Aren't we in day 6?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Gafia 3 [Mafia] | Welcome to Lynchwood Acres
- Thread starter Ourobolus
- Start date
Aren't we in day 6?
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
As in that's who I'm blocking tonight should I live
Bronx didn't work so I kept my shots
Bronx didn't work so I kept my shots
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I am 5 shot. So I only have one left.
I'm using it on splinter tonight.
I'm using it on splinter tonight.
Shouldn't you have two shots left with this logic...
Tell that to TWE.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I tried. Was blocked.
So there's two roleblockers now?
And shouldn't you have now THREE shots left?
Yeah yeah too late to worry about it. I guess at least 1 of you is scum anyway.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Fuck it. Lynch me if you want.
I'm not a doc. I had to think of something on the fly and I fucked it cause I'm drinking.
I'm Rats Off To Ya. Not town.
Neutral survivor. 3 shot BP. I have no shots left so it's whatever.
I fakeclaimed bexause I knew neutrals are bad and especially survivors can be a weird play. They either play with town or they don't. So it's your call. I just want to win, I don't give a shit who makes it to the end.
I'm not a doc. I had to think of something on the fly and I fucked it cause I'm drinking.
I'm Rats Off To Ya. Not town.
Neutral survivor. 3 shot BP. I have no shots left so it's whatever.
I fakeclaimed bexause I knew neutrals are bad and especially survivors can be a weird play. They either play with town or they don't. So it's your call. I just want to win, I don't give a shit who makes it to the end.
We haven't heard from every claimer yet. That's the one point that is stopping me, I guess. Why would scum claim a doctor? Are they scared of doctor ruining future nights, with numbers dwindling (and most likely strongman shots running out)?
I think that TWE is scum but it both could be town. Scum are 4 at most (if they were 5 it would be game over already) and mayority is 6. They need 2 townie votes to turbo.
Okay, Kyan peacing out of the game sucks for us. It does explain all of the unresolved night actions as far as I recall though.
1. *Splinter [m]
2. Burbeting [m]
3. franconp [m]
4. Kawl_USC [m]
5. TheWorthyEdge [m]
6. CCS [m]
7. WhereAreMahDragonz [f]
8. OceanicAir [m] -> replaced by flatearthpandas [m]
9. StanleyPalmtree [m]
10. gryvan [m] -> Gorlak [m]
Burb is clear obviously.
I'm less sure on splinter, especially in light of his not a cop deal here today.
Could be a ballsy scum play yesterday? Don't think splinter is a top contender today regardless.
Fran had some weird comments today that feel off he's creeping up my list.
TWE I still find suspicious, I need to look at how the votes shifted on Swamped but it felt kind of abrupt there at the days end, though I'm pretty sure Faddy and burb were two of the last votes in, so there may not be as much as I'm thinking to see here.
CCS,
1. *Splinter [m]
2. Burbeting [m]
3. franconp [m]
4. Kawl_USC [m]
5. TheWorthyEdge [m]
6. CCS [m]
7. WhereAreMahDragonz [f]
8. OceanicAir [m] -> replaced by flatearthpandas [m]
9. StanleyPalmtree [m]
10. gryvan [m] -> Gorlak [m]
Burb is clear obviously.
I'm less sure on splinter, especially in light of his not a cop deal here today.
Could be a ballsy scum play yesterday? Don't think splinter is a top contender today regardless.
Fran had some weird comments today that feel off he's creeping up my list.
TWE I still find suspicious, I need to look at how the votes shifted on Swamped but it felt kind of abrupt there at the days end, though I'm pretty sure Faddy and burb were two of the last votes in, so there may not be as much as I'm thinking to see here.
CCS,
Why didn't you claim ordinary, if you actually were a survivor?
🤔
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Because everyone fucking claims ordinary. Just look at the last page, three in a row. There's no way this game has that many ordinaries
So? The worst outcome for a survivor is to claim a doctor, that will be
a) either nightkilled by scum
b) get counter-claimed by town, and then you would be lynched.
It's the literally worst claim you could have made at this situation. Why should I trust this claim?
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
it was a risk I had to take. I figured that since scum have been so erratic with their kills that they would focus on someone not expected, just in case there is a protective role.
We haven't had a protective role since Bronx. I don't believe that everyone is ordinary but it was a role I felt wouldn't be counterclaimed because of the risk it brings. A real doc would want to avoid a NK and would probably let me flip on my own time.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I don't know how many scum there are. If there are four as you say, then that leaves 6 town. 6 outnumbers 4.
No, a doctor would counter claim. Because today is perhaps LYLO, but at the very least MYLO. Town has to succeed today.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
It was a risk. If they claimed I would have told the truth and voted with town
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Then don't vote for me. We both win.
Even if there weren't a counter claim, you would have been night killed next night, before scum would have won. Because you know, doctor claim.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Not necessarily. Roleblock is more likely
Why, when they would just roleblock Splinter instead?
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Would you rather kill the pseudo cop or the sketchy doc claim thad would probs be lynched during the day?
If there were no counter doc claim (in this scenario there wouldn't, since if there was one, you would have been already lynched), the scum would have no real reason to not believe you. Mind you, you made your claim before you were asked about your night actions. Only those made you look actually sketchy.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Mhmm, all valid points. I reasoned it out as best I could.
Are you believing the claim? I don't.
Something bothers me. I need her to respond before I go into detail.
Also Dragonz, paraphrase maybe some details from your role flavor too. Since all roles seem to have that.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I am Rats Off To Ya, an antisocial hermit.
Role flavor is all about how I hate the young people and my fellow residents and want to stay out of everyone else's business. All I want is to be left alone in solitude
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I'm watching intervention with my mom and she was mad that I kept looking at my phone
Right.
So Fran, what bothers is me is that the scum most definitely have fake claim names, right? And they must have organised at least a little about who scum should pick what.
So why would they choose to use Rats as a doctor claim out of all things? The name doesn't fit, and it was one of the little things that bothered me with Dragonz original claim. But it would fit a neutral survivor more.
But that could also mean that the scum were going to have dragonz claim survivor, and had her do this doctor claim just to veer out a counter claim from the real doctor.
So Fran, what bothers is me is that the scum most definitely have fake claim names, right? And they must have organised at least a little about who scum should pick what.
So why would they choose to use Rats as a doctor claim out of all things? The name doesn't fit, and it was one of the little things that bothered me with Dragonz original claim. But it would fit a neutral survivor more.
But that could also mean that the scum were going to have dragonz claim survivor, and had her do this doctor claim just to veer out a counter claim from the real doctor.
Why would they have fake name claims? Names can't be asociated with an aligment. Not in this game. I think that she is Rats as it's too risky to claim a name you don't have (remember Ouro in Overwatch), but I don't believe in her claim.
It's a common practice in games.
Ouro, does scum have fake names given in this game? Or is this information you cannot give?
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
If I were on a scum team do you honestly think they'd have me claim a neutral
I've played scum a few times and we ALWAYS claim vanilla. Hence why I don't trust anyone who claimed on the last page.