Soo..... yeah. Nearing the end of Chapter 2. Huge Gears fan here. I always go in to these games blind -- not reading reviews, impressions, or watching gameplay videos.
Bottom line? I like it, but so far, I don't love it.
VERY minor story/character SPOILERS FOLLOW. As I Said, I'm only on chapter 2.
Am I playing a Gears Of War game, or fucking Binary Domain: Gears Edition? The "deebs" are okay to fight but it's getting really redundant now. Waves and waves of these assholes. Where is the gore? Where is the atmosphere? Where are the executions that in past GEARS games made me stand up and cheer? Where is the hilarious banter between characters? Where is the shit talking towards the enemies ("bring it, asshole!", "that all you got!?"). Where are the new super-fidelity chainsaw executions? Shit looks good, but I'm not really impressed.
I don't particularly like the new characters, and Oscar wasn't charming, he was an obnoxious D-bag. I do like JD's voice acting but as a character he seems wimpy. The only time this game has really felt like Gears to me was when Marcus showed up and chainsawed the fuck out of that annoying female robot with the glasses.
High points? Gunplay is as good as ever. Game looks great, graphically. I dunno bro's. I really want to love this game but so far I'm just not feeling it. It's a Gears game without the Gears soul, so far.