I've heard MLB: The Show is amazingly authentic and full-featured, but, you know, fuck baseball.
The football game genre really does need either Konami to step up their game (give them 2 years to make one for fuck's sake) or EA to for some reason stop resting on their laurels. EA won't do that without competition though, and I don't for one second believe that the PES team are capable of that these days.
It would be amazing if someone came from out of the blue like a good version of This Is Football. I know I bang on about this, but I genuinely believe that people would realise what a pile of shite FIFA is if they had a good new football game to compare it to.
Its one of those games where I honestly just can't fathom how people can abide by the loose gameplay/animation and shitty physics. I'm not trying to say that my opinion is more correct than others, but...it kind of is.