First impressions crosspost-
Shatter: Played it twice, once on CTF once on Extraction. I really could not get a feel for the layout of the map, there were many paths that felt like they didn't go where you expected to and it was hard to navigate. The bases felt very slapped together and the encounters weren't that fun. As of now, Im leaning towards meh on that one, it just feels like it was thrown together.. Maybe as I get to know it more I will enjoy it, but comparing it to something big like Vortex it just didn't click like that map did. Artistically it basically looks like Vortex with some cool crystals here and there, but its kinda blah.. especially the shitty skybox.
Harvest: Its ok I guess. Base design was boring but serviceable, it kinda reminded me of a Halo Reach forge map or something. The encounters were alright at best, I think the most fun I had on it was hitting the Warthog jump rocks..those things give some air. Bland as hell artistically, but it does have a purtty skybox that is admitably lower res than ideal, but not nearly as bad as Shatter.
Wreckage: I played it both on CTF and KOTH, and had a blast both times. This map really reminds me of a larger, spiritual successor to Burial Mounds... I mean, its a ton different, but there are some things that call back to it. I love the sight-lines, encounters and map control points. I would say this map is one of the better maps in Halo 4, and it fills a unique space unlike the other DLC maps. Visually it may look bad in screens and videos, but it actually doesn't look so bad in person, in fact it looks a like a living wasteland and I really like that.. the wreckage sights could have used a bit more color and flair, but otherwise this map is definitely not a visual eyesore like the others. I can't wait to play this map some more.
---
So far this map pack is a letdown, but Wreckage is blast to play on so I don't regret it.. the other maps are OK at best, and I really hope its the last time we see maps that boring for DLC.
I would be happy with this. I feel like my map pass purchase was a waste. I bought it thinking I would save money. throw us a bone 343. This is my first time buying a season pass. And what do we have here all day free crimson maps...damn.
Agreed, I really hope they not only acknowledge this, but make steps to right things from here on out. Halo 4 has been a bit of a clusterfuck when it comes to PR, etc, and while I am a fan of the game I also think 343 has a lot to do.