• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

LTTP: Spartacus (spoilers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Wvrs

Member
As in Starz', not Kubrick's.

I came across this show by chance, flicking mindlessly through Netflix turning up something worthwhile for perhaps the first time ever. I watched the first episode and was entertained enough to put on the next, at some point my housemate stumbled in and we were pretty much just scoffing at how over-the-top and ridiculous it was. Then episode four with the Pits hit, and suddenly they had me. I fell in love with the period, the characters, the fights, even the hammy dialogue. I'd not taken such guilty pleasure in a show since season one of Arrow. By the end of season one (and what an end, without question the most satisfying hour of television I've ever watched, almost an inverse red wedding) I was shouting and screaming at the TV.

I had doubts about going into later seasons without Andy Whitfield (something I was very sad to hear about, especially as I lost a close family member to cancer this year) as he'd been such a huge part of what I loved about the series, the energy and charisma he brought to the role fully encompassing the character he played. The prequel series was an enjoyable enough watch, but all I could think of was how much I didn't want to go any further and see the series flounder with a new lead.

I went into season three and thought my fears had been realised. I couldn't get behind Liam McIntyre as Spartacus at all for the first few episodes, and was about to give up when the episode with the Arena happened, and it pulled me back in. The rest of the season was decent enough, and I read good things about War of the Damned so went in looking forward to it.

Massive improvement. McIntyre grew into the role wonderfully, bringing his own great take on the character even though they were big shoes to fill. Crassus was a fantastic character, and a young Caesar was played well in a way where he meshed perfectly with the Spartacus world. I've never known too much about Ancient Rome beyond what I learned in school, so I'll say a nice side-effect of watching this is that I've been teaching myself more about it, reading books and listening to podcasts.

Anyway, I just finished the series finale and, although predictable, it still managed to pull at my heartstrings. Glad the show found its feet again, parts of the last season peaked higher than the highs of season one in my opinion. I read rumours of there being a Caesar spin-off but it's been years so I imagine it's dead in the water?

Jupiter's cock, I'm going to miss this show.
 

Serpico99

Member
giphy.gif


This had one of the most satisfying series finale for sure.
 

MikeDip

God bless all my old friends/And god bless me too, why pretend?
Seriously..

Gannicus???

You didn't mention the best character


Best show ever btw
 

Wvrs

Member
But I saw no opinion on crixus!!! What about the beloved gannicus. Glad you enjoyed it.

Never warmed too much to Gannicus, not sure why. Crixus was great from start to finish, can't believe I didn't mention him, though he had his better moments in season one, I preferred him in the pseudo-antagonist role to the underling one.
 

EloquentM

aka Mannny
Gannicus is life, gannicus is love

Edit: also, Lucy flawless. Man I miss Spartacus. Gonna maybe do a marathon on Monday.
 

RS4-

Member
Spartacus has got to be one of the best surprises in recent memory.

And og Naevia > Waller one.
 
Great show, nah that's not good enough. FANTASTIC SHOW

It does have some pacing issues at times and the fact the actor for the main character had to be replaced after the first season due to a terminal illness made for something of a rough transition [at least we got gannicus out of it]

I cannot think of a tv show with better melee combat

Series Finale was done perfectly considering what historically happened
 

Big-E

Member
Hasn't been replaced. Black Sails is the only thing that is somewhat close, but Spartacus is still in a league of its own.
 

Monocle

Member
Brilliant series. Quite uneven, but the insanely great first season (from episode 3 or 4 on), Blood and Sand, and similarly great prequel miniseries, Gods of the Arena, make up for the stumbles.

I was unable to see McIntyre as Spartacus at any point, so the series finale fell totally flat for me, but he certainly improved a great deal after his first season.

RIP Andy. :(
 

Beepos

Member
So much love for this series. I'm also very glad they didn't drag it out and ended it when they did, as it was a great ride.
 

Mathieran

Banned
Found it on Netflix like you, and it grew on me and my wife in a similar manner. We almost stopped watching but gave it one more episode when it drew us in. The first season was incredible and it remained pretty good for every season.

The ending was very depressing but epic.
 
This show is one of the most underrated series of all time. Sad it only lasted 4 seasons. Gods of the arena is the best season.
 

Watevaman

Member
Loved the first few seasons of this, but couldn't keep in without Andy. I might give it another try one day, but I'm actually happy leaving it where I did.
 

Biske

Member
One of the best shows ever.


Even with the loss of Whitfield (god damn I love him) it was great.


Only part that felt of was the Nevea casting. Was just... Off. Or maybe they went too much a badass route for her and I couldn't buy it
 
I'd not taken such guilty pleasure in a show since season one of Arrow. By the end of season one (and what an end, without question the most satisfying hour of television I've ever watched, almost an inverse red wedding) I was shouting and screaming at the TV.
Got so much of a kick watching this on Netflix. The second to the last episode of the first season ends with Spartacus screaming "Now, we kill them all!". Credits roll, skip to the season finale episode that opens with the black title screen: "KILL THEM ALL". Perfection :)

This show is fucking fantastic. Watched it all the way through three times already, each watch better than the last, and I'll easily do it again because it is just pure enjoyment throughout. The battles, the blood, the sex, the intrigues, their way of speaking, and all the bad guys you love to hate. Its pure id, but damn clever about it.

Batiatus is still one of my all time fav character
Oh hell yes. "That's how you send a dog to the afterlife!"
 
Crixus was a G but he became a whiny shit in the last season regarding Naevia. Still he came through in the clutch. And his final episode was beautiful :(

Batiatus and Ashur were the best villains of the show for sure. And Gannicus prolly my favorite gladiator.

that scene in the finale when Spartacus caught the sword....whoooooooooooooooo so good. .
 

Serpico99

Member
Sucks to hear people dropped off once Andy was replaced. S3 started off shaky but I think Liam really owned (not better but on par) the character in the finale season.

tumblr_mlmqts0hIW1qevo2jo1_250.gif

tumblr_mjtlw9EezK1qdrbono1_r2_500.gif


tumblr_ml6qkaGWJR1rmwim3o2_500.gif
 
Sucks to hear people dropped off once Andy was replaced. S3 started off shaky but I think Liam really owned (not better but on par) the character in the finale season.
Really didn't like his intro episode, and thought it was probably the only disappointing episode in the series. But by the time they stormed the Coliseum in Capua I was sold. He really did grow into the role and was unforgettable by the end.
 
Sucks to hear people dropped off once Andy was replaced. S3 started off shaky but I think Liam really owned (not better but on par) the character in the finale season.

I was one of those that dropped off after Whitfield's death but I will probably pick it back up. Is there any love for Varro? I thought he was pretty decent.
 

jett

D-Member
This show was great. It's one of the biggest reverses in quality I've seen on TV. The first couple of episodes are pretty bad, but then it somehow becomes fantastic, and it just never stops improving.

It's terrible that Andy died, but Liam did a reasonably good job and really made the role his own eventually. His Spartacus was actually kinda different, slightly more of a mythic, bigger than life character, he seemed more apart from the rest of his men than Andy was.

I was one of those that dropped off after Whitfield's death but I will probably pick it back up. Is there any love for Varro? I thought he was pretty decent.

I was really bummed out when Varro bought it. He was an excellent sidekick.
 
The first episode of new Spartacus is especially jarring because the transition from the season 1 finale feels unearned. I can't help but wonder what Andy would dealt with the commander Spartacus role but by the end I feel like Liam made at least part of the character his own

Also can't forget to mention this guy

dmT3lGy.jpg
 

KahooTs

Member
That sword reversal reversal. The shield jump. Yellow power ranger. Ilithyia faces.

I take offence to the comparison to Arrow.
 
Probably the best softcore porno that will ever be made.

OP, you watched the prequel season, right?

I also teared up during the credits, because of the homage to Andy.

The show was a fun, mindless ride and that's what it aimed to be. Well met.
 
As in Starz', not Kubrick's.

I came across this show by chance, flicking mindlessly through Netflix turning up something worthwhile for perhaps the first time ever. I watched the first episode and was entertained enough to put on the next, at some point my housemate stumbled in and we were pretty much just scoffing at how over-the-top and ridiculous it was. Then episode four with the Pits hit, and suddenly they had me. I fell in love with the period, the characters, the fights, even the hammy dialogue. I'd not taken such guilty pleasure in a show since season one of Arrow. By the end of season one (and what an end, without question the most satisfying hour of television I've ever watched, almost an inverse red wedding) I was shouting and screaming at the TV.
That mirrors my experience with the first season. First three episodes were like a low rent yet entertaining 300, then episode 4 hits and it comes in to its own. By the end of the season I was like "fuck yeah!". One of my favorite seasons of a show ever.
 

Eos

Member
Show started off really slow (episodes 1-4) but immediately picks up and becomes a joy to watch. Really miss the show... had some of the best plot twists that I've ever seen. Definitely will re-watch it in the near future.
 

-sdp

Member
Loved the first season and is easily the best. The prequel works to see some of our favorites before S1 and the less interesting parts are what helps save the second third season, not as good as the first but still nice. The third and fourth season have some great episodes but also some very weak ones and the story arcs go to strange places that don't fit or are just a bit boring. The finale wasn't as satisfying as I wanted and I knew the ending but I still hoped for something more, nonetheless I enjoyed the finale a lot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom