• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Game of Thrones *NO BOOK SPOILERS* |OT| Season 5 - Sundays on HBO [Read the OP]

Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TimeEffect

Member
Some of the stuff that bothered me:

-We don't see Stannis' army fight, yet despite being at the forefront and being swarmed, he somehow survives, and his army seemingly does a number on the enemy?

-Brien finds him somehow, and is able to do her duty, which just feels like way too much of a coincidence
 
S

Sajjaja

Member
Eyeh4wk said:
I found it really comical that; even though the Wall was brimming with people (the wildlings, Davos, Melisandre) whatshisface possy took the time to set up that little wooden sign and play that et tu Brute act on Jon, when he saw that sign I expected him to say "haha very funny guys, now where is my uncle ?" Just poison him, shank him in the shower or whatever. There is no need to be so elaborate.
Click to expand...

Wildlings aren't at the wall, they went inland. Melisandre and Davos probably sleeping cause their past year? has been all for nothing.
 
O

OpinionatedCyborg

Member
Eyeh4wk said:
I found it really comical that; even though the Wall was brimming with people (the wildlings, Davos, Melisandre) whatshisface possy took the time to set up that little wooden sign and play that et tu Brute act on Jon, when he saw that sign I expected him to say "haha very funny guys, now where is my uncle ?" Just poison him, shank him in the shower or whatever. There is no need to be so elaborate.
Click to expand...
the whole show is pretty goofy any time you stop to think about what's going on. it's a gory soap opera with beautiful locations and nudity.
 
Y

yoplay

Member
I avoided book spoilers throughout the shows run all this time only to have both the red wedding and jon's death spoiled by my brother. I swear mann. Im not even on social media to be dealing with this shit.

I must admit this season was a little sloppy at times. The pacing seemed off. It was rushed a lot towards the last few eps.
 
D

Dr.Acula

Banned
Ninja Scooter said:
if Melisandre could just resurrect on a whim like that why wouldn't she do Stannis?
Click to expand...

She fled the battlefield before Stannis was even killed. She's at Castle Black right now, and Jon is just lying the the courtyard. She could easily trip over him on one of her creepy night walks and be all "ooh, Kings blood!"

ntropy said:
Stannis appeared as if he was observing something or someone behind Brienne.
Notice anyone missing from the Winterfell "battle"? Roose Bolton. I think he thwarts Brienne from delivering the fatal blow.
Click to expand...

Maybe.

Stannis and Snow were both too big to kill off in the same ep. If they're dead we're down to the Boltons (not really now that Sansa has fled), Targaryans, and Lannisters (via Tommen) as serious players. Way too low.
 
J

JesseZao

Member
TimeEffect said:
Some of the stuff that bothered me:

-We don't see Stannis' army fight, yet despite being at the forefront and being swarmed, he somehow survives, and his army seemingly does a number on the enemy?

-Brien finds him somehow, and is able to do her duty, which just feels like way too much of a coincidence
Click to expand...

Welp. Episode Eight used up the rest of the season's budget.

tbh I didn't care. Would've wasted more time showing a meaningless battle.
 
E

eyeball_kid

Member
Fucking Ollie, that little prick killed Ygritte and Jon both. But I never expected the former commander would do something so low. Screw him and the rest of the Night's Watch. Good luck with the White Walkers without Jon, boys.

I knew that kiss was going to be poison, poor girl. But it's going to be war now. Cersei is going to see Dorne burned to the ground. And a war is going to make King's Landing easy pickings.
 
xaosslug

xaosslug

Member
TimeEffect said:
Some of the stuff that bothered me:

-We don't see Stannis' army fight, yet despite being at the forefront and being swarmed, he somehow survives, and his army seemingly does a number on the enemy?

-Brien finds him somehow, and is able to do her duty, which just feels like way too much of a coincidence
Click to expand...

she was probably watching the battle from somewhere the entire time, never taking her eyes off of Stannis.
 
H

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
What in the hell did I just watch?

eyeball_kid said:
Fuck Ollie, that little prick killed Ygritte and Jon both, and fuck Sam for putting the idea in his head each time. But I never expected the former commander would do something so low. Fuck that guy and the rest of the Night's Watch. They're the traitors. Good luck with the White Walkers without Jon, boys.

I knew that kiss was going to be poison, poor girl. But it's going to be war now. Cersei is going to see Dorne burned to the ground. And a war is going to make King's Landing easy pickings.
Click to expand...

With what army? Dragons couldn't bring these guys to bend the knee.
 
T

TimeEffect

Member
I will continue to believe that Jon Snow, Melisandre, and the Onion Knight are the heroes we deserve.

I have found myself not caring for Tyrion, and I sure as hell don't care for Dany

Also, why did the High Sparrow let Cersei go? I thought they were taking over?

Does the royalty/Lannister family not have any army? Are they literally surrounded by the peasants?
 
F

Ferrio

Banned
I'd honestly be pretty pissed if they hadn't shown melisandre showing up at castle black. There was NO reason for that scene other than letting the viewers go "oooh she can save him!", so I'm pretty confident Jon will be back. Also maybe in the process it'll shed light on his ancestry.
 
E

ErinIsADrunk

Member
For people who don't want to know the fate of Sansa and Theon's jump then you might want to steer clear of this week's inside the episode.

There appears to be somewhat of confirmation that
they survive the jump. as the producer refers to them finding the strength to keep on keeping on, which presumably would be the opposite of jumping to your death.

At least that is what I took from it.
 
T

TimeEffect

Member
JesseZao said:
Welp. Episode Eight used up the rest of the season's budget.

tbh I didn't care. Would've wasted more time showing a meaningless battle.
Click to expand...

It's not the battle itself. I dont mind it was cut. It's the fact that we very clearly see Stannis lead the charge, have his men leave, he is surrounded...

yet he's the only one alive in the end, and the rest of Ramsay's army is seemingly dead, save for Ramsay and a few guys, who are somewhere else?

Brien somehow finds him after all this, as if she knew he'd be the only one left. Made no sense, and just felt dumb.
 
Strangelove77

Strangelove77

Member
Did anyone else think, "hey, Drogon kind of has a bit of a personality now.
I think I like him a bit.
They're eventually totally going to kill him.
Goddamnit."
 
Lamel

Lamel

Banned
Ferrio said:
I'd honestly be pretty pissed if they hadn't shown melisandre showing up at castle black. There was NO reason for that scene other than letting the viewers go "oooh she can save him!", so I'm pretty confident Jon will be back. Also maybe in the process it'll shed light on his ancestry.
Click to expand...

I don't think it will be "oh she can save him" but more like "oh nice some kings blood, let me use it".
 
N

Nori Chan

Member
You telling me that wasn't the real actress of Cersei naked.


cause I've been waiting 5 long seasons for her to drop the clothes don't tell me everything was a lie
 
D

DrBo42

Member
Nori Chan said:
You telling me that wasn't the real actress of Cersei naked.


cause I've been waiting 5 long seasons for her to drop the clothes don't tell me everything was a lie
Click to expand...

Uh... Dude that was her face match-moved onto someone else's body. It looked terrible and was incredibly obvious. Not her.
 
E

EroticSushi

Member
DrBo42 said:
There is literally 0 way they don't bring Jon back. His death serves no purpose.
Click to expand...
This is honestly a show that kills characters off while serving no purpose. I'm pretty sure they'll bring Jon back to life but it's a tough call given how this show goes on about killing people you care about for no reason.
 
Deviousx

Deviousx

Member
Ferrio said:
Most of us weren't looking at the face.
Click to expand...

hhh.png
 
D

DrBo42

Member
Ferrio said:
Most of us weren't looking at the face.
Click to expand...

Then you dun fuckin' goofed. That shit was obvious even from the cell, completely different person.

Sentient said:
This is honestly a show that kills characters off while serving no purpose. I'm pretty sure they'll bring Jon back to life but it's a tough call given how this show goes on about killing people you care about for no reason.
Click to expand...

Cite an example. Red Wedding had massive purpose. I can't honestly think of a death that had no purpose.
 
F

Ferrio

Banned
DrBo42 said:
Cite an example. Red Wedding had massive purpose. I can't honestly think of a death that had no purpose.
Click to expand...

His death could be Red woman getting Jon's blood but not rezzing him. But honestly, I don't see that happening since I think she'd want the one with such powerful blood alive.
 
D

Das Ace

Member
Sentient said:
This is honestly a show that kills characters off while serving no purpose. I'm pretty sure they'll bring Jon back to life but it's a tough call given how this show goes on about killing people you care about for no reason.
Click to expand...

It really isn't though? There hasn't been a major character death (barring any that happened tonight) that happened for no reason. Cut Jon from the whole story and the wall is in the same spot it is now, with any character development effectively being a waste of time. Cut Rob and the show's plot is quite different. See the difference?

Game of Thrones for all it's pretenses is still a fairy tail, and Jon leaving the show here is bad storytelling.
 
G

GoodMorningPluto

Member
All them cuts and shameless cliffhangers...
Now what will happen to the Wall storyline? Outside of Jon's probable resurrection there is like nothing going on and no one to watch for.
 
S

STILLethal

Member
Ghost didnt show because he knows deep down that Jon didnt really die completely and will get resurrected



Theres just too many things when considered that point to him being resurrected
 
D

Dr.Acula

Banned
The Cersei thing is so stupid. If the actress doesn't do nudity, just shoot around it. Doing a weird CGI thing isn't ever a good compromise. They could have shot around it like they shot around the fucking battle of Winterfell.

I'm interested in what's up with Arya now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

K-Drama |OT| A Swoonworthy Community
32
2K
John Marston replied
HBO submits GoT finale, "The Iron Throne", for Best Writing at Emmys 2019
43
3K
ZehDon replied
The 2019 Emmy Award Winners - Suck it Game of Thrones
17
2K
andreymagnus replied
HBO Max going all Out - Green Lantern & Adam Strange Shows, new Dune Show, Animated Gremlins, Boondocks revival, Anime, SouthPark, Lovecraft Show etc
News
19
2K
DeafTourette replied
Disney reveals the next Star Wars film is from Game of Thrones creators
2
68
4K
MB1 replied
Top Bottom