MoonsaultSlayer
Member
You have a great point regarding the behind the scenes controversy and drama.The role was also originally meant for Eddie Murphy, who did Beverly Hills Cop instead. So they just replaced him with another black guy, who ended up not having anything to do in the movie. I've said it before, but Ghostbusters isn't a movie about 4 guys hunting ghosts - it's a movie about 3 guys hunting ghosts. Hudson's account of that period is very sad, as his role in the script kept diminishing and diminishing until he was hardly there, and he wasn't even on the original poster, and he was often completely ignored in other promotions as well. His role was meant to be much bigger, and the fact that he was the only black guy on the team makes it very uncomfortable.
People who are now claiming that his role was important because he was the straight man/regular joe are missing the point - he was hardly in the movie (and not much of a character because of it) because he wasn't a famous white comedian, and because he wasn't Eddie Murphy either. Both Hudson and Aykroyd have talked about this numerous times and admitted that it was a huge mistake. People shouldn't forget that leading black parts were impossible to get in those days (even moreso than now) unless you were one of the chosen few, like Murphy. Ignoring that is ignoring an important - if uncomfortable - part of hollywood history. In comparison Leslie Jones is way better off in the new movie - she gets to be just as much of an oddball and just as crazy as the other comedians, and is actually just as much a part of the team as the rest. She was my and my girlfriends favorite Ghostbuster in the movie, after McKinnon (who steals the show the entire time).
But what actually makes Ghostbusters so charming comes from what we got not what could have been.
I don't care that it doesn't have Belushi, Candy or Murphy because I'm not even sure those factors would make it a better movie. Would it have been marketed the same way? Would I have seen it and crave it as much? I have no idea.
I can say this, though: If Zeddemore was a military expert instead of the everyman, I'm not sure I'm as interested in A) the film, B) his character.
Coming into the job at ground level, getting a lesson on the containment unit (setting it up for the audience), offering a biblical explanation to the madness (for that kind of audience), leveling with the city officials when they find it hard to trust a few loonies with nuclear backpacks and punctuating the finale with an exclamation that could only be impactful coming from an everyman/someone on our level... They were all very important scenes as is if you ask me.