• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Game of Thrones *NO BOOK SPOILERS* |OT| Season 4 - Sundays on HBO [Read the OP]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, it is partially HBOs fault for trusting GRRM to deliver in a timely fashion. But I put a lot of the blame on him because it sounds like he misses deadlines all the time for his books. Michael Lombardo, the president of HBO programming, has stated he doesn't want to put the show on hiatus as they could lose key talent. From what I've read, GRRM has told Weiss and Benoiff the last couple arcs already so they know the end game. Would be interesting if HBO branches the show off on their own with perhaps only GRRM notes.

Can you imagine people spoiling in the book thread if that comes to fruition?

I would never
 

Pepiope

Member
7aEqYzb.png
 

aravuus

Member
No summons, be they dragons or knights of the round can withstand a supernova.

In that case he'd end the show fairly prematurely lol, killing everyone on the planet.

Made me start a new FF VII playthrough btw so thanks for that guys, now I'm not as bored as I was 10 minutes ago
 
I dont believe Tyrion will die. He is too important to the story.
My theories for his escape...

1. Shae will somehow spring him from prison

2. Jamie will somehow spring him from prison.

3. Old lady Martell will come clean to Tywin and Cersei on murdering the king, knowing that the Lanisters are broke and needing her familys money (from the upcoming marriage), she will escape punishment.
 

TronLight

Everybody is Mikkelsexual
I dont believe Tyrion will die. He is too important to the story.
My theories for his escape...

1. Shae will somehow spring him from prison

2. Jamie will somehow spring him from prison.

3. Old lady Martell will come clean to Tywin and Cersei on murdering the king, knowing that the Lanisters are broke and needing her familys money (from the upcoming marriage), she will escape punishment.

But not Cercei's wrath.
And Tywin doesn't really care if Tyrion really did it or not, he just wants to get rid of him, so he'll probably pretend not to have heard her.
 

Cyan

Banned
I hope fucking hope Tyrion dies. I just want to see if GRRM has the guts to kill off a character he's been developing for so long. There are certain characters in my mind which I see as the main characters: Jon, Tyrion, Bran, Arya, Dany, Jaimie, P.Baelish, Sansa and Varys. It would really impress me on GRRM's part if he kills one or two of these characters before the end of this season, otherwise GOT is too predictable.

Right? It's ridiculous how all the people he's killed just aren't major characters anymore.
 

poppabk

Cheeks Spread for Digital Only Future
The Hound was clutching at his wound last episode. :( And Arya says "You should have let me burn off the flesh" or something like that. So worried that's a setup for a major disease.
The Mountain will probably survive and capture Rickon. The Mountain, Rickon in tow, will be on his way to fight the Hound, with Arya alongside him. A day before they would meet the Hound will die of sepsis, and Arya will leave, just missing her brother.
 

Nameless

Member
I hope fucking hope Tyrion dies. I just want to see if GRRM has the guts to kill off a character he's been developing for so long. There are certain characters in my mind which I see as the main characters: Jon, Tyrion, Bran, Arya, Dany, Jaimie, P.Baelish, Sansa and Varys. It would really impress me on GRRM's part if he kills one or two of these characters before the end of this season, otherwise GOT is too predictable.

tumblr_m9moqoVhyO1rtf7rf.gif
 

Nekofrog

Banned
I don't know, with everything that has happened the Hound's wound feels like a red herring to me. Sure we've seen it before, but I think that's why he's going to be okay. Because we've seen it before.

He might take a turn for the worse for a while and be on the verge of dying, but something tells me he'll pull through.

or it could just be my wishful thinking :(
 

BraXzy

Member
I've decided. This is my least liked season so far. Besides the wedding and Joffreys death, this episoded, and the odd scene here and there (shout out to Oberyn and Arya/Hound) I haven't really enjoyed much that has happened. I can't even remember half of what has happened because I wasn't too into it.

Dany's storyline, as has been said repeatedly is getting really dull and needs to go somewhere soon. I hate the bolton's and the Reek storyline puts a bad taste in my mouth. Sure it is meant to but I don't enjoy watching any of it. The whodunnit over Joffreys death was fun while it lasted but then the cat came out of the bag and it was a long wait till the trial.

It just seems like barely anything has happened. I know stuff has but, nothing that had my full attention at least.

For me, Season 1 was awesome because it was the first look into this world and all of the political intrigue and characters were all fresh and exciting. It was fun following along trying to get used to King's Landing in much the same way that Ned Stark was doing in the show. That didn't turn out so well but his end was shocking and unexpected.

I liked Season 2 just as much, the war was in full swing and we had all sorts of things going on with the Starks like Arya's journey. Dany's storyline was interesting with the Dothraki, and we got to see some new places like Quarth. We were introduced to interesting characters like Pyat Pree from the House of the Undying. Tyrion was featured a lot and he had some great scenes, and then there was the battle of Blackwater. Stannis wasn't quite so dull and Melisandre had the whole baby thing going on. Brienne and Jamie's pairing started, and they were almost as brilliant as the Hound and Arya. Plus who can forget Hot Pie?

Season 3 gave us more Brienne and Jamie AND we get the pairing of the Hound and Arya. Before that Arya, Gendry and Hot Pie's struggle in captivity was quite interesting to watch. Jamie's good side arc begins and then gets his hand cut off, ouch! The Stark drama in the war wasn't quite so good this season but it wasn't too bad. I really enjoyed Jon Snow's time 'beyond the wall' with the Wildlings. Things seemed to start ramping up all around, and even Bran's storyline seemed to kick off a little. Then the Red Wedding happens and as shocking as it was I think it was the point at which the 'good guys never win' shtick ceased to be shocking or unexpected.

Compared to the previous seasons.. this one just feels.. slow? Not much seems to have progressed. We all know what episode 9 is like in a season so I really hope a tonne of shit goes down.
 

Ovid

Member
I dont believe Tyrion will die. He is too important to the story.
My theories for his escape...

1. Shae will somehow spring him from prison

2. Jamie will somehow spring him from prison.

3. Old lady Martell will come clean to Tywin and Cersei on murdering the king, knowing that the Lanisters are broke and needing her familys money (from the upcoming marriage), she will escape punishment.

None of those seem likely at all. Especially #3.
 

Nameless

Member
I don't think Bran or Rickon are coming back anytime soon to claim Winterfell.

There's no way Greatjon Umber doesn't groom Rickon to retake Winterfell. He's as North as it gets and will never be loyal to Roose or the Crown after what happened to Ned, Robb and Cat.
 

Raynes

Member
Right? It's ridiculous how all the people he's killed just aren't major characters anymore.

No need to be bitter, I was only giving my point of view. GRRM has focused on those characters in particular, they've gone through great development changing massively as people. Whilst characters like Joffrey and Ned did not do any adapting, they never felt like main characters (I did not say "major", brodog) to begin with.
 

Nameless

Member
No need to be bitter, I was only giving my point of view. GRRM has focused on those characters in particular, they've gone through great development changing massively as people. Whilst characters like Joffrey and Ned did not do any adapting, they never felt like main characters (I did not say "major" brodog) to begin with.

Our Liege Lord Eddard Stark was definitely the main character.
 

Cyan

Banned
No need to be bitter, I was only giving my point of view. GRRM has focused on those characters in particular, they've gone through great development changing massively as people. Whilst characters like Joffrey and Ned did not do any adapting, they never felt like main characters (I did not say "major", brodog) to begin with.

I'm not mad or anything, it just seems a little silly to say "well obviously the people killed weren't main characters," because that's really only true because they were killed. That's all I was pointing out.
 

Blader

Member
No need to be bitter, I was only giving my point of view. GRRM has focused on those characters in particular, they've gone through great development changing massively as people. Whilst characters like Joffrey and Ned did not do any adapting, they never felt like main characters (I did not say "major", brodog) to begin with.

Well, Ned had comparatively little room to grow and adapt as a character due to the untimely loss of his head early in the show.
 

Raynes

Member
I'm not mad or anything, it just seems a little silly to say "well obviously the people killed weren't main characters," because that's really only true because they were killed. That's all I was pointing out.

Well that's not what I said was it? I've not just said "they've died therefore they're not main characters", I made a distinction and said those that did die didn't get a lot of development, and from the reckless decisions they've made they've ended up dead. They can also be compared to characters who aren't on the list of names I've given.
 

Cyan

Banned
Well that's not what I said was it? I've not just said "they've died therefore they're not main characters", I made a distinction and said those that did die didn't get a lot of development, and from the reckless decisions they've made they've ended up dead.

Your argument was that the show is predictable because no main characters have been killed. This is only true in retrospect. Prior to their deaths, most would have considered Ned, Robb, and Cat to be main characters.
 

Raynes

Member
Your argument was that the show is predictable because no main characters have been killed. This is only true in retrospect. Prior to their deaths, most would have considered Ned, Robb, and Cat to be main characters.

Of course you are not going to believe me when I say I predicted those deaths. I am not making an empty point, because I do compare them to the characters who aren't on my survival list. They all seem to have something in common, a feeling like their death is very imminent. I just can't see that with my survival characters.
 
There's no way Greatjon Umber doesn't groom Rickon to retake Winterfell. He's as North as it gets and will never be loyal to Roose or the Crown after what happened to Ned, Robb and Cat.

I agree with this.

We haven't seen anything from Rickon in a long time, so I can only assume his journey is going along as expected until the show gives us more scenes. If he makes it to Greatjon alive I have not doubt it will sooner or later lead to a northern uprising of some sort.
 
The Hound is on Arya's list. Ever since she said it in front of him, I've expected her to be the one to kill him, and this would seem to be an appropriate way of doing it since they seem to have developed a friendship.

Or maybe she still harbours ill will towards him and will leave him to suffer a long and painful death?
 
I've decided. This is my least liked season so far. Besides the wedding and Joffreys death, this episoded, and the odd scene here and there (shout out to Oberyn and Arya/Hound) I haven't really enjoyed much that has happened. I can't even remember half of what has happened because I wasn't too into it.

Dany's storyline, as has been said repeatedly is getting really dull and needs to go somewhere soon. I hate the bolton's and the Reek storyline puts a bad taste in my mouth. Sure it is meant to but I don't enjoy watching any of it. The whodunnit over Joffreys death was fun while it lasted but then the cat came out of the bag and it was a long wait till the trial.

It just seems like barely anything has happened. I know stuff has but, nothing that had my full attention at least.

For me, Season 1 was awesome because it was the first look into this world and all of the political intrigue and characters were all fresh and exciting. It was fun following along trying to get used to King's Landing in much the same way that Ned Stark was doing in the show. That didn't turn out so well but his end was shocking and unexpected.

I liked Season 2 just as much, the war was in full swing and we had all sorts of things going on with the Starks like Arya's journey. Dany's storyline was interesting with the Dothraki, and we got to see some new places like Quarth. We were introduced to interesting characters like Pyat Pree from the House of the Undying. Tyrion was featured a lot and he had some great scenes, and then there was the battle of Blackwater. Stannis wasn't quite so dull and Melisandre had the whole baby thing going on. Brienne and Jamie's pairing started, and they were almost as brilliant as the Hound and Arya. Plus who can forget Hot Pie?

Season 3 gave us more Brienne and Jamie AND we get the pairing of the Hound and Arya. Before that Arya, Gendry and Hot Pie's struggle in captivity was quite interesting to watch. Jamie's good side arc begins and then gets his hand cut off, ouch! The Stark drama in the war wasn't quite so good this season but it wasn't too bad. I really enjoyed Jon Snow's time 'beyond the wall' with the Wildlings. Things seemed to start ramping up all around, and even Bran's storyline seemed to kick off a little. Then the Red Wedding happens and as shocking as it was I think it was the point at which the 'good guys never win' shtick ceased to be shocking or unexpected.

Compared to the previous seasons.. this one just feels.. slow? Not much seems to have progressed. We all know what episode 9 is like in a season so I really hope a tonne of shit goes down.
How has not much progressed and seems slow? The wildlings have taken 2 seasons to finally come, Jaime has turned almost into an enemy at this rate with sister and father, breaking the Lannister family into two, last Kingdom introduced by one of the biggest badasses who is likely going to bring them into the fold after his death (only Kingdom not to be conquered), Arya has transformed into a straight up killer after killing that one person in season 3, Sansa has gotten one of the biggest character developments of any character this season, got away from King's Landing and stopped being a crybaby all the while forming an alliance with Littlefinger (who actually saw this coming?).. Littlefinger has come out of the shadows to learn that he's the biggest player of the game being the reason the series started, and he kills Lysa after marrying her while simultaneously putting moves on Sansa and grooming Robin to be one of the 7 Kingdom Lords who will be under his command. Joffrey died, and Stannis stoped sulking like a bitch and looks to either be going to King's Landing or hitting up the Wall, Shae the whore turned on Tyrion, and Bron may have possibly also left him with him potentially losing all 3 of his circle as well as wife all in one season, Jon Snow started to become a man like Rob/his father, and we finally had an episode that Bran was interesting since the premiere episode of the season.

The only people in transition are Brianne and Pod which is fine as long as it's for one season and they meet one of the Starks.. eventually next season. The Hound/Arya is also in transition but we still got a lot of depth for her. As long as she's not walking around next season, I'm ok with it. The main issue is Danny being more boring than last season and getting more unlikable by the episode (for me), but at least we still got Sir Friendzone not even being a friend anymore, with his plot out in the open which is more interesting prospect that Danny's entire plot since S3E5. We still have two more episodes left, 20% left after all of this.

I understand not liking it, but this season has had a lot of things happening and saying otherwise is pretty crazy to me. To me season 2 is by far the weakest IMO, but still pretty fantastic season nonetheless. Season 4 is shaping up to be the best one yet for me, which is saying something considering there's two episodes including episode 9 left. We usually get 3-4 really great episodes per season, but this year we've got 2 and 6, 7 & 8 so far for me. To each his own I suppose. ;)
 

Ichi_

Neo Member
I've decided...

Compared to the previous seasons.. this one just feels.. slow? Not much seems to have progressed. We all know what episode 9 is like in a season so I really hope a tonne of shit goes down.

Just to point out, we still got two more episodes, so I'd hold on to your hat for now before you hang it up ;) Usually the biggest episodes (ned's head, blackwater battle, red wedding) are the 9th episode. Those other great seasons also had many slow moving parts, Mah dragons saga, theon torture porn, ect.
 

BokehKing

Banned
A whole episode at the Wall
You know what that means?
They will actually show a battle finally
We haven't had a good one since black water (as in more than one on one figbts)
 

cormack12

Gold Member
^Don't think we have found out for sure. The only hint we have to go on is Varys spent time over there and he is a eunuch. When he spoke of it he says 'root and stem' were taken which would indicate both. However, there is still a chance the unsullied were treated differently.
 
Heh, there's a lot of things from GoT that already don't look out of place in Dragon Age... like the run-down, unappreciated Night's Watch protecting the realm from the White Walkers who live in the wilds to the far north even though the people don't believe in them any more.

Oops, correction: I meant to say the run-down, unappreciated Grey Wardens protecting the realm from the Darkspawn who live in the wilds to the far south even though the people don't believe in them any more.

At least Dragon Age has a happy ending. :(
 

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
How has not much progressed and seems slow? The wildlings have taken 2 seasons to finally come, Jaime has turned almost into an enemy at this rate with sister and father, breaking the Lannister family into two, last Kingdom introduced by one of the biggest badasses who is likely going to bring them into the fold after his death (only Kingdom not to be conquered), Arya has transformed into a straight up killer after killing that one person in season 3, Sansa has gotten one of the biggest character developments of any character this season, got away from King's Landing and stopped being a crybaby all the while forming an alliance with Littlefinger (who actually saw this coming?).. Littlefinger has come out of the shadows to learn that he's the biggest player of the game being the reason the series started, and he kills Lysa after marrying her while simultaneously putting moves on Sansa and grooming Robin to be one of the 7 Kingdom Lords who will be under his command. Joffrey died, and Stannis stoped sulking like a bitch and looks to either be going to King's Landing or hitting up the Wall, Shae the whore turned on Tyrion, and Bron may have possibly also left him with him potentially losing all 3 of his circle as well as wife all in one season, Jon Snow started to become a man like Rob/his father, and we finally had an episode that Bran was interesting since the premiere episode of the season.

The only people in transition are Brianne and Pod which is fine as long as it's for one season and they meet one of the Starks.. eventually next season. The Hound/Arya is also in transition but we still got a lot of depth for her. As long as she's not walking around next season, I'm ok with it. The main issue is Danny being more boring than last season and getting more unlikable by the episode (for me), but at least we still got Sir Friendzone not even being a friend anymore, with his plot out in the open which is more interesting prospect that Danny's entire plot since S3E5. We still have two more episodes left, 20% left after all of this.

I understand not liking it, but this season has had a lot of things happening and saying otherwise is pretty crazy to me. To me season 2 is by far the weakest IMO, but still pretty fantastic season nonetheless. Season 4 is shaping up to be the best one yet for me, which is saying something considering there's two episodes including episode 9 left. We usually get 3-4 really great episodes per season, but this year we've got 2 and 6, 7 & 8 so far for me. To each his own I suppose. ;)

I agree with everything you said here and a really well argued point. I do however have a question about the bolded. You still think Dorne will join the "fold" after all this?
 
I agree with everything you said here and a really well argued point. I do however have a question about the bolded. You still think Dorne will join the "fold" after all this?
I mean join the fold as in start to play a role into the storyline. Otherwise killing Oberyn served no purpose at all to the story and was done for "shock value!!1" by GRRIM, which doesn't seem like his style. Someone who did a youtube review mentioned that he knew Oberyn would die for the simple reason that it would give a perfect reason for his Kingdom to enter the storyline.. which makes sense in hindsight.

My guess is they are going to be coming after revenge 2.0, but maybe it will be something less lethal. I don't think you want someone like Oberyn coming to KL again if you are Cersei or Tywin for next season. He also told Cersei that one of his daughters has his sister's name which he fights a lot with. I can only hope that she is the female version of Oberyn in badass and comes to fuck shit up.
if this happens, please for the love of God, don't kill her GRRIM.

If they don't join the storyline and Oberyn dies for nothing, I am not going to be pleased.
 

Cyan

Banned
A confession that Tywin ordered The Mountain to rape and kill Oberyn's sister would've also been pretty effective at bringing Dorne onto the stage, I imagine. :p
 

Exokell

Banned
almost of the actors in game of thrones are having a shot on the big scree, I hope Pedro Pascal gets some of that attention. Great actor :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom