London 2012 Summer Olympics |OT2|

Status
Not open for further replies.
Determining "greatest Olympian ever" purely by medal count is a stupid concept anyway.

Not all Olympians can compete in a dozen different medal events in a single Olympics like swimmers can.
 
Honestly dude probably doesn't have much else left to accomplish. And I agree with the quoted, ESPN loves to tear down an icon or rather "what is wrong with so and so?"

They do with Tiger every fucking time e lsoes and then hops back on his pipe wen he wins ("is tiger back yo?"), and They did it with LeBron last season.

When you it star status, they basically make sure that you are always a source for a story...good or bad. They don't care.

Comes with the territory.

Personally, I have no beef with Phelps. He's proven himself enough.

The people you all keep mentioning have legitimate reasons to be torn down: phelps/work ethic and weed, tiger/cheating and his game falling off a cliff, lebron/the decision and declaration of seven championships then losing to Dallas while playing like shit.

To not call those people out on that and discuss it would be the disservice, not looking past it.

Yet many athletes, if not most, never get anything but praise from the media their entire careers. Guys like Tom Brady and Peyton manning might get knocked occasionally but overall have never been outcasted. Countless Olympians are the same. Basketball players like CP3 and Durant I can't remember ever being piled on to.

You all make it seem like its an inevitability if youre a star and i disagree. The media is shitty but it's not some monolithic entity that follows a set pattern through all players careers.
 
The people you all keep mentioning have legitimate reasons to be torn down: phelps/work ethic and weed, tiger/cheating and his game falling off a cliff, lebron/the decision and declaration of seven championships then losing to Dallas while playing like shit.

To not call those people out on that and discuss it would be the disservice, not looking past it.

Yet many athletes, if not most, never get anything but praise from the media their entire careers. Guys like Tom Brady and Peyton manning might get knocked occasionally but overall have never been outcasted. Countless Olympians are the same. Basketball players like CP3 and Durant I can't remember ever being piled on to.

You all make it seem like its an inevitability if youre a star and i disagree. The media is shitty but it's not some monolithic entity that follows a set pattern through all players careers.

And the media is really forgiving to a lot of athletes. Ali was not the nicest guy but the media loves him and then you got MJ who by all accounts, is an asshole, but people love him.
 
I can't get behind syncro diving. I just don't get the point. It seems like a sport for all of the divers who aren't good enough to win in singles diving. Get rid of it.
 
Determining "greatest Olympian ever" purely by medal count is a stupid concept anyway.

Not all Olympians can compete in a dozen different medal events in a single Olympics like swimmers can.

True. There are many ways of looking at things. Phelps may not be the best ever, but he's certainly among the best. Kim Rhode is among the best too. She won a medal 5 olympics in a row. First time that's been done. Of course you could argue age is less of a factor for marksmanship contests. Just like you could argue swimmers and runners have more chances to medal than most other athletes.
 
Yeah I disagree. He put himself in the garbage stage by his poor work ethic and controversies.

There are countless athletes who have remained beloved by the media their entire careers and even post careers. Especially Olympians.

Exactly, all this stuff about "Oh people are just hatin' on Phelps now like Kobe and the media needs a 'fallen' hero to tear into, you don't like him because of personality when you should be focusing on his talent as an athlete" is pure nonsense and a load of strawmen. Maybe if he was a bit more enthusiastic and not a bit bored with things he would've snagged even more gold. In this case his attitude was a reflection of his performance as an athlete. Lochte has stupid gimmicks like his grills/biting the medals but his attitude and appetite for what he does is infectious.
 
One reason why I love the Olympics is that it gets me hyped up for sports I would never watch. Been watching synchronized diving and I'm amazed at the Chinese divers. Their dives seem so perfect.
 
Determining "greatest Olympian ever" purely by medal count is a stupid concept anyway.

Not all Olympians can compete in a dozen different medal events in a single Olympics like swimmers can.

I was thinking the exact same thing earlier today.

I'm not questioning his ability, but there aren't 6 shooting events or 7 tennis events etc etc.
 
The people you all keep mentioning have legitimate reasons to be torn down: phelps/work ethic and weed, tiger/cheating and his game falling off a cliff, lebron/the decision and declaration of seven championships then losing to Dallas while playing like shit.

To not call those people out on that and discuss it would be the disservice, not looking past it.

Yet many athletes, if not most, never get anything but praise from the media their entire careers. Guys like Tom Brady and Peyton manning might get knocked occasionally but overall have never been outcasted. Countless Olympians are the same. Basketball players like CP3 and Durant I can't remember ever being piled on to.

You all make it seem like its an inevitability if youre a star and i disagree. The media is shitty but it's not some monolithic entity that follows a set pattern through all players careers.

Except Phelps isn't gonna be forgotten either. He's gonna be loved for a while too(unless he fucks up big time).

Smoking some tree isn't that big of a deal, IMO...and the whole work ethic thing is lol IMO. If he's not even trying then that's some impressive ass shit to still be in the running for medals.

Phelps is on his Snoop Dogg/Lion mode now....Doesn't have to make a good record (or win gold in Phelps case) again.


That shits gravy.


Exactly, all this stuff about "Oh people are just hatin' on Phelps now like Kobe and the media needs a 'fallen' hero to tear into, you don't like him because of personality when you should be focusing on his talent as an athlete" is pure nonsense and a load of strawmen. Maybe if he was a bit more enthusiastic and not a bit bored with things he would've snagged even more gold. In this case his attitude was a reflection of his performance as an athlete. Lochte has stupid gimmicks like his grills/biting the medals but his attitude and appetite for what he does is infectious.


who cares if he has the personality of a rock. Dude's got records, he was a straight monster in the last two Olympics, anybody who thinks he is a bum is a moron anyway.
 
And the media is really forgiving to a lot of athletes. Ali was not the nicest guy but the media loves him and then you got MJ who by all accounts, is an asshole, but people love him.

They both had the benefit of not playing when the media was at the frenzy that it is now. No one is going to attack Ali given the shape that he's in and MJ's career is long over. So they'll just praise him for being the best basketball player ever. The venom is saved for current athletes. All those secrets that were easy to keep under wraps in the past (infidelity, gambling problems etc) will quickly be exposed by the current media.
 
I really have not heard Phelps being called Greatest Olympian of all time, I defintely heard one of the greatest swimmers many times being said also people adding if not the greatest swimmer or one of the greatest Olympians of all time. Many regard Carl Lewis as a more impressive American Olympian, could have sworn something voted him athlete of century at one point.

Also Phelps isn't liked by alot of atheletes, but even one of the swimming analysts said he has improved on that, mentioning that he may not be a better swimmer at this Olympics but he is a better person. Supposedly he was real hard to get along with but now is more laid back.
 
I was thinking the exact same thing earlier today.

I'm not questioning his ability, but there aren't 6 shooting events or 7 tennis events etc etc.

And if you are in team sport, you may not even qualify if you are born in a lessor country.
 
Should skip the condoms and make some SUPER BABBIES.

Though there might be an issue as to which country gets to claim them in the case of cross border fuckage.
Annie Chandler, the girl Matt Grevers is engaged to, was 5th in the 100 breaststroke at US trials and Rebecca Soni and Ricky Berens have been dating for a while (he moved to train at her club), so there is hope (that America can stay ahead of China in swimming at least).

Edit: I'll be looking for these kids in Tokyo/Madrid/Istanbul 2020.
 
It's funny how each room has a box of condoms on there beds....Dat global melting pot.

darwin.jpg

"shhhh, they don't have to know"
 
Determining "greatest Olympian ever" purely by medal count is a stupid concept anyway.

Not all Olympians can compete in a dozen different medal events in a single Olympics like swimmers can.

and if they did I bet they wouldn't remain unbeaten for 12 years, break a world record in every event, win 8 gold medals in 8 days and/or win 19 medals overall.
 
There is really no point in calling someone the "Greatest Olympian" unless they actually compete across a broad range of Olympic disciplines. Since the path to gold (or any medal) is so different in all events, it kind of diminishes what other people are doing.

On another note, I tried to avoid seeing results for the events today but completely failed. Spoilers everywhere.
 
There is really no point in calling someone the "Greatest Olympian" unless they actually compete across a broad range of Olympic disciplines. Since the path to gold (or any medal) is so different in all events, it kind of diminishes what other people are doing.

a medal is a medal. It doesn't matter if you won it running the fastest or by jumping the highest.

Michael Phelps is the greatest Olympic athlete ever by any measure.
 
a medal is a medal. It doesn't matter if you won it running the fastest or by jumping the highest.

Michael Phelps is the greatest Olympic athlete ever by any measure.

Would he win gold and break records in track.
Same for Carl Lewis. Would he do the same in swimming.
Would either of them win in volleyball, table tennis, gymnastics...
How is he the greatest by every measure?

What you can say is he is at the top of swimming, but not greatest Olympian ever.
 
There is really no point in calling someone the "Greatest Olympian" unless they actually compete across a broad range of Olympic disciplines. Since the path to gold (or any medal) is so different in all events, it kind of diminishes what other people are doing.

I don't even really like after the decathon winner some label him greatest athlete in the world. But I guess that is one of the closest things you can argue, but imo when Jordan was at his peak I thought he was a better athlete than some past decathlon winners.
 
Would he win gold and break records in track.
Same for Carl Lewis. Would he do the same in swimming.
Would either of them win in volleyball, table tennis, gymnastics...
How is he the greatest by every measure?

What you can say is he is at the top of swimming, but not greatest Olympian ever.

no, you missed my point. A gold medal in swimming is equal to a gold medal in any other sport. You can't say he's not the best because somebody can beat him at volleyball, that's dumb.
 
I actually don't know the results of the events that are on the NBC broadcast tonight!

Sure hope the US women took care of business in gymnastics.
 
a medal is a medal. It doesn't matter if you won it running the fastest or by jumping the highest.

Michael Phelps is the greatest Olympic athlete ever by any measure.

I dunno, far from all athletes have the opportunity to win 7-8 medals in one olympic.
 
who cares if he has the personality of a rock. Dude's got records, he was a straight monster in the last two Olympics, anybody who thinks he is a bum is a moron anyway.

Reading comprehension fail. Nobody's disputing his records or that he is a great swimmer, as said before, it's HIS WORK ETHIC AND ARROGANT ATTITUDE TOWARD THE GAME WHICH MANY FEEL WAS REFLECTED A BIT IN HOW HE PERFORMED THIS YEAR He could act like a wacko for all I care if he'd just shown some more tenacity and enthusiasm for the competition this year he would've so much more fun to watch and maybe would've won even more. Instead it totally came across as "Welp, I hate the 400 but whatever I guess I'm here to mop up those last medals." But yes, please keep casting dispersions and calling others morons for not being as jazzed as you are for "the greatest Olympian of all time" who'd rather be on XBL or eating a hoagie.
 
That was the most perfect vault I have ever seen. I have heard about it throughout the day. but wow (and yes, prisoner of the moment, but goodness.)
 
...people dislike phelps or somethig? Why?
Anyone assuming he would repeat 2008 is loco

If Phelps doesn't have haters then he's doing something wrong.


Now how about this Ye Shiwen girl? Wtf kind of enigmatic PEDs are the Chinese doping their athletes with?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom