since here's more of a discussion board thing than discord: i dont like having a constant stream of gated shit coming my way that have a big sign that says HERES SOME GOODIES THAT YOU CANT ACCESS YET, and when you actually get access to it it's randomized so you might get disappointed anyways. you're just injected this feeling of "i'm missing out on something". even if it's all attainable for free, you don't have any guarantees that they won't balance the drops around making you buy keys aside from trust on riot (which imo they have mostly earned, if we forget about chromas)
not to mention wonky things like basing a system on post-game mastery grades which are often very skewed towards certain roles (junglers get fucked like every game) or just dumb (you get an A for going 3 0 9 or something). i get the feeling since it's randomized it won't be abused but that's also something to think about, for rito at least
i bet it's nice for new players and it's louder and shinier than just making a better economy and adjusting prices/ip gains or introducing some sort of ip/mastery points -> rp conversion, but i don't like obtuse systems that kind of feel like gambling
i was mostly ok with mystery chests because they were time limited and mostly gift only. yeah you could cheat and gift yourself with a smurf account but even then there was a buying limit so you wouldn't be super dumb and waste all your money like that (and most likely to fight ppl abusing gifting). i still didn't like it much but things like mystery gift trading and generally giving gifts is nice and it's a positive thing to have so i gave it a pass
but this i just really don't like, it sounds like an overly complicated thing. wanna help new players? make champions cheaper, give them more free ip boosts, give them free rentals, whatever. want to reward long time players? just give them free skin/champion vouchers
might be less fancy but whatever, i actually liked that about riot, no shitty chests, no palette swaps and if you wanted to buy overpriced virtual vanity shit, then you're gonna get like the very best overpriced virtual vanity shit there is.
will wait until there's more info to say if i 100% hate it, specially since i think there's some stuff like making it a limited number of chests (which is both to stop the grind but also to limit the amount of free shit you can get) and being able to reroll the shit that you don't like that i think is pretty ok, but these things make me feel like i wish there was an option to opt out entirely
not everything has to be gamified
edit: btw keys are also sold so they're also inserting (more) gambling into the game