I tend to see more hyperbole from the critics. There are definite issues with the game, but saying how this game is an affront to the series, or how it's not a God of War game is silly. I also think its a result of having expectations out of check. Returning to an intimate story with smaller (but in my opinion, better) boss battles is poison to people who only care about scale.
Just beat it, and I can see where some of the complaints come from, mainly because 3 is one of the best of the generation.
I have mixed feeling about combat, really didn't like how magic was locked behind 4 levels for the other weapons. That, along with some added "vulnerability" (wall bounce, additional stagger, etc) made it less enjoyable for me. However, I did like the subweapons, the "doppleganger" move was really useful.
Some weird audio cutouts too, and sometimes the camera would pull back way too far--at times it was hard to tell where I was. Didn't have that problem in 3.
Overall, this is good, but just different, once you can get past not quite playing it like 3, its fine. The environments and graphics were unreal--I really enjoyed the Sub-boss mini-games, as a twist on QTEs.
I honestly am ready for someone new now. Bring on Persia.
For the Trials, I agree with using Ares + Time--the first wave was actually the trickiest for me.
For Stage 2, throw the Harpies out towards the screen, instant KO. The Talos, just take your time and use the Eye Attack to knock him back.
For Stage 3, Hold Block until the centaur charges, win QTE, extra 2 hits, roll towards the center, block, rinse repeat. For the others, time and shadow and take your time.
I passed the whole thing in one try, just take your time and block.
And the last boss fight was really easy.
I just played God of War 3 on Titan. Nothing took that long.
By the way, is there a checkpoint in between the trials or is all in one go kind of thing? I remember God of War 3 had a trials portion but you got a checkpoint in between waves
Agree with this--I have the plat for 3, the enemies in this one are sponges.
I thought it was to emphasize Kratos being less powerful, and the need to fight with more tactics...I'm fine with that in theory, but it was a little extreme. Especially towards the end when they throw some crazy combinations at you.