much better than the almost 15 years old PS2 chip's soundsets.
Some people will dislike the changes, for me though, being a regular user of FL Studio, Impulse Tracker and other music creation software, I like the fact they went to the effort of revising and using higher quality samples used for FFX, instead of just recording the original samples to wav and just slapping them on the disc as is.
Although I suppose for some the option of having the original would be nice for those who want the choice to swap between the two. Of course some don't think the remasters audio wasn't executed well, but 2 of the 3 original artists handed the soundtrack, with Uematsu apparently supervising, so it's not like the original artists intent was lacking when the remasters were done