• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Hostage situation at a church near Rouen in northern France (Update: it's over)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Boem

Member
That's a myth created by people who want to feel good thinking by saying Daesh they are helping to defeat them.

It's not a myth, it's actually true. Not the second part of your sentence of course, that's just you being flippant. But the fact that Isis violently punishes those who use the term Daesh is true, as they themselves have confirmed many times.
 
It's not a myth, it's actually true. Not the second part of your sentence of course, that's just you being flippant. But the fact that Isis violently punishes those who use the term Daesh is true, as they themselves have confirmed many times.

Can you post some of these confirmations ?
 

Bedlam

Member
Par for the course in EU threads dealing with "immigrants and refugees" (which are never the white ones). So much nationalism and racism thrown around as if their countries will die if they let any more middle eastern people in (but Canadian and US and Australian are totally fine though!)

Some of the richest countries in the world with hundreds of years of law and culture and they can't even handle being exposed to something Iraq and Afghanistan have endured a million times more without "wishing for trump in Europe"
edit: I think I misread the bolded part.

Wishing for European Trump is mind-boggingly short-sighted and crazy dangerous, of course. A populist like him would almost surely start an all-out war with "Islam" (yes, saying "Islam" is dumb in this context but that's exactly how I mean it ... a populist such as Trump thinks that simple).

She is something much worse, she is an opportunist without any values and her only interest is to win elections.
Blaming Merkel for not having any values ... that's rich.

The lack of reason, common sense and knowledge in this thread is staggering.
 
Cool. And people think that the earth is flat. And now?

I am astonished that people refuse to acknowledge the move to the left in soical policiy the CDU has made under Merkel and try to handwave it away.
If the AfD wasn't a bunch of nutjobs that moved towards extremist nonsense, they would be the 2nd strongest party easily IMO.
 
The right and left are as bad as each other. They should both come together and responsibly solve the CLEAR migrant issue for the good of Europe.

Will never happen though. Government and the media are a joke. According to them, this post would probably be considered racist or xenophobic.
 

PJV3

Member
Getting a bit sick of Europe threads where every act of terror is turned into party political bullshit.

The people responsible are the ones carrying out or instigating the attacks.
 

GAMEPROFF

Banned
I am astonished that people refuse to acknowledge the move to the left in soical policiy the CDU has made under Merkel and try to handwave it away.
If the AfD wasn't a bunch of nutjobs that moved towards extremist nonsense, they would be the 2nd strongest party easily IMO.

There is a thing between moving from the right (where the CDU definitly was, but attentions, there is again a difference between the right and the far right) to the center and beeing center left.

I guess this is the moment to leave this thread. Bye.
Good idea.
 
The right and left are as bad as each other. They should both come together and responsibly solve the CLEAR migrant issue for the good of Europe.

Will never happen though. Government and the media are a joke. According to them, this post would probably be considered racist or xenophobic.

That was perhaps true a few years ago. Now though? Nope.
 

lenos16

Member
What voters think =/=reality

Yes because voter perception doesn't matter right? The AfD defines themselves as a rightwing conservative party, but in reality they are viewed as the new Nazi scum by the general populace not too dissimilar to the NDP. CDU under Merkel has shifted a lot to the left alienating a portion of their old voter base, the only center right party I can think of in Germany is the CSU.
 

Maedre

Banned
Yes because voter perception doesn't matter right? The AfD defines themselves as a rightwing conservative party, but in reality they are viewed as the new Nazi scum by the general populace not too dissimilar to the NDP. CDU under Merkel has shifted a lot to the left alienating a portion of their old voter base, the only center right party I can think of in Germany is the CSU.

And that are the key words ;)
 

KingSnake

The Birthday Skeleton
Yes because voter perception doesn't matter right?

Economic policies promoted by Merkel both internal and in the EU are anything but centre-left. Calling Merkel leftist is as stupid as it can get.
Maybe Merkel promoted some left policies in Germany that I'm not aware of. Can you name a few?
 
Confirmations in the article: 0


Not saying it is true or not, but the article does not contain what the poster you quoted was asking for.

You guys need actual footage from ISIS cutting off a tongue and explaining it to the camera or something? The source is "Evan Kohlmann, a national security analyst at Flashpoint and a contributor to NBC News".
 

Xando

Member
Wait are you really saying that voter perception doesn't matter?

If voter perception would be relevant we would have kicked Greece out of the EU last year, would have send weapons to ukraine while lifting sanctions on russia and left the euro.

The common european working class has shown multiple times in the last 100 years it is not to be trusted with political decision other than voting every 4 years because they can't distinct between actually policy and populism
 

ElTorro

I wanted to dominate the living room. Then I took an ESRAM in the knee.
The CDU has moved "the the left" on social issues; meaning, they have become more socially liberal, which is a good thing in my book. In addition to its anti-immigration/anti-EU positions, the AfD is running on a platform of social conservatism in regards to all the usual issues like "family values", LGBT rights, schooling, religion, climate change, etc. In that regard, it is comparable to where the CDU has been some 20-30 years ago.

That might appeal to social conservatives who feel unrepresented, while other AfD supporters probably have never read the its program and are only aware of the anti-immigration/anti-EU rhetoric.
 

Fantastapotamus

Wrong about commas, wrong about everything
Confirmations in the article: 0


Not saying it is true or not, but the article does not contain what the poster you quoted was asking for.

What is a "confirmation" for you then? ISIS leaders going around confirming that they hate that word?
 

patapuf

Member
Solutions that actually work to solve "the immigration problem" take time and money.

Putting up walls and not letting anyone in won't solve the much bigger issues already festering at home, neither will giving up civil rights for higher surveilance.
 

Chuckie

Member
You guys need actual footage from ISIS cutting off a tongue and explaining it to the camera or something? The source is "Evan Kohlmann, a national security analyst at Flashpoint and a contributor to NBC News".

First of all I wouldn't want to see that at all.
However the person you quoted wanted a confirmation that ISIS actually punishes people who use the term. As a reaction you post an article which only says two things:

Kohlmann said:
"It's a derogatory term and not someting people should use even if you dislike them,

NBC said:
ISIS has reportedly threatened to 'cut out the tongues' of anyone it hears using the term

These to me are by no means confirmations whatsoever. And that was what the Gaffer was asking for.

What is a "confirmation" for you then? ISIS leaders going around confirming that they hate that word?


Well they issue a fucking magazine, so yeah that could be something. Some of you seem to have forget the original post:
But the fact that Isis violently punishes those who use the term Daesh is true, as they themselves have confirmed many times.


Anyway like I said, I don't know if it is true or false.... but 'reportedly threatens' =/= fact that has been confirmed by ISIS many times
 

lenos16

Member
If voter perception would be relevant we would have kicked Greece out of the EU last year, would have send weapons to ukraine while lifting sanctions on russia and left the euro.

The common european working class has shown multiple times in the last 100 years it is not to be trusted with political decision other than voting every 4 years because they can't distinct between actually policy and populism

Yes and all this happened before the current election cycle. How is the current trend in Europe again? Oh look there is a rise of far right political parties because part of the voter base felt alienated. Voter reception matter a lot, even if they only vote every 4 years.
And even regarding your issues, the popular opinion on Greece and Ukraine were very divided even amongst the voter base.
 
Anyway like I said, I don't know if it is true or false.... but 'reportedly threatens' =/= fact that has been confirmed by ISIS many times

There are enough sources to make it plausible people are punished for using the acronym as not using the full name shows a lack of respect.

But that does not mean someone shouting DAESH instead of ad-Dawla al-Islāmiyya fi al-'Irāq wa-sh-Shām while beheading a priest is not an ISIS inspired islamist.
 

Nicktendo86

Member
I'm reading reports that at least one of the attackers was known to the authorities and was on a terrorist watch list as he had been arrested for trying to get to Syria.

No links as it's just twitter so might be bollocks
 

Xando

Member
Yes and all this happened before the current election cycle. How is the current trend in Europe again? Oh look there is a rise of far right political parties because part of the voter base felt alienated. Voter reception matter a lot, even if they only vote every 4 years.
And even regarding your issues, the popular opinion on Greece and Ukraine were very divided even amongst the voter base.

The greek crisis was last year when a majority of germans wanted to kick them out. You talk like the far right is even close to somehow win a majority. In reality Afd lost some 5% in polls over the last 3 months.

You talk about the rise of the far right but claim the CDU is now a center left party which would mean german parlament would consist of 80-90% of leftist parties if there were votes today.

I'm reading reports that at least one of the attackers was known to the authorities and was on a terrorist watch list as he had been arrested for trying to get to Syria.

No links as it's just twitter so might be bollocks

If true what we need is not more surveilance but to keep these people who want to go to syria (or were there) in prison instead of letting them run around and commit crimes
 

KingSnake

The Birthday Skeleton
Did Hollande said something about "even troops on the ground" regarding stopping ISIS or it was a mistranslation on Euronews?
 

Nicktendo86

Member
So a Catholic priest brutally murdered in a Catholic church by people aligned to IS.

Have had the feeling that anger is really taking hold after Nice, this will surely only make that anger even more apparent. Pretty telling that Hollande made his way to the scene very quickly, people will take out that anger at the ballot box in April.
 
Well they issue a fucking magazine, so yeah that could be something.

Sorry that I don't have a subscription to Dabiq so that I can scan an issue for you. Jesus.

There are enough sources to make it plausible people are punished for using the acronym as not using the full name shows a lack of respect.

But that does not mean someone shouting DAESH instead of ad-Dawla al-Islāmiyya fi al-'Irāq wa-sh-Shām while beheading a priest is not an ISIS inspired islamist.

No one ever said these guys were not Isis inspired. There is, however, a lot of irony in Isis praising as heroes people they would kill or maim on their controlled territory.
 
Fucking unbelieveable...it's every goddamn day now. What the hell sparked all this? Because the amount of attacks in such short notice stack up in an insane way now. Before Nice it had been pretty quiet since Brussels, right?

And this stuff keeps happening in either France or Germany and once in Belgium. I hope to god The Netherlands stays out of this but i bet it's only a matter of time now. Goddamn man.
 
I'm reading reports that at least one of the attackers was known to the authorities and was on a terrorist watch list as he had been arrested for trying to get to Syria.

No links as it's just twitter so might be bollocks
This does seem to be a recurring problem. Weren't those people doing killings last week in Germany also already known by police?

You can't lock up people without reason, but it seems an awful lot of people are on the polices radar and running around free.
 

Cub3h

Banned
Well I'm absolutely stunned.

I think we'll never be able to untangle their motives..

RIP to the priest and any family / friends affected by this. Sadly this seems to be the new normal. I am fully convinced that these attacks are leading to a much higher likelyhood of a Trump presidency, so hopefully France actually cracks down on these extremists.
 
Absolutely terrible.

Something needs to be stepped up to try and stop this.

If this is another instance of the murderers being "known to police" then questions need to be asked.
 

Nicktendo86

Member
This does seem to be a recurring problem. Weren't those people doing killings last week in Germany also already known by police?

You can't lock up people without reason, but it seems an awful lot of people are on the polices radar and running around free.

I think those in Germany were known for relatively petty crimes, but I could be wrong about that.

Being on a terror watch list is a whole different story though, if true this is scandalous.
 

Cub3h

Banned
I think those in Germany were known for relatively petty crimes, but I could be wrong about that.

Being on a terror watch list is a whole different story though, if true this is scandalous.

What could you possibly do though? Set up a new French Guantanamo style prison? I don't see any ways of keeping these potential extremists at bay.
 

lenos16

Member
The greek crisis was last year when a majority of germans wanted to kick them out. You talk like the far right is even close to somehow win a majority. In reality Afd lost some 5% in polls over the last 3 months.

You talk about the rise of the far right but claim the CDU is now a center left party which would mean german parliament would consist of 80-90% of leftist parties if there were votes today.
No I talk like as if the far right is gaining more support, which is fact. Sure the AfD lost 5% in the last few months due to Brexit, but there is no telling if it's only a short term setback or if the voter opinion is going to stick.
 
Being on a terror watch list is a whole different story though, if true this is scandalous.

There are thousands of people on the watchlist, way too much to keep under surveillance. If they buy tickets to the Middle East or try to buy a ton of fertilizer an alert will be triggered but they can pretty much move around freely.
 
Just clicked on the AFP twitter and saw:

AFP news agency ‏@AFP 42s43 seconds ago
#BREAKING Shots fired at Berlin hospital: police
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom