Some games have had scum claim their power roles, but modified to fit town role more. That's why your slips towards "blocking someone" seem pretty bad.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Gafia 3 [Mafia] | Welcome to Lynchwood Acres
- Thread starter Ourobolus
- Start date
Some games have had scum claim their power roles, but modified to fit town role more. That's why your slips towards "blocking someone" seem pretty bad.
I cannot provide that information.
I see.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I fucked up and had to try to fix it on the fly. I'm a neutral survivor. 3 shot BP. That's all I've got.
Let's say I believe you (and I don't). How does the 3 shot BP works? Can you give BP? Who did you gave one?
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Nope, it's all for me. I choose a night to use it and if I'm attacked, I don't die.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
If you want specifics the command is LOCK DOOR. No one can come into hurt me during the night. I'm still targetable by other actions though.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
Everybody that's been in this game has had a role name that corresponds with someone else in the game.
Rats of to Ya wasn't in this game.
Rats of to Ya wasn't in this game.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
Umless ouro is doing something super crazy (and really cool)
The role names would have been decided well before the sign ups finished. No way in hell is making calls based on role names a good idea right now.
This isn't correct. Not sure if this is the case for anyone who's flipped, but I'm Barrylocke.
Also, I don't buy WAMD as neutral one bit.
flatearthpandas
Member
I think scum just feel bad for us this game, holy fuck.
flatearthpandas
Member
Not only that, acohrs flipped as me. But i was a sub in this game. He would have had to change acohrs flip.
flatearthpandas
Member
"Not only that" was referring to a second quote i forgot to include. But the theory is no good. There is no wifom on this.
I don't think there are fake claims in Gafia because they aren't needed - names aren't at all indicative of alignment. I assume WAMD is ROTY and just lying about everything else.
Besides, ROTY has been a doc before. Gafia 1 I think?
Anyway, this claim is obviously nonsense, the only concern now is whether or not it was intentionally botched.
FEP claimed Mazre
Fran claimed GreatCharleston(!)
I claimed NeverForever
Why didn't you mention these?
It's an interesting observation, but can't be more than a coincidence
I'm Kawl_USC, ordinary.
---
I get legit constructed crab scum slip vibes from Dragonz claim. Splinter and fran both qualify as the counter part.
Dragonz is full of shit. Lynch bomb is possible. I'm in favour of TWE voting her last. I can see a connection between these two. There was this weird town read TWE had on Dragonz and they both never voted together the whole game.
Splinter's claim leaves us with nothing. I can see the case for scum fucking up one claim big time to let the other go unnoticed. We already had a (neutral) joat flipping as well and he lied about his role (but that's what splinter probably often does, so not that big of an argument).
I'm surprised by fep's non-answer, because he casually reversed his read today and doesn't bother to give any explanation:
Mind you he voted twe, and is backing off now. Closer look required.
---
I get legit constructed crab scum slip vibes from Dragonz claim. Splinter and fran both qualify as the counter part.
Dragonz is full of shit. Lynch bomb is possible. I'm in favour of TWE voting her last. I can see a connection between these two. There was this weird town read TWE had on Dragonz and they both never voted together the whole game.
Splinter's claim leaves us with nothing. I can see the case for scum fucking up one claim big time to let the other go unnoticed. We already had a (neutral) joat flipping as well and he lied about his role (but that's what splinter probably often does, so not that big of an argument).
I'm surprised by fep's non-answer, because he casually reversed his read today and doesn't bother to give any explanation:
Mind you he voted twe, and is backing off now. Closer look required.
She already changed her claim at that point, why did you feel the need to do this?
flatearthpandas
Member
I didn't really reverse read, i just put him into null, leaning scum still.
Can you explain the bolded? I don't know what Crab slip you are referring to or what the "counter part" means.
Also I don't think I lied about my role? I just left out info and let people come to the wrong conclusion, and I've already explained the point of that
Yeah its a weird post. He also makes some excuse about "typing for too long and not refreshing the page", but his previous post has clearly been interrupted?
There is also this one which is over-sure about the number of scum.
Also I missed this one before, but WAMD claims neutral and then forgets to count a neutral
thinking_emoji
.I hadn't seen it at that point. I refreshed thread and saw the x shot doctor claim and burbs post saying without a counter claim that was reasonable.
This is pretty obviously lylo so there was no way I wasn't going to counter that.
I wish I had read the ridiculous shit that came out past that but fuck me
If there is 5 scum left this game is already over barring some miracle. 4 scum to start in a game this large would typically have more kills at their disposal than we've seen. It's basic balancing and logic to parse the overwhelming likely number of scum.
4 to start is entirely possible. There have been at least 2 poison shots and an extra neutral kill in the game. I agree that 5 is more likely but we had 4 in Danganronpa with less firepower than that.
Meh, This feels like some kind of cheap "gotcha!" splint which makes me a little uneasy about you. Town won't lynch survivors at this point because it has very likely* no mislynches to spare. No way does survivor claim doc.
Dude what
In what world do we vote for anyone beyond dragonz? This isn't even a discussion.
Only thing left to do is make sure we get opinions on those most likely to be targeted, decide on who hammers in case of lynch bomb, and get a move on.
Haven't we run these numbers enough times to know this isn't true?
5-1-4 = we are alreadydead.gif
6-1-3 = we can lynch the neutral and remain in mylo
and yes, no survivor claims doc at this point. Don't try to make it look like I'm arguing against that.
In a world where both are scum? I'm om mobile but look how TWE interacted with WAMD. He said she was the only town by gut-feeling and then backtracked to null. Seems scum partners to me.
Hmm its pretty scummy...
...but not as scummy as shouting "I AM SCUM" over and over for an entire page
I think we will proooobably lynch WAMD today
I agree. I said I want to lynch WAMD before TWE but put both as Burb seemed to have doubts still.
The first situation is the more likely one if there were to actually be a neutral survivor. But it's not game over as scum has to either equal or outnumber non scum to win game. Since there exists game states in which that's possible town can't safely lynch the survivor if you believe the claim as that becomes an auto loss. Sure if it's actually only 3 scum remaining it isn't game, but why risk it. Most likely it just ends in a heist situation. And we all know how garbage that game was.
Yea sorry that wasn't fair I didn't mean to misrepresent your argument.
Hmmmmm
I'm just not sure. It's like she's trying to tell us something....
But I just can't quite make it out.
Oh well, it's probably nothing. Guess we should lynch burb instead.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I mean I'm an extra vote for town but whatever
I'll follow Burb
I'll follow Burb
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Let's put it this way. Assuming there are 4 scum, that leaves 5 town, one neutral left. So you've only got one chance to lynch today, because with a town mislynch, scum will get the final kill tonight. Or, if you lynch me instead, that still puts town back a day. You will still lose if you lynch me.
Or, you could vote for an actual scum read. Then with the night kill tonight, town would have to hit scum 3 days. But at least with me, you'll have the extra vote to go down the list. Eventually you're gonna hit mafia, it's just a matter of time.
My reasoning for siding with town is this. I don't know who scum is. I have no fucking clue. But I know that Burb is confirmed and I know Splinter is semi confirmed. More confirmed with Faddy's flip. It's a better bet for me to go with a sure thing than a what if.
Or, you could vote for an actual scum read. Then with the night kill tonight, town would have to hit scum 3 days. But at least with me, you'll have the extra vote to go down the list. Eventually you're gonna hit mafia, it's just a matter of time.
My reasoning for siding with town is this. I don't know who scum is. I have no fucking clue. But I know that Burb is confirmed and I know Splinter is semi confirmed. More confirmed with Faddy's flip. It's a better bet for me to go with a sure thing than a what if.
Can you vote yourself Dragonz?
Best to leave Burb out of that lynch. I suggest Kawl as first (or second if WAMD goes first) and TWE as last. Think I want Splinter on the lynch as well, that leaves two more spots. Two of Stan, Fran, fep, CCS and me. Think any two of the others are fine.
Best to leave Burb out of that lynch. I suggest Kawl as first (or second if WAMD goes first) and TWE as last. Think I want Splinter on the lynch as well, that leaves two more spots. Two of Stan, Fran, fep, CCS and me. Think any two of the others are fine.
TWE was the second issue, the first one was your reversal on me (town to scum) and no reasons.
It felt like you lied, but it could be true that you left things open nd everyone went with certain assumptions. Hmpf, doesn't make you more believable though. One more question concerning your targets: Why protect Bronx N3?
And in response to your first question:
In Mini 3 Crab was scumread and close to being lynched, he fabricated a fake claim with one more target than nights were played (just like WAMD did here). He desperately urged his mates in scumchat to grab them townie points by calling this mistake out and CzarTim got 'em all, riding it to victory (obviously wasn't the sole reason, but you get the idea).
I'm wondering if something like this went down here. We got Burb (specifically calling out the term blocked) and can neglect this. Almost at the same time you react with your smiley, you overuse in this game much. Fran calls out N6 first, but I can't tell if you saw that or posted your callout at the same time - hit the respond button right again after the smiley i.e. or sth. like that.
Basically your's and Fran's immediate reaction don't sit well with me because of this trauma in the last game.
Actually that's enough of a reason for me that I want to see fran on the Dragonz lynch as well.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
As if I'd sabotage myself by voting myself. That actively goes against my win con.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I used my BP nights 1, 3, and 4.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Where is everyone
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I see how it is
